The Gospel Messenger of Mt. Morris, Ill., not long ago published a short series of articles entitled, “Twenty Reasons for Observing the First Day of the Week.” The twentieth and last reason which appeared in the Messenger of June 24, 1890, begins as follows:—
When compelled to work on the first day of the week, we break no law, and come under no curse. There are times when we must work on Sunday,—not for the sake of covetousness, but from sheer necessity. When thus compelled to work, we have no fourth commandment thundering its curses against us. We dread no penalty, for we break no law. No law says, “Thou shalt do no manner of work on Sunday.”
Well, well; and this is given as a reason for observing the first day of the week! Yet it is all true. But a better reason for not keeping that day could not have been given. In the face of such an admission as this, all other alleged reasons for observing the first day of the week must be as sounding brass and a tinkling cymbal to him who looks to God and to his word to learn his duty. The writer admits that no law is broken when work is performed on Sunday, because there is no divine law regulating its observance. But where there is no law there is not only no penalty but no obligation. Law is given for the purpose of making known duty. What “reason” can there be for doing that which it is not our duty to do? (See Luke 17: 10.)
To fear God and keep his commandments is declared to be the whole duty of man. Eccl. 12: 13. But, according to this writer’s admission—and his admission is correct—there is no commandment of God requiring the keeping of the first day of the week. Therefore, such observance must be outside of man’s duty; in other words, a work of supererogation, the doctrine of which, like the Sunday institution itself, belongs to the Roman Catholic Church.
Again, Christ’s commission to his disciples is that they shall go and preach the gospel to every creature, teaching them to observe all things whatsoever he has commanded. But upon this writer’s own showing, Sunday-keeping is not one of the things which Christ commanded. “No law,” he asserts, “says, ‘Thou shalt do no manner of work on Sunday.’” Then the conclusion is unavoidable that to teach Sunday-keeping is not a part of the gospel.
The writer of the twenty “reasons” continues his twentieth reason thus:—
We love the day on which Jesus rose from the dead, and, like all antiquity, we make it a day to rejoice in.
Yes; Ephraim was joined to his idols, and loved the work of his own hands, too. But of all such love and worship God asks, “Who hath required this at your hand?” Christ condemned the observance of man-made institutions. Quoting from Isaiah, he said, “In vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.”
“Like all antiquity.” A very fit reason for observing so groundless an institution as Sunday-keeping! Dr. Adam Clarke appropriately rebuked such “reasons” when he said, “There are many ungodly opinions which are more than a thousand years old.” Antiquity consecrated Friday also.
The writer of these reasons, Mr. James Evans, of Beatrice, Neb., very truly, if not intentionally, says, “Like all antiquity, we make it a day to rejoice in.” God never made Sunday a sacred or holy day, nor put upon it any pre-eminence whatever above other days. All that has been done for the day in this way has been done by man. From the first, from the remotest antiquity, it has been but a man-made institution. No one has ever been able to trace it to a divine source. W. A. C.