A HARD TIME OF IT

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 10, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 6.

Read the full edition

A HARD TIME OF IT.

Were the subject not so serious, and the consequences not so momentous, it would be truly amusing to note how people will try to twist and turn, crawl, creep, walk, run, jump, turn somersault, cross themselves, get hopelessly snarled up in logic, and tripped up by facts, in their frantic but futile endeavors to crowd the Sabbath out one side of the obligations now binding upon Christians. Witness the following exhibition of high and lofty tumbling by the editor of the Christian Oracle, of Dec. 25, 1890. He is answering an argument of the Interior of Chicago, showing the immutability and perpetuity of the decalogue, and we note these declarations: “The decalogue has become obsolete, and has been ‘taken out of the way.’” “The decalogue as such, was given to the literal descendants of Abraham through Isaac, and was intended as a part of the Mosaic institution, to serve a temporary purpose, which purpose was accomplished when the Christ came.”
Having thus made a clean sweep of the decalogue, now something must be done to save all its principles; for every one must acknowledge that the decalogue contains the summary of all morality. This he undertakes to do in the following paragraph, and his theory now begins to run into trouble:—
“The principles of piety and morality are older than the decalogue, and were binding upon men so far as they were able to know and to do them, before they were formulated and written on the tables of stone; and are still binding, though the ten commandments have been abrogated.”
The reader will please notice the remarkable statements of this paragraph: 1. The principles of piety and morality are introduced. These must embrace all piety and morality; for there is no limitation. 2. These were “formulated and written on the tables of stone.” Then what have we on the tables of stone?—A formulated and written expression of all the principles of piety and morality. But the Sabbath commandment was quite a portion of what was written upon the tables. Then this Sabbath commandment had in it piety and morality.
Do you try to squirm away from this conclusion, and say that it had not? Then God in endeavoring to formulate and write out the principles of piety and morality, made a mistake, and spoiled the formula by inserting a large commandment which had in it neither piety nor morality!
And these principles, we are assured, “are still binding, though the ten commandments have been abrogated.” But how is this? We have just been told that the ten commandments were a document in which the principles of piety and morality were “formulated.” Now, did this formula correctly express those principles? If it did, what was the matter with the formula? And if the principles were to remain, why abolish the formula?
Now apparently seeing that it had gone too far for its own safety, the Oracle (and what an oracle!) throws in another paragraph to cover up, retract, and modify its statements, and confuse the mind of the reader. In the usual run-way it goes on to argue that the Mosaic dispensation has given place to the Christian, and that the principles of the decalogue are now binding only to the extent that they have been incorporated in the new. It then indulges in one of those slippery, deceitful statements so characteristic of error, as follows: “But it happens that all of the ten commandments in substance have been incorporated in the new covenant, except the fourth. Why is it omitted from the new?”
“All of the ten in substance.” “In substance!” What does that mean? Does it mean that we have less or more than the people of God had back there? If more, what was lacking then? If not so much, what is lacking now from what they had? If we are to have the “substance” of the commandments which do remain, why not have them just as they were expressed before? Why any change? This is the question we would like to have answered. But the Oracle knows as well as we, that all the apostles have said is only a reference to, or quotation from, the ten commandments, just as brief as it could be made, and have the reference sure. Hence all this blind scramble to get around the matter.
It then attempts to illustrate the case by reference to a State which has occasion to adopt a new constitution, as Iowa did a few years ago, that portion only of the old constitution being binding which is incorporated into the new. This at first sight looks very specious; but it is not pertinent to the case at all. For when a new constitution is adopted, it is done with all the publicity and formality with which the old constitution was adopted. But there is nothing at all of this kind in the New Testament with reference to the ten commandments; and, secondly, when it is proposed to adopt a new constitution, it is because the old is considered to be imperfect, and to need revising: it is not explicit enough, or it needs to have something added to it or taken from it. Was this the case with the ten commandments? After implying so strongly the necessity of some change, will the Oracle please tell what change was needed in any of the ten commandments, except the fourth, which it is trying so hard to get rid of?
But the fourth commandment, it says plainly, was omitted from the new covenant. And now it finds itself in another dilemma; for, lo! it finds itself setting apart a day for rest and worship, and devoting it to all the purposes for which the Sabbath was ordained. And having thrown away the only commandment in all the Bible for such an institution, it now has to patch up some kind of an apology in defense of its practice. So it makes another grand whirl to get a Sabbath back into its creed. After taking care to state that the seventh day (italics his) was never required of any but the Jews, it says: “The septenary principle, that is, the setting apart one seventh part of time for rest from secular pursuits, and which seems to be woven into the general order of things, is carried over to the new dispensation, and appears in the first day or Lord’s day.” How very accommodatingly, to be sure, the machine works. Something new now appears—“a septenary principle,” “woven into the general order of things.” Where did this principle come from? and when and how was it introduced? Of course it was older than the decalogue; for it was formulated there among the principles of piety and morality of that document. But how did it exist, and how was it expressed, before that time? And when the Lord came to formulate it in the decalogue, he fixed it to the seventh day, and stated its object to be, a grand memorial of his creative work. But it fared hard, it seems, with this commandment: for while all the other commandments re-appear “in substance,” this is entirely left out of the new covenant, not even appearing there “in substance.” But, lo! the principle turns up serenely all the same, without any formula or substance. And the next marvel is that it now appears on the first day of the week; and it turns up for an entirely different purpose—not to commemorate the creation at all, but Christ’s resurrection from the dead.
But we would like to know when and by whom this was “carried over,” as asserted, “to the new dispensation?” Christ, the only one competent to establish the new covenant, in all his instruction concerning its principles, said not one word about the first day, and the septenary principle coming over and lighting on that day. And the apostles have no right to bring it in, after the covenant was ratified by the death of Christ upon the cross. Again we ask, How has all this jugglery been performed?
But it will be seen that the Oracle has given the day first too much of a Sabbath cast, and now it has to take another tack to fix this up, which it does, as follows: “It [that is, this septenary principle requiring one seventh part of time for rest from secular pursuits] is not, however, the chief feature of the Lord’s day observance, which has for its principal object the commemoration of Christ’s resurrection from the dead.”
If this argument has ever been matched, the curiosity has not fallen under our notice. First, the whole decalogue is wiped out, and taken out of the way. But, lo! it is found that it was composed of principles which existed before, and which survived its abrogation. Then the commandments, formulating these principles, re-appear in the new covenant, but only “in substance.” But hold! one of these commandments has disappeared altogether. But we are observing a day of rest and worship, [which that commandment calls for]; and what shall we do about this? It is then suddenly discovered that there is a “septenary principle, requiring one seventh part of time to be devoted to rest from secular pursuits,” which, of course, makes it a religious matter; and this is “woven into the general order of things,” and so cannot be dispensed with, though the commandment for it has disappeared bodily. When formulated by Jehovah, it was confined to the seventh day; but when the principle re-appears in the New Testament without a formula, lo! it turns up on the first day. And then it is found that this septenary principle is not the reason, after all, for keeping the first day; for that is kept to commemorate the resurrection of Christ! But why Christ’s resurrection should be commemorated every week, does not appear. It does, however, appear that it is not needed to commemorate Christ’s resurrection at all; for the Bible has explicitly given one memorial of his resurrection; namely, baptism; and the Bible does not repeat itself by giving two memorials of the same event. What, then, becomes of such an institution, and such an argument to defend it?
We respectfully submit that any one who has such a crooked path to follow, and such a theory to maintain, has “a hard time of it.”