POLYGAMY AND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 7, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 39.

Read the full edition

POLYGAMY AND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.

BY A. F. BALLENGER.
(Chicago, Ill.)
(Concluded.)
It will be conceded that it is the province and the duty of civil government to protect its citizens; and if any right of the citizen is invaded by the practice of polygamy, and such practice can be shown to be a menace to the peace and good order of society, irrespective of religious prejudice, it can and should be prohibited by civil law. That polygamy is an invasion of the natural rights of man, we shall proceed to prove.
All men are created equal, and are endowed by nature with certain natural and inalienable rights, among which is the right to the undivided companionship of a wife. But while this proposition will not be disputed, our position is that for men to take unto themselves a plurality of wives, is abnormal, and will invade that right. Polygamy is abnormal, since nature has made no provision for it. For that institution to be normal and within the reach of every man, nature must provide at least twice as many females as males; or if we take the number of wives associated with Brigham Young in the marriage relation as a precedent (and once admit the principle, the number cannot be restricted), nature would have to produce more than twenty times as many women as men. “It is fully established,” says the Encyclopædia Britannica, “that among all races of mankind, the number of male infants born slightly exceeds the number of females, the ratio being about twenty-one males to twenty females.” After mentioning the comparative mortality of the two sexes, the same authority says: “Taking the human race as a whole, the number of married and marriageable men and women are practically equal.” (See Encyclopædia Britannica Supplement, vol. 4, pp. 222, 223.) For one half of the male population to take even two wives, or one more than is allotted to each man by nature, would be to deprive the other half, of the one wife which nature has provided. Polygamy is, therefore, a violation of the natural rights of man, and as such, should be prohibited by civil law.
The statement that the supply has always equaled the demand in countries where polygamy has been practiced, even if true, loses its force when we consider that the practice has been restricted to the wealthy and powerful. Even in Utah, among the modern polygamists, the number of wives is restricted by a property qualification, and even then the supply has not equaled the demand, as will be shown further on. All such restrictions, based on property or other qualifications, are inconsistent with the equal rights of man and the principles of our free Government.
The Mormon community in Utah is a practical and forcible illustration of the fact that polygamy is an abnormal state of society. It is an acknowledged fact that this community does not furnish the excess of females required to meet the demand for a plurality of wives, their offspring there, as elsewhere, being about equally divided between the sexes. This demand has been met by the efforts of missionaries who have induced women, in some cases wives and mothers, who have deserted their families, to join the Mormon community, and add another wife to the already well-supplied Mormon husband. To say that the females drawn from non-polygamous districts to furnish women for polygamous communities do not materially alter the proportionate number of marriageable men and women in those districts, does not in the least militate against the argument. Having shown that in principle it violates the inalienable rights of men, the limited extent of its practice cannot be advanced in support of the institution. The State should not abolish its laws against polygamy (thus giving it legal sanction), and then wait until one half of the male population of the country are deprived of their rights, in order to prove that the practice would invade natural rights. As well wait until the seals are destroyed, to prove that the present method of killing will destroy them, before enacting laws against their destruction. The necessity of the Government’s thus taking precautionary measures, was advocated by Secretary Blaine in the recent seal-fishery dispute, and admitted by the English premier. All the government needs to know is that the practice will invade the rights of men; its duty in the matter is then made clear. It must prohibit the practice in order to preserve those rights.
Having shown that the practice of polygamy invades the rights of man to the undivided companionship of a wife, we will next show that it is an invasion of the natural rights of woman to the undivided companionship of a husband, which nature by its producing as many men as women, proves to be her natural right.
The husband by taking the second wife, invades the right of the first wife to the undivided companionship of a husband. To say that both women voluntarily accept the relation, does not place the matter beyond the jurisdiction of civil government, because the government cannot sanction the invasion of natural rights, even though the parties are agreed. It may be objected that because the government cannot sanction a practice, it does not follow that it must prohibit it. It is true the government cannot be regarded as sanctioning a practice by not prohibiting it when the practice does not come within its jurisdiction. But since the practice of polygamy has been proved to be a violation of natural rights, the very thing which governments are established to prevent, it comes within the rightful jurisdiction of civil government, and a failure to prohibit it is to give it legal sanction. The absence of law prohibiting a practice, when that practice comes within the jurisdiction of civil government, is to give the practice the sanction and protection of government. To illustrate: A government has no law against murder. A man is murdered, and his friends bring the murderer before the authorities for punishment; but the parties are told that the State has no law against murder, and the order is given that the murderer be set at liberty. By this the government sanctions the act of murder. A failure to prohibit the act, makes the government responsible for it. Thus it is with the invasion of the right of the first wife by her husband’s taking other wives. A failure on the part of the government to prohibit it, gives the act the sanction of the government; and having by its failure to prohibit the act given legal sanction to it, it cannot contradict itself by declaring the marriage illegal at some subsequent time, in order to secure to the woman her rights. The law ought, therefore, to prohibit polygamy, that it may be faithful to its duty of securing to all its citizens their natural rights.
Neither can the plea that polygamy is practiced as a part of the religion of the Mormon, affect the argument. No religious practices, however sacred in the eyes of the believer, can receive the sanction of a just government, if they infringe upon the rights of others.
Again: To protect the Mormons in their practice of polygamy on account of their religious convictions, and prohibit the same practice among others, would be class-legislation, which is opposed to the principles of free government. If polygamy is permitted in Utah, it must be permitted in every State and Territory in the Union. If this permission is granted to the Mormon, it must also be granted to the “Gentile”; and since the “Gentile” has not the religious convictions which alone make order possible in a polygamous society, it would be destructive of the family relation, and, through that, the destruction of civilized government itself.
For these reasons, we arraign this whole system as unnatural, an infringement of human rights, a menace to the good order of society, and at variance with the practice of all enlightened nations, and maintain that it may be suppressed by law without infringing any principle of Religious Liberty, and must be suppressed, in order to preserve Civil Liberty.