ADDING FUEL TO THE FLAME.
By W. A. Blakely
Not Church and State United, but Church and State in the Same Position.
In the Christian Statesman, the leading organ of the National Reform Association, of Dec. 12, 1888, in the department of “Clashing Voices,” by the Rev. M. A. Gault, a vice-president of that association, appear the following excerpts and comments:— The Voice says it has never heard of a prominent Prohibitionist who favored the union of Church and State. Now Mr. Sam. Small is a prominent Prohibitionist—one of the most prominent of Prohibitionists, in fact. He was secretary of the National Prohibition Convention of 1888, and he publicly declared this, in Kansas City, in January of that year: “I want to see the day come when the Church shall be the arbiter of all legislation, State, national, and municipal; when the great churches of the country can come together harmoniously, and issue their edict, and the legislative powers will respect it and enact it into law.”—The American Sentinel. The New York Voice inclosed this article to the Rev. Sam. Small, with the request that he would answer it, and this is his reply:— “The representation of the American Sentinel, that I favor a union of Church and State, is wholly an invention of the enemy. The extract he quotes from a partial report of a sermon preached in Kansas City, in January, 1888, is sufficiently correct to mislead; not exact enough, however, to convey the thought which I clearly expressed, and which at the time secured the approval of an audience of thousands, the large majority of whom was not made up of third-party Prohibitionists. If the American Sentinel desires to do me and the Prohibition party justice, I can repeat my thoughts as clearly now as I did on the occasion in question. The quotation from my sermon should read as follows: ‘I want to see the day come in the history of our country, when the voice of the Church of Christ will be heard and respected upon all moral issues. I shall ever hope for, and patiently expect the day when legislation, State, national, and municipal, will be projected in harmony with the eternal principles of justice and righteousness, revealed by Christ and proclaimed by his Church. Happy will be the day when righteousness exalts the nation, when sin is no longer the reproach of our people; when the harmonious judgment of the people of God in America upon the issues of temperance, purity, and uprightness shall be received with respect and enacted into laws. When this people, who owe so much to the divine favor, will have no more fellowship with the throne of iniquity which frameth mischief by a law, and that continually.’” “I hold that the above expressions are in perfect harmony with the principles of the National Prohibition party, as expressed in its preamble and platform. There is in them no warrant for any sane man to pronounce me an advocate of the union of Church and State. The charge is a device of desperation, to compass an argument against the Prohibition party. At the same time it is a fraud upon the readers of the American Sentinel, or a queer confession of the idiocy of its constituency. “—SAM. W. SMALL.” The point that needs to be made clear in the above reply is that the relation of the State to divine law is not through the Church as the uniting link. The Church is not the coupling-pin, linking the State to God. It is an idea akin to Rome that the State should regard the Church as the promulgator of law. The truth that needs to be emphasized is, that the State is as directly related to God as the Church. The State has the same right as the Church to go to the Bible as the fountain of law. The judge in the civil court has the same right to appeal to Bible law as the minister or elder in the Church court. In other words, the Bible is as much a legal text-book for the State as for the Church. How, then, are the Church and the State to be kept separate?—By clearly drawing the line between civil law and ecclesiastical law. The latter pertains only to the Church; to its doctrines, worship, government, and discipline. These are never to be enforced by civil penalties like the laws of the State. This alone separates Church and State by a wide difference. We protest against any attempt to compel people by civil law to build churches or support any ecclesiastical system. The purpose of this article is not so much a refutation of the above, as to present to the readers of the REVIEW AND HERALD the words of these people themselves. It was charged that Mr. Small was wrongly represented; so the reverend gentleman himself, in order to make it perfectly clear what he did mean, repeats the thoughts which he “clearly expressed.” And what are they, according to his own words?— I want to see the day come in the history of our country, when the voice of the Church of Christ will be heard and respected upon all moral issues. I shall ever hope for, and patiently expect the day when legislation, State, national, and municipal, will be projected in harmony with the eternal principles of justice and righteousness revealed by Christ and PROCLAIMED BY HIS CHURCH. Happy will be the day when righteousness exalts the nation, when sin is no longer the reproach of our people; when the harmonious judgment of the people of God in America upon the issues of temperance, purity, and uprightness shall be received with respect and enacted into laws. If such a state of affairs would not destroy American institutions and as thoroughly uproot the principles implanted by our early American statesmen, it is impossible to conceive what would. Then the Rev. M. A. Gault attaches some of his National Reform ideas:— “The truth that needs to be emphasized is, that the State is as directly related to God as [is] THE CHURCH!” Think of it! But then, on a second thought, it might be just as well to admit it. The State is composed, in part, of the most corrupt politicians, of the most licentious libertines, of thieves and defaulters, and of persons whose prominent characteristics are the works of the flesh, such as “adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations, wrath, strife, seditions, heresies, envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like.” And a State church is very similar. It is only an unintentional admission of the application of the prophecy in the Revelation, which says, “Babylon the great is fallen, is fallen, and is become the habitation of devils, and the hold of every foul spirit, and a cage of every unclean and hateful bird;” i. e., the Church when it unites with a corrupt State instead of with Christ. The judge in the civil court has the same right to appeal to Bible law as the minister or elder in the Church court. In other words, the Bible is as much a legal text-book for the State as for the Church. Could anything be more preposterous? Can human absurdity take man further? To think of using the Bible as “a legal text-book for the State” as much “as for the Church”? Who can say now that there would be no persecution on account of religious belief? No one would ever suspect that we were living in the free land of America in the nineteenth century, if he were to judge from reading the writings of these religio-political National Reformers and Sunday-law advocates. In closing, the reverend writer says:— How, then, are the Church and the State to be kept separate? [That is a point the reader would like to find out!]—By clearly drawing the line between civil law and ecclesiastical law. The latter pertains only to the Church; to its doctrines, worship, government, and discipline. These are never to be enforced by civil penalties like the laws of the State. This alone separates Church and State by a wide difference. That is perfectly clear! It is exactly what the Roman Empire had for about ten centuries. And now people all over America are calling for it again. Are the citizens of the United States willing to rest in quiet security while the Roman Catholics, the National Reformers, and many of the Protestant churches are undermining our free institutions? Are Americans willing to let the first steps be taken by our National Government in religious legislation? For if we once begin, who can tell what will be the end thereof?