WHY NOT HAVE A CREED?

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 14, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 2.

Read the full edition

WHY NOT HAVE A CREED?

BY W. A. BLAKELY.
  • (Ann Arbor, Mich.)*
Creeds and confessions of faith are the designations given to the authorized or official expressions of the Church at large, or of some denomination or sect of the Church. Such statements of doctrine naturally sprung out of the theological arguments and controversies of the earlier centuries.
The great creeds, as they rise in succession before us, and mark the climax of successive controversial epochs in the Church, are nothing else than the varying expressions of the Christian consciousness and reason, in their efforts more completely to realize, comprehend, and express the originally simple elements of truth as they are recorded in Scripture.—People’s Cyclopedia of Universal Knowledge.
It is the natural inclination of humanity to desire to prevail in an argument, and this is especially true if it be in a theological controversy, where one party consider that their views are the all-important thing, and at the same time that the views of the other party are extremely dangerous, and ought, by all means, to be suppressed. “Under circumstances like these,” it is argued, “where the salvation or true conversion of souls depends upon the suppression of those views [the views of the other party, of course], we certainly should use every means in our power to suppress them. And if a vote of the Church will help to do it, then a vote should be taken.”
But there is another way to look at the question. A creed, or confession of faith, is the views of one or more men formally written out. Now, because the views of these certain men are indorsed by the majority of a council or any other body, does that necessarily make those views correct? If two persons, after studying a subject, come to different conclusions, does the indorsement of one by the majority in a church make the one right and the other wrong? Is the truth to be determined by the votes of a majority in a conference, council, or synod, especially when a percentage, sometimes large and sometimes small, do not fully understand the subject under consideration; or is truth to be found by investigation and the individual use of the reasoning powers which God has implanted in man?
The tendency of creeds and authoritative statements of doctrine has invariably been to imbitter the controversy, to multiply sects, to suggest and foster intolerance, and to transform persons who are naturally amiable, into acrimonious and malevolent persecutors.
This may seem to be strong language, but it is nevertheless true. St. Hilary, bishop of Poitiers, describing the condition of the church in his time (the early part of the fourth century), says:—
It is a thing equally deplorable and dangerous that there are as many creeds as opinions among men, as many doctrines as inclinations, and as many sources of blasphemy as there are faults among us; because we make creeds arbitrarily, and explain them as arbitrarily. The Homoousion is rejected, and received, and explained away by successive synods. The partial or total resemblance of the Father and the Son, is a subject of dispute for these unhappy times. Every year, nay, every moon, we make new creeds to describe invisible mysteries. We repent of what we have done, we defend those who repent, we anathematize those whom we defended. We condemn either the doctrine of others in ourselves, or our own in that of others; and reciprocally tearing one another to pieces, we have been the cause of each other’s ruin.”—Hilarius ad Constan., book ii, c. 4, 5.
The frequency of their synods is told in a curious passage from the Roman historian, Ammianus, who says:—
The highways were covered with troops of bishops, galloping from every side to the assemblies, which they called synods; and while they labored to reduce the whole sect to their own particular opinions, the public establishment of the posts was almost ruined by their hasty and repeated journeys.—Ammianus xx, 16.
Instead of unity, they had division; instead of harmony, they had discord; instead of settling questions of dispute, they raised new points of difference; instead of brotherly love and Christian fellowship, they had hatred and animosity.
At first, as is the case with resolutions and official statements of doctrines generally, “creeds were drawn up with the greatest latitude.”—Gibbon, vol. 1, chap. 21, par. 10, note. But the bishops were not satisfied with this. “The freedom of private judgment submitted to the public wisdom of synods; the authority of a theologian was determined by his ecclesiastical rank; and the episcopal successors of the apostles inflicted the censures of the church on those who deviated from the orthodox belief.”—Id., par. 10.
Following this, came the anathemas of the Church; the right of private judgment in matters of religion was denied in toto by the clergy; the Bible was taken out of the hands of the laity; and the doctrine of an infallible ministry, infallible councils, and an infallible pope, is the logical outgrowth of defining, at first in a very liberal way, what views some one else should take of the word of God.
It is much safer to take “the Bible, and the Bible alone.” “All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness;” but it is safe to say that all creeds are not. No man on earth, the pope of Rome not excepted, has a right to dictate what others shall believe and teach; neither has any body of men, whether it be a church of two members in the back-woods of some obscure country, or an ecumenical council composed of the best and greatest men of earth.
Just as soon as freedom of thought is hindered, just so soon and to just that extent progress and development are checked. The mind of man is the greatest and most wonderful creation of God. It was created for use. Man’s reason was given to him to enable him to draw proper conclusions on all subjects. And whenever any council, synod, conference, presbytery, or ecclesiastical power whatever dictates as to what a person shall believe, or what he shall not believe, that body is assuming prerogatives possessed by no earthly power; and any such action always has hindered, and always will hinder, advancement and independent thought; and the invariable result is that people drift away from the truth, religious power becomes a dead formalism, and the aid of the State is called in to supply the power that is lost in the Church.
This is why we oppose creeds.