THE THIEF ON THE CROSS

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 11, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 6.

Read the full edition

THE THIEF ON THE CROSS.

Whenever the scriptural view of the unconsciousness of man in death is presented to one not a believer in it, almost invariably the inquiry is made, “How shall we understand Christ’s statement to the thief on the cross—‘To-day shalt thou be with me in paradise?’” It matters not how emphatically the Bible teaches the certainty of man’s entire cessation between death and the resurrection, from all thought, knowledge, life, love, joy, hope, grief, or pain, this one statement to the penitent thief seems more to them than all the scriptural testimony that could be adduced. Job had called death a “sleep” in which man should lie down and not awake until the “heavens [should] be no more” (Job 14:12); that is, till Christ should come, and the “heaven depart as a scroll.” And the psalmist David had stated positively that “in death there is no remembrance” even of God. Ps. 6:5. Good King Hezekiah, when praising God for a miraculous deliverance from death, declared that his “soul” had been delivered “from the pit of corruption” (which certainly implies that his soul would have entered said “pit,” had he died), and that “the grave [original, sheol; Hebrew, the place of the dead] cannot praise thee, death cannot celebrate thee.” It is “the living” alone who can praise God. Isa. 38:17-19.
The apostle Paul in his incomparable discourse on the literal resurrection, clearly teaches that but for the resurrection, every soul, even of those who are “fallen asleep” in Christ, had irretrievably “perished.” 1 Cor. 15:18. Certainly this would not be true if all the dead were conscious, either in heaven or hell or anywhere else, between death and the resurrection. If righteous Abel is alive and in heaven, praising God after being dead 6,000 years, he has no need of any resurrection, and could not be said to “perish” if there never was any. Inspiration declares that man’s “breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146:4. Could any statement more clearly declare that death causes all thought to cease in those who experience it? In like manner another inspired writer clearly enunciates the same most solemn truth: “The dead know not anything;” “Their love, and their hatred, and their envy, is now perished;” “There is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave [Hebrew, sheol, the place of all the dead] whither thou goest.” (See Eccl. 9:5-10.) Many scriptures teaching the same great truth could be cited. But such emphatic declarations as we have given certainly furnish positive evidence of the unconsciousness of man in death.
But does not the statement of Christ to the dying thief plainly teach that he would be conscious after he was dead, and have possession of all his thoughts, and be truly alive, and in paradise with his Saviour that very day after he died? It would be strange, indeed, if this were so, and that the Son of God himself should squarely contradict the very Scriptures which he teaches us to “search,” that very “word” which he declares to be “truth.” John 5:39; 17:17. Let us, then, more carefully examine this oft-quoted testimony in behalf of consciousness in death. “And one of the malefactors which were hanged, railed on him, saying, If thou be Christ, save thyself and us. But the other answering rebuked him, saying, Dost not thou fear God, seeing thou art in the same condemnation? And we indeed justly; for we receive the due reward of our deeds: but this man hath done nothing amiss. And he said unto Jesus, Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom. And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To-day shalt thou be with me in paradise.” Luke 23:39-43. This quotation contains all the facts stated in the Scriptures concerning the thief on the cross. The facts of the record briefly recited, are these: He was a criminal, and himself admits he was being punished justly for his crimes. He had repented of them, and accepted Jesus as One who could save him. In this moment of great agony he pleads with Christ to save him. He has faith in him as a Saviour. He entreats: “Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom.”
It would not be reasonable to suppose that this thief was very familiar with Christ or his teachings. But his question does plainly imply that he knew enough of them to understand that one prominent doctrine which Jesus taught, was that he was coming again to establish a glorious and immortal kingdom, in which the saved should ever dwell. He knew Jesus and himself were about to die, were, in fact, being put to death at that moment. This kingdom, therefore, in which he asked to be “remembered,” was not some temporal affair like that over which David and Solomon reigned, and which many of the Jews at this very time were expecting to see restored by the defeat of their Roman enemies, and the exaltation of the Jewish nation above all the Gentile nations around them. He must have clearly comprehended the fact that the “kingdom” in which he desired to have a part, if the Lord “remembered” him, was to be ushered in by a second coming of Christ, and a resurrection, else Jesus or himself could have no part in it. The question was not, Lord, remember me when thou goest to thy kingdom, or when thou goest to heaven, or to the place where good spirits are supposed, by some, to go (in hades or “in limbo,” as the Catholics have it). Nothing of the kind; but, “Lord, remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom.”
The second coming of Christ is here distinctly and emphatically recognized by the dying thief, in his question. It was in this event that his hope lay. Our Saviour had prominently dwelt upon this grand event of his second coming, in his discourses to the Jews and in his conversation with his disciples. He had instructed them that he should suffer death, be raised again, go to heaven, from whence he came, and return with all the holy angels in glory, destroy his enemies, purge the kingdom from all wickedness, gather his elect, and save them forever to reign with him to all eternity. Matt. 13:31-43; 16:24-27; 24:30, 31; Mark 8:38; Luke 9:26; John 14:1-3, and many other scriptures. And however slow the Jews and his own disciples were to grasp the full significance of these emphatic statements of Christ, it must be evident that this repentant thief in the dread hour of agony while suffering crucifixion, had enough knowledge of the Saviour’s teachings and sufficient illumination of the Spirit of God to realize that his only hope was in the coming of that Saviour “into” his “kingdom.”
The form of the thief’s request has much to do with a proper understanding of our Saviour’s answer, “Verily I say unto thee, To-day shalt thou be with me in paradise.” The request referred entirely to our Lord’s coming again, and not at all to his going, as the time when he hoped to be remembered. All versions at our command so render it, and the literal Greek requires this rendering. Did our Saviour answer the request? or did his reply speak of something entirely foreign to that request? If his answer is to be understood according to the popular view, that the converted thief should be in heaven with him that day, then it must be admitted that he wholly ignored the request to be remembered when he should “come into” his “kingdom,” and promised him something else wholly different in time, place, manner, and nature, and different from his own teaching elsewhere; for he uniformly taught that the reward of his people would be given at his second coming, and not at death. (See scriptures heretofore quoted, and many others.) It is a far more consistent view to believe our Lord directly answered the thief’s request to be remembered when he should come into his kingdom.
G. I. B.
(To be continued.)