REASON, INSPIRATION, AND TRUE RELIGION

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 8, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 40.

Read the full edition

REASON, INSPIRATION, AND TRUE RELIGION.

The province of reason and inspiration in the work of genuine religion is well worth considering. The importance of the former is not always realized. When the prophet Isaiah was reproving the children of Israel for their sins and lack of religion, he said, “Come now, and let us reason together.” Isa. 1:18. It is the province of reason to weigh; to consider; to examine closely with the understanding; to draw conclusions from premises; to ascertain the value of proofs offered; to give the proper weight to facts and arguments presented, in order that conclusions consistent with truth may be attained, and error detected. The possession of the faculty of reason is one of the main features which distinguish a man from a brute. We would never for a moment think of addressing religious considerations to the animal creation. There have been some trained horses, dogs, and other animals which exhibited marked intelligence. But never was one heard of which could appreciate religious knowledge. They could not weigh such considerations. Appeals to them of this character would be utterly unavailing. But mankind can, by use of their reason when so disposed, understandingly consider such intelligence, and survey with interest eternal and spiritual themes. The prophet recognizes this fact, and appeals to the people to use their reason in viewing the considerations involved in their course of life. Man has an intellectual and spiritual nature. They should ever be mutually and closely interwoven, blended, and united in all religious experience. We are furnished with abundance of evidence that the intellect alone is insufficient to guide a man safely in obtaining the highest good. The moral and spiritual nature must be enlisted. When these are enlightened by the truths of inspiration and the Spirit of God, then a man can go safely and surely.
There are many men of intellect who are great rascals. The most selfish, unprincipled men are often shrewd, bright, and keen, intellectually. Satan himself is, doubtless, a being of vast intellect. But, on the other hand, we cannot ignore the intellect,—the reasoning power,—and rely upon the spiritual nature alone. It would be difficult to tell which course would result most deplorably, to ignore the reason or the spiritual nature. Both would result disastrously in the end. They are designed ever to be united, blended in their work. The skeptic, however, sees little use for the one; the fanatic, for the other. The vain reasonings of the one, and the lack of good sense of the other, only demonstrate the truthfulness of our position. Paul speaks on the one hand of the insufficiency of “worldly wisdom.” It is but “foolishness” with God, and wholly unable to find him out, grasp or comprehend his plans. On the other hand, he presents the folly of a “zeal of God, but not according to knowledge.” Neither will answer.
The religious nature of men has been terribly abused and outraged. We cannot question that every false religion has made use of the religious faculty as certainly as true religion has. Man uses his veneration as really when worshiping Jove or Baal as when worshiping Jehovah; when bowing before the virgin as when bowing before Christ. The faculty of religious belief or faith may be as truly called into requisition in behalf of Buddha as in behalf of Jesus; and the hope of attaining nirvana, i. e., absorption into the body of Deity, or extinction of being, may be as real as our blessed hope of everlasting bliss in the presence of God. And who can doubt that the conscience is greatly troubled at one’s sins when such acts of self-abnegation are performed as the Hindoos and others do, involving the greatest pain and the loss of life itself? When mothers give their children to the destructive embraces of Moloch or cast them into the Ganges, we cannot question the sincerity of their acts. Benevolence has been as fully exercised in behalf of idol shrines and grand cathedrals for popery as ever it has been for Christ. These faculties—reverence, faith, veneration, conscientiousness, and benevolence—are those we use in the service of God, and a mere glance convinces any one that their perverted use has been oftener displayed than their legitimate use. And an intensity of devotion has as often been shown in wrong directions as in right ones. The millions of lives of Mohammedans and Catholics sacrificed in the crusades over the possession of the holy sepulcher; the countless lives given in behalf of wars of persecution and to sustain slavery and other terrible evils; the sacrifices of ascetics, recluses, hermits, and monks, of all that we would call of value in life, to carry out their perverted views of religion; the compassing of sea and land by Jesuit priests and others, to sustain false systems of religion,—all are illustrations of an intense false devotion, and a misuse of the religious faculties.
