THE CATHOLIC CHURCH AND SOCIALISM

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 10, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 23.

Read the full edition

THE CATHOLIC CHURCH AND SOCIALISM.

INDUBITABLY three powers are struggling for the supremacy, first, in the German Empire, and then, perhaps, also in entire Western Europe: the Social Democracy, the so-called State Socialism, and the Catholic Church. Which of these powers will win the victory? Or is it conceivable that individual liberty, now hard beset by all of these mighty powers, will prove capable of resistance, and that the possible victory of either of the three will be only transient? Socialism tends toward the leveling of all conditions, and even when it comes in the insidious form of State Socialism, it will pass over to simple Socialism without kid gloves and with a complete change of persons; and thus Socialism “without injury to my family,” is based upon a delusion. Even the hereditary monarchy, when the leveling process is begun, will be exposed to it in the end. . . .
The Catholic Church has always shown great mastery in the art of molding popular opinion and utilizing it for its purposes. Is it therefore inconceivable that a compact should be formed between the State seeking to establish State Socialism, whether as a means to other purposes or as the final purpose, and the Catholic Church, which since the sixties has busied itself in Germany with social questions and with the organization of working-men’s societies, especially through the influence of the able and, in his time, widely known bishop of Mayence, Wilhelm von Ketteler? The very dogma of authority, which constitutes the essence of this church, renders it possible for it to rescue from the leveling floods of Socialism those institutions that it is undesirable to sacrifice; for the principle of authority stands in the way of the drawing of consequences. Of course, as could not be otherwise from its doctrine and traditions, the Catholic Church will render such service only in the expectation that the State, as was often the case in the Middle Ages, shall become its vassal. Unless all signs fail, many hands are already stretched out for such a compact from both sides; and it may happen that the personage to whom a prominent part in social questions is imputed, will at the same time present demands to the State—demands that imply the complete surrender of the school, and with it the future of the State, to the Church. The belief may be cherished on the part of the State, that complete subjugation to the Church may not be the price that will have to be paid. Yet probabilities all speak against such a hope; for, in the first place, the Church, if given complete liberty, will control opinion; and, in the second place, it will be following a course that is consistent throughout; whereas, the State favoring Socialism and calling the Church to its assistance, will find itself frequently compelled to disappoint the general expectations and draw back from the consequences of its principles at certain points, lest it should become completely ingulfed in Democratic Socialism, or fall under the dominion of the Church.—L. von Bar, in Die Nation.