THE “CIVIL SABBATH” MUDDLE

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 6, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE “CIVIL SABBATH” MUDDLE.

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.
(Ridgeway, N. Y.)
A NATIONAL REFORMER, M. A. Gault, pleads for a civil sabbath law. He says, “The State can require only cessation of labor on the sabbath. It cannot compel people to attend church, or to perform church duties as such.” Very well; what next? His very next words are, “But the authority of Christ is behind the civil sabbath law as much as it is behind the church sabbath law, and the one is as much a matter between man and his conscience as the other.” Further on, he says, “What we need and what we must have is a law that is the will of an unchanging Lawgiver. This alone will present a force sufficient to bind the conscience of the citizen.”
Now, civil law cannot control the conscience; it can only compel men to act civilly. But they want a law that will “bind the conscience of the citizen”—“a law that is the will of an unchanging Lawgiver.” They propose then to legislate for God; to bind men’s consciences by the will of God. And who is to decide what that will is?—Oh, the majority, of course. But the majority may change sides. Would that event change the will of God? Mr. Gault understands that majorities are liable to change. He asks, “How much respect or obedience will a people render to a law which is only the expression of the will of a bare majority, and which may be changed in an hour?” And this he puts forth as a grave argument that civil law, which is the expression of the will of the majority, may re-enact the law of God, so as to reach men’s consciences! And yet the civil law “can require only the cessation of labor on the sabbath.” Why not enforce the commandment as a whole?
The fact is, the Sabbath which God commanded is wholly a religious institution. The keeping of it according to the commandment is a solemn act of worship toward God. It lies wholly between each individual and his God whether he will keep it or not in whole or in part; and the man who imperiously dictates to another its observance, assumes the place of God.
It is no incivility to his fellow-citizens for a man to mind his own business on any day of the week. But it would be quite uncivil to compel him to lose a day in every week from his lawful occupation. Our laws protect every man in his right to worship God on Sunday and every other day. What, then, do they want but to compel men to worship according to their dictates?
The fact is, for generations they have been breaking God’s Sabbath law, and honoring a human institution in its stead. This has encouraged a growing disregard of God’s Sabbath law, till many claim that no Sabbath is binding. Meanwhile the true light has been increasing, and many are being convinced that if they will obey God they must return to the original, God-appointed Sabbath. To evade this light, the subterfuge has been invented, and extensively adopted, that to keep any one day in seven will fully answer the Sabbath law. But some are slow to believe this, and really believe they are bound to the day mentioned in the fourth commandment. To convince them of their error, National Reformers have talked of chartering a vessel, and taking this little company on a voyage around the world, and thus show them that Saturday comes on Sunday. But the little company are increasing, so that that would be hardly practicable. The only argument left is to convince them by civil (rather uncivil) law.
The National Reformers are looking for a glorious millennium soon to be ushered in; then, of course, all will keep the same Sabbath; and, strange as it may seem, they look to the making and enforcing of Sunday laws as an important step toward its introduction. Nations are to be converted to God, acknowledge his name, and enact his laws. Only just think of it—the enforcement by State laws, of an institution which has no higher authority than that of Constantine and the Roman Church, is about to introduce the glorious reign of Christ on earth! Could blindness be more complete?
Civil law can only restrain men from crime, and compel them to respect the rights of others. All have a civil right to rest; but these self-styled reformers wish to compel all to rest on a particular day which they call a civil sabbath. But to make this civil law reach the conscience, there is a pretended divine institution behind it. This they call the Christian sabbath. But when we come to sift the matter, it is found that this sabbath was not instituted by Christ, but originated in the Dark Ages of papal apostasy, and is, in fact, a rival of the only weekly Sabbath of the entire Bible.