LUTHER VS. ZWINGLE

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 4, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 43.

Read the full edition

LUTHER VS. ZWINGLE.

A Lesson on Union of Church and State

BY ELDER J. P. HENDERSON.
(Des Moines, Iowa.)
THE contemporary, yet diverse work of these two great Reformers, presents a lesson on the results of the union of Church and State, that National Reformers might do well to investigate. Luther operated in Saxony, one of the states of Germany, while Zwingle had his home in Zurich, a canton or division of Switzerland. Both imbibed the spirit of the Reformation about the same time (i. e., 1515), yet with important points of difference both in doctrine and methods of defense.
Luther adhered to the Roman idea of consubstantiation, and other doctrines discarded by Zwingle. In Bible truth, as viewed by Protestants of to-day, Zwingle had the purest ideas of Scripture, but lacked in faith and in that unwavering trust in God. He deemed it necessary for the preservation of the Church, to unite with the State, and “thought it his duty to examine not only doctrine but also federal questions.” He resolved to be at one and the same time “the man of the State and of the Church.” “He took part in the most important deliberations, and was commissioned by the council of his canton to write letters, compose proclamations,” etc. “History of the Reformation,” chap. 16, Art. 1.
In the wars in which Switzerland was likely to be involved, Zwingle detailed plans of defense, and showed how the republic should act with regard to other empires; in fact, he became at once “the head of the State and general of the army,” which was in the end the “ruin of the Reformation and of himself.” When the cantons were preparing to crush the work he had done, and put down the “heretics,” “Let us be firm,” said he, “and fear not to take up arms. This peace which some desire so much is not peace, but war. . . . If we shun it, the ministers’ lives and the gospel will never be secure.” He thought that without some decisive action on the part of the State, Christianity would be overwhelmed, and fall back into its ancient slavery. This fatal position proved his ruin, and brought about the very calamity he wished to avoid. He often said, “We must trust in God alone, but when he gives us a just cause, we must also know how to defend it, and like Gideon and Joshua, shed blood in behalf of our country and our God.”
As the enemy approached to attack Zurich, where Zwingle lived, the inhabitants found in him a strong advocate of self-defense, by the sword. The first engagement proved fatal. The enemy was victorious. Zwingle’s troops were defeated, and he was slain. The enemy, capturing his body, decreed that it should be “quartered for treason, and burned for heresy.” His ashes were mingled with those of swine, and a “lawless multitude flung them to the winds.”
How different from this was the faith of Luther. He declined the aid of temporal power, and rejected the force of arms, looking forward to victory only through the confession of truth; in consequence of which his cause was crowned with the most brilliant success. Luther’s language was, “Christians fight not with the sword and the arquebuse, but with sufferings and the cross.” “Though our enemies,” said he, “should have around us not only that puissant Roman emperor, . . . but the emperor of the Turks and his Mohammed, they could not intimidate; they could not frighten me. It is I, who in the strength of God, am resolved to frighten and overcome them.” “As for us, the Lord is with us.” “The cause of faith is won by faith.” “When the evangelical doctrine of truth takes root in the heart of the world, neither the storms of men nor the powers of hell will ever be able to tear it up.”
When the emperor, Charles V., was about to enter Saxony with the design of crushing the Reformation, Luther wrote to the Elector, “Above all things, let not the attack proceed from our side, and let no blood be shed through our fault.” When the Elector became alarmed, and began making preparations for defense, he wrote to Luther asking advice. In reply, Luther said, “If the Emperor desires to march against us, let no prince undertake our defense. God is faithful; he will not abandon us.” When the Elector, who was a convert to Luther, received this, all preparations for war ceased, and the expected invasion of Saxony never took place.
It was indeed by faith that the world was conquered. Luther’s cause triumphed gloriously. Notwithstanding the anathemas pronounced against him, and the rewards offered for his life, he was permitted to escape the hands of persecution, and die in a quiet and peaceful manner; while the truths he defended have spread to the utmost parts of the earth.