GEE, HAW, GET UP, WHOA!

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 25, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 46.

Read the full edition

GEE, HAW, GET UP, WHOA!

This heading may sound a little rude, especially when we consider that it is used in reference to an article on the Christian sabbath, in the Interior of Nov. 13, 1890; but we can think of no words which better illustrate the shifting from side to side, the starting forward, and backing up, which the writer of the article seems to find necessary to get through his subject. He will have it that Sunday is the Sabbath, in honor of Christ; then he appeals to the fourth commandment, as that is the only Sabbath law. But as the fourth commandment says nothing about the first day of the week, another turn must be made. Hence he says the commandment does not establish the week as we have it, but creates a week of its own; and that is, a day of rest after any six of labor. But he finds this will hardly do; for in this case Sunday is no more a Sabbath than any other day, so he takes that back and says that it is not true, after all, that the commandment requires only one day in seven.
To show that we do not misrepresent, we will let the writer, “Rev. W. S. Pryse,” speak for himself. He says:—
“The week has no defined limits, no necessary beginning or ending. An isolated community which had lost the reckoning of the week might observe six days of labor and one of rest, and in so doing would literally keep the fourth commandment, no matter on what day they should happen to begin their reckoning.”
This is plain one-day-in-seven and no-day-in-particular theory; but he goes right on and says:—
“It is not strictly accurate to say that the commandment merely requires the keeping of one day in seven. It requires six days of labor and the seventh day of rest. . . . It is true the law of the Sabbath fixed the Jewish week; but wherever observed, it establishes its own week. It is a mistake, therefore, to say that Christians observe the first day of the week. Sunday may be arbitrarily reckoned as the first day of the secular week, but by the very fact of its observance as the Christian sabbath it becomes the seventh day of the sacred week of the Church. But we confuse our minds by thinking in this connection of the arbitrary numbering of the days of the week. Any one may be the first and any one the seventh.”
This covers all the parts of the article that lay any claim to being an argument. The long introduction praising the first day as such an honor to Christ, will apply every whit as well to Good Friday. But what shall we say of the argument? As an effort to occupy two positions at once, to be on both sides of the fence at the same time, to make the commandment both definite and indefinite, both general and particular, to make a day the first day and at the same time the seventh day, to make the Church keep the commandment when keeping a day for which there is no commandment, to make that day the day of the commandment which is just as far as it can be from the day named in the commandment,—as an effort to do all these things it surpasses anything of the kind we have recently seen. It reminds one of the words of Saul when Samuel asked him why he had not obeyed the command to slay the Amalekites root and branch. “I have obeyed the command,” said Saul boldly, while there was the lowing of the cattle and the presence of king Agag to witness against him. So our Christian friends say, “We are keeping the seventh day,” when they know, as every one else knows, that they are keeping the first day. Their creed demands that they keep the first day to honor Christ. And so far the week is all right. But they must have a commandment for it, and so are obliged to go to the fourth commandment, as there is no other. But that commandment says the seventh day, not the first. Then they turn around and say, “We are keeping the seventh!” Our keeping the first makes it the seventh! And to bring this about, they cautiously add, “Now pay no attention to the arbitrary numbering of the days of the week, lest you become confused.” Indeed! How satisfactory this must be to any one who is disposed to think.