A FEDERATION OF CHURCHES

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 17, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 7.

Read the full edition

“A FEDERATION OF CHURCHES.”

BY ELDER R. F. COTTRELL.
(Ridgeway, N. Y.)
The subject indicated by this quoted heading is being agitated by certain self-styled “Reformers” of the present time. They set forth their plan of union as follows:—
The idea is that the various churches unite to form a federal union somewhat similar to the union between the States, in which there shall be no renunciation by the churches, of their peculiarities or independent organizations, but which shall render possible a Federal Council through which the influence and efforts of all Christians might be brought to bear for the accomplishment of common ends. In this way, it is suggested, the united power of the churches might be brought to bear more effectually upon legislators and other departments of the Government in its action on the Sabbath, temperance, and other social and moral questions. In this way, too, the work of the whole Church could be more effectually directed to the evangelization of the irreligious classes, and a united front presented against the pretensions and assaults of Romanism.
Let us examine this proposed union. If the churches were united in all the truth,—in all the faith and practice of the teachings of the Scriptures,—they would “all speak the same thing,” and there would be “no division” among them, but they would be “perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.” 1 Cor. 1: 10. The “peculiarities” which divide the various sects are the result of various errors: for two positions directly opposed to each other cannot both be true. But they do not propose a renunciation of errors and a union in the truth. They say, “There shall be no renunciation by the churches, of their peculiarities or independent organizations.” They are to retain their various and contradictory creeds, which include all their false doctrines, but unite to form a federation “for the accomplishment of common ends.”
And what are these common ends?—To get the control of the civil government. It is, as they say, that “the united power of the churches might be brought to bear more effectually upon legislators and other departments of the government”—a sham union to obtain political power!
The apostles inculcated obedience to civil rulers. And they exhorted that “supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men; for kings, and for all that are in authority”—for what purpose?—“That we [Christians] may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty.” The thing desired in these prayers is, that the Government may be so ruled by Providence that the churches may be left to the enjoyment of their religion in a quiet and peaceable way, without interference from the Government. This is all the apostles asked of civil rulers. They formed no political scheme to correct the government of the empire, but were content to obey its laws, accept of and enjoy such privileges as it granted, and attend to their own business under their great commission of persuading all men everywhere to be reconciled to God.
Mark the double-dealing of these “reformers” toward Catholics. At one time they solicit their aid, as a part of the Church of Christ, to procure legislation in behalf of Sunday, an institution which “the church” justly claims to have originated as a Christian institution; but anon they tell us that by a federation “the whole Church” could present “a united front” “against the pretensions and assaults of Romanism.” They want the aid of Catholics to turn our free secular Government into a hierarchy, and then they wish to run it themselves exclusively, presenting “a united front” against their best friends and allies. Will they be able to do it?