Mohammedanism presents as many strange excesses in the name of religion and prostitutions of everything sensible, as any system of so-called Christianity. Its dervishes correspond in a measure to monkery in Catholicism. They have an immense influence with the masses, so great that even the Sultan himself can scarcely control them. The dancing and howling dervishes compose their greatest number. Persons perform the most menial and unpleasant offices for a period of years, in order to gain a membership among them. Their worship is an exhibition of the most astonishing fanaticism. In it is a mixture of dancing, whirling, shouting, and howling till they become frenzied and often insensible. Well-authenticated facts, stated by reliable travelers, seem too much for credence. One traveler says: “By looking at a stop-watch, I ascertained that they turned [around] sixty-four times a minute. After spinning around for about five minutes, at a signal from the high-priest both music and dancers suddenly stopped, but recommenced in a few seconds. The third time they kept it up for nine minutes and three-quarters. My brain was swimming, too, so much so that I could hardly count their evolutions. The fourth and last time they whirled for five minutes and three-quarters, thus making in all 1504 turns in twenty-three and one-half minutes.” (See McClintock and Strong, Art. “Dervishes.”)
The perversion of the religious faculties has been seen associated with Protestantism as truly as with other forms of religion; but not to the same degree, owing to the fact that it seeks to conform to reason and inspiration. In just the degree that it does this, is it saved from fanaticism. But there has been no lack of exhibitions of wild excitement, foolish zeal, and fanatical extremes manifested here and there, even in connection with movements mostly reasonable and genuine. In times of great religious interest, weak minds lose their balance, unless guarded by wise instruction, and a healthful, sensible influence is kept uppermost. In “revivals,” as they are called, where strong appeals are made to the feeling, there have been numerous instances of persons losing their minds, and even becoming permanently insane. Even in connection with the great advent movement a movement founded on Scripture, and taught by appeals to the understanding and judgment, some became unbalanced. Especially after the passing of the time, before the third angel’s message was preached, did persons become affected, more or less, with false ideas of the nature of true religion. Some taught that no work must be done. Some advocated that the sisters’ hair should be worn flowing down the back; others, that it should be cut off; and various silly and extravagant ideas were circulated. But the present truth concerning the last message corrected largely, at least, these follies, wherever it was received. It ever appeals to the Scriptures and the understanding. Hence fanaticism, which largely grows from feeling and excitement, has found little congenial soil in it.
What a strange scene the history of past ages has presented when we view the realm of religious thought!—what vagaries, what extremes, what follies, what crimes, what perversions of all true religion! Verily, an enemy hath done this. Satan has stepped into this field, and made terrible havoc. But God has ever had a truth in the world,—pure, lovely, reasonable, elevating, benevolent, sensible, in harmony with the highest reason. The inspired word presents the light of truth, to invigorate the understanding and correct its waywardness. Yet even in this realm the reason must have place. An idiot cannot be benefited even by inspiration, and a fanatic will claim to be taking the word for his guide, and deceive other enthusiasts by his cranky notions of the Scripture itself. We must use common sense in religious things as well as in other things, or we are liable to go astray. When the Lord says, “Come now, and let us reason together,” he would have us use our reason in religious things most certainly. Reason and inspiration must be interdependent. When true prophets spoke, there must have been a difference between their appearance, their sentiments, their course of action, etc., and the statements and actions of false prophets. Our Saviour says: “Beware of false prophets. . . . Ye shall know them by their fruits.” Here the reason must be called into play, to weigh and thoroughly consider the nature and character of those fruits and the evidence of genuineness, in order to arrive at just conclusions. But when the evidence is convincing, that God is speaking through the prophet, then the reason must accept the light imparted as a guidance to duty.
The Scriptures have been thoroughly proved for past ages as well as by present experience, to be genuine revelations from God. When we can be certain that we have their true meaning, they must be regarded as authoritative. But reason is constantly necessary in their study and investigation, in order to arrive at their real meaning, lest we take foolish and false views of their teachings. The instruction they give, and the blessing of the Holy Spirit which inspired them, also resting upon us, enlarges, purifies, strengthens, and spiritualizes the understanding, and thus prepares us to drink deeper and deeper draughts of true spiritual experience; to know more and more of God, and be more and more conformable to Christ. May we all thus grow in grace and in the knowledge of the truth.
G. I. B.