WILL IT EXEMPT?

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 18, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 11.

Read the full edition

WILL IT EXEMPT?

BY ELD. E. E. MARVIN.
(Cross Plains, Tenn.)
The pretended exemption clause for seventh-day-keepers, in the resurrected Blair Sunday bill, is a fraud on the very face of it. It looks very innocent at first. Section 6 first makes some real exemptions for certain branches of commerce. Then follows a marvelous exhibition of cunning. It reads as follows:—
Nor shall the provisions of this act be construed to prohibit or to sanction labor on Sunday by individuals who conscientiously believe in and observe any other day than Sunday as the Sabbath or a day of religious worship; provided such labor be not done to the disturbance of others.
The word “sanction” succeeding the word “prohibit,” utterly destroys or neutralizes all the protection that the clause otherwise would afford to the class mentioned. If “the provisions of this act shall not be construed to sanction” Sunday work by seventh-day-keepers, then where is the exemption, and why is it called an exemption? The reason is obvious—to silence the persistent and unmanageable opposition to the proposed law, by seventh-day-keepers, and to deceive the credulous into the supposition that seventh-day-observers ought now to be still, as their liberty is provided for, etc., etc. But let us look deeper into this matter.
Instead of being an exemption, it provides against an exemption for the class mentioned. At a casual reading of this supposed exemption clause, it appears nonsensical; i. e., that the provisions of this act are not to be construed to sanction Sunday work by seventh-day-keepers, provided such work be not done to the disturbance of others. What does this mean? Does it mean anything at all?—It means that this law will not sanction Sunday work, even though it “be not done to the disturbance of others;” i. e., if the work be done by conscientious seventh-day-keepers. Who is it that “construes” the law?—The courts, of course. Courts sometimes so construe law as to exempt offenders from its operations; for instance, hotel-keepers, liverymen, barbers, railroad companies, etc., are exempt in the operations of the present Sunday laws of nearly all the States. But this exemption provides against any court’s construing this proposed national Sunday law in such a way as to make it sanction work by this class on Sunday, though it be not done to the disturbance of others. No matter how conscientiously they may keep any other day, it does not give them the right to work on Sunday, though that work may not disturb a single soul, and be done ever so quietly. But the bill puts on a pleasant, innocent, and kindly appearance, and purports to be what it is not. Instead of its being an exemption, it is not only not an exemption, but positively provides against an exemption for the class named, in the construing of the law by its executors. This new-born child reveals the true animus of the bill, and shows that what John saw in Rev. 12:17 is coming to pass.