THE COUNCILS

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 1, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 39.

Read the full edition

THE COUNCILS.

BY ELD. R. S. WEBBER.
(Pittsfield, Me.)
(Concluded.)
Speaking of the fact that Sylvester, the bishop of Rome, confirmed the Nicene creed in the presence of 275 bishops, Maimbourg’s “History of Arianism,” vol. 1, p. 48, says:—
We confirm with our mouth that which has been decreed at Nicæa, a city in Bithynia, by the three hundred and eighteen holy bishops, for the good of the Catholic and apostolic church, mother of the faithful. We anathematize all those who dare to contradict the decree of the great and holy council which was assembled at Nicæa, in the presence of that most pious and venerable prince, the emperor Constantine. To this the 275 bishops answered, “We consent to it.”
We have seen above that the bishop of Rome was given a higher rank than any Eastern bishop in the Council of Constantinople, A. D. 381. This council was Oriental not Occidental; it was convened at Constantinople, not at Rome; it was a Greek, not a Latin council, and there was not a single Latin bishop present; nevertheless, it was raised to the ecumenical rank by the consent of the Latin Church toward the middle of the following century. (See History of the Christian Church, by Philip Schaff, vol. 3, pp. 332, 333.) This very council also received the sanction of the pope of Rome. Hefele, in his “History of the Church Councils,” vol. 2, p. 44, says:—
When the pope and the Western bishops heard the decrees of the Council of Constantinople, held in 381, subsequently accepted as the second ecumenical council, they expressed in an Italian synod their disapproval of some of the steps taken, although they had not then received the acts of the council. Soon after they had received the acts, Pope Damasus gave his sanction to the council. This is the account given by Photius (De Synodis in Mansi. III., 595).
Thus it will be seen that the Latin Church, with the pope at its head, did have great influence with these councils. It was not the number of bishops present, or the place where convened, that gave power to these councils and their decrees. Mr. Schaff says:—
It is, therefore, not the number of bishops present, nor even the regularity of the summons, alone, that determines the ecumenical character of a council; but the result, the importance and correctness of the decisions, and, above all, the consent of the orthodox Christian world.—Hist. Christian Church, pp. 333, 334.
Here is the truth exactly. The third ecumenical council was held at Ephesus, 431 A. D., and its decisions were signed by the legates of Pope Celestine. And besides this sanction, Celestine’s successor, Pope Sixtus III., sanctioned this Council of Ephesus, as Hefele said, “in a more solemn manner, in several circulars and private letters, some of which have reached us.” The fourth ecumenical council was held at Chalcedon, under the emperor Marcian, 451 A. D. “Chalcedon was the first general council where the legates of the bishop of Rome presided.” (See Gieseler, vol. 1, p. 385.) In the Council of Chalcedon, “the Roman delegates sat on the left, who for the first time at an ecumenical council conducted the internal proceedings as spiritual presidents.” (See Schaff’s Church History, p. 743.) The decisions of this council were signed by the papal legates, then all the acts of the synod were sent to the pope in order to obtain his approval and confirmation. “The emperor Marcian, like the council, requested the pope to sanction the decrees.” The archbishop of Constantinople, Anatolius, expressed himself to the pope as follows: “The whole force and confirmation of the acts have been reserved for the authority of your holiness.”
After refusing for a long time, Pope Vigilius finally sanctioned the decrees of the fifth ecumenical council. For further information concerning the other councils, see Hefele’s History, to which we have referred. Besides these great general councils, some of the provincial councils were very important. Their decrees were added to those of the great ecumenical councils, and received as law by all the churches east and west. Among these was the Council of Laodicea. Speaking of this, Philip Schaff says:—
The universal councils, through their disciplinary enactments, or canons, were the main fountains of ecclesiastical law. To their canons were added the decrees of the important provincial councils of the fourth century, at Ancyra (314), . . . and Laodicea, between 343 and 381.—Hist. Christian Church, pp. 353, 354.
Another writer, speaking of Laodicea, says:—
It was the seat of two important general councils of the Christian Church: the first, whose date is variously placed from 363 to 372, enacted sixty canons. [This was the Council of Laodicea.]—Johnson’s New Universal Cyclopædia, vol. 2, part 2, p. 1645.
This is called a very important council by many historians, not because of the large number of bishops of which it was composed, for it was a comparatively small council, but because of the importance of its decisions, and of their acceptance by the Christian churches in both Eastern and Western Rome. Dr. John C. L. Gieseler, in his Church History, vol. 1, pp. 308, 309, speaking of the dissensions among the Eusebians till the suppression of Arianism, 381 A. D., says:—
Thus the canons of the Oriental councils, held during the schism, constantly remained in force, particularly those of the Council of Antioch, A. D. 341, and of Laodicea, perhaps A. D. 363, which canons afterward passed over from the Oriental to the Occidental Church.
Thus we see that the canons of the Council of Laodicea were clothed with the same power and authority that the decrees of the great ecumenical councils were, and universally received by the Greek and Latin churches. Hefele not only speaks of this council, but gives all the sixty canons that were enacted. The twenty-ninth reads as follows:—
Christians shall not Judaize and be idle on Saturday, but shall work on that day. But the Lord’s day they shall especially honor, and as being Christians, shall, if possible, do no work on that day. If, however, they are found Judaizing, let them be shut out from Christ.—Hefele, vol. 2, p. 316.
And according to Dr. Schaff and Dr. J. C. L. Gieseler, as already quoted, this canon passed over from the Oriental (Eastern) to the Occidental (Western) churches, and became “part of the main foundation of the ecclesiastical law” for the Christian world. Thus God’s holy Sabbath was lowered to a common working-day; and the first day of the week, a common working-day, was raised to the rank of the sacred Sabbath. Speaking of the early custom of keeping Sunday, Fisher, in his History of the Church, says:—
It had been the custom of the Church to observe Sunday by special religious exercises, and by an increasing abstinence from the pursuits of secular life. This custom was made a law by the Council of Laodicea (363).
William Prynne, a celebrated English divine, in his comments upon the council, says:—
The seventh-day Sabbath was solemnized by Christ, the apostles, and primitive Christians till the Laodicean Council did in a manner quite abolish the observance of it. . . . The Council of Laodicea, A. D. 364, first settled the observance of the Lord’s day, and prohibited the keeping of the Jewish Sabbath under an anathema.—Dissert. on Lord’s Day, p. 32.
Here the first step was taken to change the Sabbath, by a decree of the church that became universal, and was sanctioned by the pope of Rome. Therefore, the Catholic Church, with the pope at its head, of which church the Council of Laodicea was, in its time, a representative, did change the Sabbath day.