CONFLICTING OPINIONS WORTH READING AND CONTRASTING

2%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 24, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Extra

Read the full edition

CONFLICTING OPINIONS WORTH READING AND CONTRASTING.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.—Declaration of Independence.
Jefferson’s dictum that “Rulers receive their just powers from the consent of the governed” is only a half truth, and if taken for a whole truth, becomes a dangerous error.—J. M. Foster, in Christian Statesman, December 12, 1889.
I, for one, do not believe that as a political maxim. I do not believe that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed; and so the object of this movement is an effort to change that feature in our fundamental law.—Rev. W. D. Gray, Secretary Sunday Reform Convention, Sedalia, Mo.

RESOLUTION OFFERED BY ELDER R. C. PORTER AT THE SUNDAY CONVENTION IN SEDALIA, MO.

Whereas, The principles of equality of rights as set forth in the Declaration of Independence, and incorporated in the Constitution of the United States, by securing to all citizens equal protection of the law, and as is expressed by our Saviour in the golden rule, is the only true principle of civil and religious liberty; and,—
Whereas, The rights of conscience of a minority are as sacred as those of the majority, and should be equally respected; therefore,—
Resolved, That it is the object of this Association that the principles of the equality of rights, both civil and religious, guaranteed to all citizens by our Constitution, as it now stands, should be maintained; and that we will strenuously oppose any movement that will endanger the rights of conscience of any citizens, or deprive them of equal protection of the laws of the State of Missouri or of the United States.
Rev. W. D. Gray, secretary of the convention, said:—
Mr. Chairman, I move you that the resolution be laid on the table.
The motion was carried.
Rev. J. W. Morrow moved the return of the resolution to its proposer, and that the paper be not made a part of the record of the convention.
Elder Porter asked:—
Does the gentleman mean to say that he is opposed to the expression of equality of rights and the principles of the Christian religion as set forth in this resolution? Is that the idea of the gentleman in making the motion?
Mr. Morrow said:—
That resolution is directly opposed to the object of this movement, and I do not think that any one can be imposed upon by it. I am in favor of free speeches in this convention all the way through, but I am not in favor of allowing this resolution to lie on the table, liable to be brought up at any time.
The motion to return the paper to the author prevailed with almost a unanimous vote.—From Report of Sunday Convention at Sedalia, Mo., June, 1889.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.—First Amendment to the Constitution.
No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the law.—Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution.
Contrast these two unqualified expressions from our fundamental law with the two following from a prominent officer of the Sunday Union:—
Our remedy for all these malefic influences is to have the Government simply set up the moral law, and recognize God’s authority behind it, and lay its hands on any religion that does not conform to it.—M. A. Gault, District Secretary of the Sabbath Union, in Christian Statesman, Jan. 13, 1887.
We propose to incorporate in our national Constitution the moral and religious command, “In it [the Sabbath] thou shalt do no work,” except the works of necessity, and by external force of sheriffs we propose to arrest and punish all violators of this law.—M. A. Gault, in Letter of June 3, 1889.
Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence. John 18:36.
The kingdom of Christ must enter the realm of law through the gateway of politics.—Woman’s Christian Temperance Union National Convention, 1887.
The resolution offered in the Iowa State Sunday Convention, November 12, which excited the most discussion, and which was finally defeated, was one declaring that to reach the citizen’s conscience, it was necessary for civil government to recognize divine authority behind the law of the Sabbath. Dr. C. T. McCaughon and Dr. H. M. Robinson, of Winterset; Rev. W. L. Ferris, of Cherokee; and Rev. James Parker, of Cedar Rapids, argued strongly in favor of this resolution, but the opposition to the Christian theory of government was too strong, and it was lost. It was claimed by the opposition that many influential men in the State refused to identify themselves with the movement because of the mistake of urging the law of the Sabbath from the divine stand-point. In other words, if God was identified with the movement, it would excite opposition; therefore we must keep God out of it, and urge it merely on the authority of the people. President G. A. Gates, of Grinnell College, took grounds that the State could not regard Sabbath observance as a Christian duty, but only as a police regulation. He said he stood with those who did not want Sabbath laws on religious grounds. We could never control conscience by law.—Reported in Christian Statesman, Dec. 12, 1889.
The above reported language from President Gates, and that which follows from J. K. Fowler, taken together with the parenthetic quotations from leaders in the Sunday Union, show to a slight degree the marked differences that are arising in their own ranks.
What authority has the majority to enact a Sabbath law which they must obey?—None whatever, except on the basis of the law of God.—J. M. Foster, in Christian Statesman, Dec. 12, 1889.
The Rev. J. K. Fowler, pastor of the Presbyterian church at Cedar Rapids, delivered in the Iowa State Sunday Convention, an able and carefully written address, in which he argued from the basis of the secular or infidel theory of government. He said:—
