ASKS CONCEDED WHAT HE SHOULD PROVE

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 6, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 18.

Read the full edition

ASKS CONCEDED WHAT HE SHOULD PROVE.

In the Christian Oracle of April 17, a writer, J. H. Painter, notices Father Enright’s statement concerning the authority for the change of the Sabbath. Referring to Mr. Enright’s repeated offer of $1,000 to any one who will furnish any proof from the Bible that Sunday is the day we are bound to keep, he says:—
If he will concede that the Bible binds us to keep any day, I will furnish some proof that Sunday is the day.
There is a fatal weakness in this proposition of Mr. Painter’s. He asks conceded just what he should prove, that the Bible binds us to keep any day. Mr. Painter and his brethren observe a day. They claim to go by the Bible and the Bible only. Now, in observing Sunday and teaching others to do so, are they doing something the Bible does not enjoin? If not, why does Mr. Painter ask Father Enright to concede that the Bible binds us to keep any day? Why does he not give the proof that it does, and avoid the necessity of asking that it be conceded? The very fact of asking the concession is a tacit but fatal admission that (taking the position he and his people do, that the ten commandments and the Old Testament are done away) they find no Bible authority upon which to base their weekly rest day. Having destroyed the foundation for such a septenary institution, nothing is left upon which to build one. The Catholics do not go so far. They admit the binding obligation of the fourth commandment together with the others (save the second). They find these taught in all their catechisms. But they claim that their Church has power to change the Sabbath, and that it did change it to Sunday, and therefore they keep that day. But our Disciple friends have not as plausible an assumption to set forth even as this. So they ask that the very Bible authority itself, enjoining the keeping of a day, be “conceded.” They can give no good reason for keeping one day in seven, for they ignore the commandment which gives the only divine reason for dividing time into periods of seven days; and no Bible reason for observing the first day of the seven. They find one instance in which bread was broken on the first day of the week (Acts 20: 7–11), but they do not have to search long in their New Testaments before finding that bread was broken by the disciples upon all days (Acts 2: 46), and that the Lord himself instituted his Supper on Thursday night shortly before his betrayal. Matt. 26: 26–34. Thus their “some proof that Sunday is the day” proves to be no better than like proof for all days.
Father Enright will readily concede that the Bible enjoins the observance of a day, but he will just as freely grant that the only day it enjoins is the seventh day. He will agree with Cardinal Gibbons in saying, “Read the Bible from Genesis to Revelation, and you will not find a single line authorizing the sanctification of Sunday;” with the “Catholic Christian Instructed” wherein it says, “So that truly, the best authority we have for this is the testimony of the Church;” and the statement in the “Douay Catechism,” that “therefore they [Protestants] fondly contradict themselves by keeping Sunday strictly and breaking most other feasts commanded by the same church.” Mr. Painter may deny all this, but he cannot do it successfully without showing the Bible authority for keeping Sunday. But Bible authority for keeping a day is just what he wishes conceded. He certainly is a long way from getting Father Enright’s $1,000.
How Mr. Painter, together with all other Sunday-keeping Protestants, came to be keeping Sunday, is well told in a Catholic tract entitled, “A Question for all Bible Christians.” The question is, “Why do you not keep holy the Sabbath day?” and the explanation referred to reads as follows:—
The present generation of Protestants keep Sunday holy instead of Saturday because they received it as a part of the Christian religion from the last generation, and that generation received it from the generation before, and so on, backward, from one generation to another, by a continual succession, until we come to the time of the (so-called) Reformation, when it so happened that those who conducted the change of religion in this country, left this particular portion of Catholic faith and practice untouched.”
While the Reformation of the sixteenth century stirred up the nest of papal dogmas to no small degree, there were several of these dogmas of the Romish Church left untouched to be protested against by Protestants of later generations. There was infant baptism. Upon this the Christian Herald of Nov. 14, 1889, says:—
Baptists are reforming Luther’s work by taking from it the fatal error of birthright church membership.
Then there was sprinkling for baptism. In this Baptists, Disciples, and others have gone on in the work of reformation, met, of course, with all the quibbles and foibles that error could invent. But they have stood for the right and made a noble defense. And now comes up the Sabbath question. Seventh-day Adventists claim that they are reforming the work of Protestants hitherto in taking from it a false sabbath,—one which, like infant baptism and sprinkling, rests solely upon the authority of the Catholic Church and tradition, and not upon any command of God. While Presbyterians and Methodists may not accept the special truths held by the Baptists and Disciples, and the Baptists and Disciples may not accept those held by Seventh-day Adventists, still penitent believers are the only proper subjects for baptism, immersion alone is baptism, and the seventh day and no other is the divinely appointed rest day. These are facts whether men will hear or whether they will forbear.
W. A. C.