It may perhaps be of interest to the readers of the Review, to learn some facts relative to the International Sunday Congress which convened in Paris Sept. 24–28, 1889, within the precincts of the Exposition, and under the patronage of the French Government. The congress was presided over by Senator Léon Say. A large number of eminent men have consented to become honorary members, among whom I might name President Harrison, elected president of honor of the congress, and Mr. Gladstone.
In one or two respects, the congress appeared to be a novel sight; Catholic priests and Protestant ministers were there seen to discuss harmoniously, side by side, the questions of the day. A continental religious paper says candidly: “With joy was it discovered that there exists a common ground on which we can meet and work together.”
Another feature worthy of attention, is the basis on which the congress placed the Sunday question; this basis is well indicated in the official title of the meeting: “International Congress for the Weekly Rest, from a Hygienic and Social Stand-point.” Thus it would seem that in Europe the Sunday movement is to assume a civil and not a religious form, and that the laws enacted to enforce the observance of the day are to be based on social grounds. However this may be, the Sunday advocates will have to be more consistent with themselves, and future congresses more so than the one just held.
Indeed, it may fittingly be asked whether a day of rest, devoid of all religious character, can at all be beneficial to man or society; whether it is not probable, rather, that this regular day of leisure will become an occasion of dissipation and demoralization; and whether this is not a fact of which every week gives us a fresh demonstration.
But to come to the inconsistency of the congress. I have before me the eleven resolutions voted upon on the main question—“The weekly rest from a hygienic and social stand-point.” In these eleven propositions, the argument drawn from the moral nature of man, from his morality, from his moral progress, occurs no less than seven times. Now, what is this moral argument, if it is not a religious argument? In fact, what is moral progress without religion? Unless the members of the congress be believers in the exploded system of morals as independent of religion (which I will not suppose), this sevenfold reiteration of the moral argument is an admission of the essentially religious character of the Sabbath institution. On this point, an American delegate boldly and truthfully said in the congress: “For myself, as well as for others, the assertion that the civil institution of the rest-day is distinct from the religious institution,—that assertion is not a truth.”
This inconsistency on the part of the congress is perhaps explained by the fact that the organizers and leaders of the same were no others than the members of the two most prominent French Protestant Sunday Boards, that of Geneva and that of Paris. The congress was, then, really a religious scheme under a civil garb. This fact was perhaps made most conspicuous by seven resolutions voted on concerning “the weekly rest-day and the railroads.” These resolutions urge the suppression of labor on the railroads—the time being seven times specified—on Sundays AND HOLY DAYS! Which holy days?—The holy days of the churches, of course, among others the Catholic Church. Protestants, compelled to keep her holy days, might, perchance, be led to see the true origin of Sunday.
Laws enforcing the observance of Sunday were loudly clamored for in the congress. The legitimacy of legislating on the question was sustained by most surprisingly weak and shallow arguments, which I will not here repeat. I was cheered, however, to hear in the congress calm but decided protests against what was called a disastrous intervention on the part of the State.
Besides the official meetings, the leaders of the congress held two supplementary meetings directly devoted to the religious side of the question. It was frankly recognized that Sunday-keeping, and, consequently, public worship, were generally abandoned in many churches. “There are even churches,” said one speaker, “in which the keeping of Sunday is never made the subject of a sermon.” Is not the cause of this state of things revealed by the following incident, related by the secretary of the International Federation for Sunday-keeping: In Copenhagen, a Sunday committee was not able to get on in its work until all the ministers—and with them all doctrinal discussions—had been excluded from it, and replaced by thirty laymen. (That is to say, that as long as there were ministers on the committee, the differences of opinion on the nature and authority of Sunday were so great and so many, that nothing could be done.) The matter hardly admits of any doubt: the desecration of Sunday arises largely from the prevailing uncertainty as to its rights upon the conscience, as to its legitimacy as a religious institution; in a word, as to its divine origin.
This, the advocates of Sunday in Paris seem to have felt more or less distinctly. But what did they do? Was it their first object to settle this capital point?—Far from it. They warmly recommended that all ministers should avoid all doctrinal discussions on the Sunday question. “Whatever may be our theory about the Sunday,” said one speaker, “let us agree upon the necessity of defending it as a condition of the existence of our churches.” In other words: The foundations of our work are tottering; no matter, keep silent about the divine or human authority for Sunday; let there be no Bible argument on that; let it be taken for granted that the fourth commandment applies to the first instead of the seventh day. Research would hinder the Sunday movement, then suppress all research; shut your eyes and go ahead.
What shall honest minds think of such proceedings on so solemn and timely a question? Indeed, the Sabbath question comes to the front in every land; irresistibly it is becoming the great religious problem of the present generation. How shall it be solved? Seventh-day Adventists were twice branded in the congress as “adversaries.” And yet, what a much nobler way they have of settling this great question!