Many ardent defenders of the Sabbath justified it on the ground that God enjoined the observance of the Sabbath, and the State should do the same. It is time we had done with arguing for Sabbath legislation, before Congress or other civil bodies, on the plea of its supposed divine institution and scriptural authority. It is utterly untenable according to the spirit of our charters of government.
Says the Supreme Court of Ohio:—
The statute prohibiting common labor on the Sabbath could not stand for a moment as the law of this State if its sole foundation was the extra duty of keeping the day holy, and its sole motive was to enforce the observance of the day.
(We do not put this work on mere human reasoning, for all that can be overthrown by human reason; we rest it directly and only on the divine commandment.—Elliott F. Shepard, Address on Election to Presidency of American Sunday Union.)
The Supreme Court of New York in sustaining one of the Sabbath laws, says:—
The act complained of here compels no religious observance, and offenses against it are punishable, not as sins against God, but as injurious to, and having a malignant influence on, society. It rests upon the same foundation as a multitude of other laws upon our statute books, such as those against gambling, lotteries, keeping disorderly houses, polygamy, etc.
Dr. Fowler said further in the Sunday convention:—
The civil law forbids these not as offenses against God, but as crimes against man. The law has to do with the relations of men to each other, and not with the relations of men to God. To base these Sabbath laws thus upon a divine command, as the civil ground, is to that extent to unite church and State, and to violate the fundamental principles of our State and Federal governments.
(A weekly day of rest has never been secured in any land except on the basis of religious obligation.—W. F. Crafts, Field Secretary American Sunday Union, at Philadelphia, Nov. 16, 1888.)
Dr. Fowler continued:—
If our zealous, well-meaning, but deluded friends of the Sabbath, desire to defeat the very ends they aim at, they want to push to the front and press upon the lawmakers this scriptural command for the basis of Sabbath laws, until a furor of popular feeling like that of 1826 again sweeps the country, and takes with it every vestige of Sabbath legislation.—From Report of Iowa State Sunday Convention, in Christian Statesman.
Congress must establish a standard of religion.—Prof. C. A. Blanchard, in National Reform Convention, Pittsburg, 1874.
When legal enactment begins, moral suasion ends.—Christian Union.
We want State and religion, and we are going to have it.—Rev. Jonathan Edwards, in National Reform Convention, New York City, 1878.
Religion flourishes in greater purity without than with the aid of government.—James Madison, quoted in Schaff’s Church and State, p. 34.
Let those who will, remember the Sabbath to keep it holy from motives of love and obedience; the remnant must be made to do so through fear of law.—Christian Nation, Sept. 28, 1887.
Secular power has proved a Satanic gift to the church, and ecclesiastical power has proved an engine of tyranny in the hands of the State. The apostles used only the spiritual weapons of truth and love in spreading the gospel of salvation. If men had always acted on this principle and example, history would have been spared the horrors of persecution and religious wars.—Schaff, Church and State, p. 11.
Enforce upon all who come among us the laws of Christianity.—Christian Statesman, Oct. 2, 1884.
Guizot, speaking of the government of religious society, says:—
There is no doubt but compulsion is here strictly forbidden: there can be no doubt, as its only territory is the conscience of man, but that every species of force must be illegal, whatever the end designed.—Guizot, History of Civilization, p. 93.
And again on page 105 of the same work:—
Finally, the church had a third connection with the sovereigns, and it was to her the most disastrous and fatal. She laid claim to the right of coercion, to the right of restraining and punishing heresy. But she had no means by which to do this; she had no physical force at her disposal; when she had condemned the heretic, she was without the power to carry her sentence into execution. What was the consequence?—She called to her aid the secular arm; she had to borrow the power of the civil authority as the means of compulsion. To what a wretched shift was she thus driven by the adoption of the wicked and detestable principles of coercion and persecution.
The Washington Star reports Rev. W. F. Crafts as saying in a late sermon in that city, while he held up an instrument which he said was an oriental saw, that:—
It was such a one as the Saviour laid down every Saturday night, a badge of honest labor.
Contrast with that expression the following, from “Sabbath for Man,” by W. F. Crafts, p. 376:—
The preceding Saturday Sabbath, which began with a home sacrament; such as I saw at sunset, of a Friday, in Jerusalem,—a Jewish father standing in the midst of his family to “bless his house,” as David did, and reciting the fourth commandment.
The only certain voice in the above extracts, will be found to be from those who consistently oppose religious legislation always, everywhere, and on principle. The defenders of Sunday laws are many of them in doubt which side of this plank to place uppermost in their platform, the religious or the civil, the Biblical commandment of devotional reverence, or the physiological and humane need of physical rest. The constitution of the Sabbath Union distinctly states the object of the Union to be to preserve the “Christian Sabbath,” not the secular Sunday; but the Wisconsin branch calls itself the “Wisconsin Civil Sunday Association,” and in the Iowa and Louisiana conventions, the Field Secretary was vigorously opposed on the religious plank by several clear-minded ministers.
The key-note of the difference in the ranks of the Sunday legislationists was heard in a conversation between two National Reformers in Washington not long since:—
We must conceal our real object, or we shall be defeated. They are so easily frightened with anything like religious legislation. We must keep that back, or we shall surely fail.
W. H. M.