HAS ANY MAN ASCENDED TO HEAVEN?
Ans.—The apparent contradiction between these two texts is only on the surface. When we take into consideration the subject in reference to which the declarations were made, and the purpose had in view, all difficulty disappears. The passage in Kings says that Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven; and in John 3:13 Christ says that no man hath ascended up to heaven. As a matter of fact, both Enoch and Elijah had been taken up bodily into heaven before Christ spoke these words to Nicodemus. But for the purpose which Christ brings to view, it was true that no man had then ascended to heaven. And what was that purpose?—Paul reveals it in Rom. 10:6 when he says, “Who shall ascend into heaven?” and then explains himself by adding in parenthesis, “that is, to bring Christ down from above.” Thus it is clear that to ascend to heaven merely as a matter of fact, or of personal experience, and to ascend for the purpose of coming back, to bring back Christ, or to bring revelations from thence, are two separate and distinct things; and any number of persons might ascend in the first sense, and yet it be true that in the second sense no man had ascended. In the first sense we have the historical record that Enoch and Elijah ascended to heaven; while it was in the second sense that Christ used the language to Nicodemus. “No man hath ascended.” Enoch and Elijah did not ascend to heaven, or were not taken to heaven, for the purpose of gathering a knowledge of heavenly things, and then coming back to instruct their fellow-men in reference to these things. But it was of these very heavenly things of which Christ was speaking to Nicodemus, when he said that no man had ascended to heaven: that is, for this purpose, to come back and impart to men a knowledge of the heavenly mysteries. So with reference to the subject of which Christ was speaking, John 3:12, 13 may be paraphrased thus: “If I have told you about earthly things, which men can know for themselves, and ye believe not, how shall ye believe me if I shall tell about heavenly things, which are beyond your knowledge? And, moreover, no man has ever ascended to heaven to learn its mysteries, and then come back and reveal them to you; but I, the Son of man, who came down from heaven, have been in heaven; and my knowledge and understanding of heavenly things is as perfect and complete as if I were personally there, as I am in spirit always there; and hence my testimony should be received.” The whole tenor of Christ’s conversation with Nicodemus shows this to be his meaning. But this, it will be seen at once, has no conflicting bearing on the statement that Enoch and Elijah, historically considered, were long before translated from earth to heaven, as types of those who will be likewise translated at the last day. 1 Cor. 15:51, 52.