WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH? AND IN WHAT DID THE CHANGE CONSIST?
By W. A. C.
MANY are the evasions made by those who seek to cling to that broken reed, the Sunday Sabbath, in view of the claim that it has been instituted by other than divine appointment. It is said by some that Seventh-day Adventists claim that the pope changed the Sabbath. To offset this, it is affirmed that there was no pope before the fifth or sixth century, but that there is abundant proof that Sunday was observed long before this; and consequently they pronounce this claim to be false. Others say we hold that the Sabbath was changed at the Council of Laodicea in A. D. 364, and then produce evidence that Sunday was observed prior to this time, and consequently condemn this position. Still others say we claim that Constantine changed the Sabbath by an edict passed in the year 321 A. D., and then read testimony from Tertullian, Irenæus, Clement, Justin Martyr, and others of the early fathers, showing that long even before this the first day of the week was observed by the majority, at least, of professed Christians, as a day for meeting together for religious worship. This is stating the case as plainly as we are able to state it in few words. To the superficial reasoner, or to the individual whose mind has been clouded with Sunday fog, this might seem a sufficient statement of the case, however, to put the matter at rest, and to forever silence Seventh-day Adventists on this question. But we think the matter will bear a little further consideration. It will be observed that in each case the fact that meetings were held on the first day of the week before a certain time, is offered as sufficient evidence to disprove the claim that the change of the Sabbath occurred at or subsequent to that time. But is such the case? Meeting together on the first day of the week for certain religious services, though done regularly, in itself considered, proves nothing in regard to the change of the Sabbath, any more than the fact that regular weekly prayer-meetings are now held on Wednesday or Thursday proves a change from Sunday-keeping. The change of the Sabbath did not consist in the mere holding of meetings on Sunday. Meetings could have been held on that day, or on any other day, regularly, and not have affected the Sabbath in any way whatever. This leads us to inquire in what the change of the Sabbath did consist. We have no disposition to deny that the practice of meeting together on the first day of the week in honor of the resurrection of Christ, very early obtained among Christians. There was no sin in their meeting together on that day for religious services, any more than there is in Christians now meeting together regularly in the middle of the week for prayer-meeting. In Acts 2: 46, we learn that the early Christians celebrated the Lord’s supper and had religious meetings daily. Neither did the change of the Sabbath, as we have already observed, lie in the practice of meeting together on the first day of the week. The change consisted in transferring to the first day of the week the honor which God had put upon the seventh day,—in making the first day take the place of the seventh. Herein lay the change. But neither the apostles nor the Christians of the first century did this. No apostle ever said that the first day of the week is a sacred day, or that it should be observed as a rest (Sabbath) day, or in the place of the Sabbath. It was the recognition of this patent fact that caused Neander, in the first edition of his Church History, to say:— “The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intentions of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect,—far from them, and from the early apostolic church, to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday. Perhaps at the end of the second century a false application of this kind had begun to take place; for men appear by this time to have considered laboring on Sunday as a sin.”—Neander’s Church History, translated by H. J. Rose, p. 186. It is in recognition of this fact that Lyman Abbott, in the Christian Union of June 26, 1890, says:— “The current notion that Christ and his apostles substituted the first day of the week for the seventh, is absolutely without any authority in the New Testament.” It is in acknowledgment of this fact that the Catholic Church says:— “Sundays and holy days all stand upon the same foundation; viz., the ordinance of the church.”—Catholic Christian Instructed, p. 203. In like manner Mr. Dana, in the New York Sun of Nov. 10, 1889, said of the Sunday institution:— “It is simply one of the many holy days of the church, and the obligation to observe it is no greater than to observe the others. . . . There is no injunction with regard to it in the New Testament, from which the Christian Church derives its law.” These are truthful statements. But the very transfer of which Neander speaks, and says the apostles and early apostolic church did not make, has been made. The very substitution which Lyman Abbott affirms there is no New Testament authority for warranting a belief that Christ and the apostles made, has been made. Sunday has been made a day of rest. It has had transferred to it the laws of the Sabbath, and has been made to take the place of the seventh day. The question, Who has done this? very naturally arises. If it was not Christ nor the apostles, who was it? Was it Constantine, some particular pope, or some ecclesiastical power? The circumstances which brought about this change we believe to have covered a considerable length of time. The change, as we have explained it, took place gradually. As Neander observes, the sabbatical idea of the observance of the first day had begun to obtain at the end of the second century, as some appeared by this time to have considered labor on Sunday to be a sin. The seventh day had by no means wholly ceased still to be regarded as the Sabbath, as is evident from abundant testimony stating that both days were observed; but a change was taking place. As Rev. George S. Mott, of the American Sabbath Union, in Pearl of Days “Leaflets,” No. 3, says: “Already in the Christian heart, the seventh day was receding and the first was assuming its place.” Coming down to the time of Constantine, we find that this idea of the sabbatical observance of the first day had increased, so much so that, in deference to the sentiment, Constantine passed the following edict in support of its observance as a day of rest:— “Let all the judges and towns-people, and the occupation of all trades, rest on the venerable day of the sun; but let those who are situated in the country freely and at full liberty attend to the business of agriculture; because it often happens that no other day is so fit for sowing corn and planting vines; lest the critical moment being let slip, men should lose the commodities granted by Heaven.”—Schaff’s Church History, vol. 2, chap. 2, sec. 17. This, says Chambers’s Encyclopedia, is “unquestionably the first law, ecclesiastical or civil, by which the sabbatical observance of that day is known to have been observed.” No Seventh-day Adventist claims that this constituted the change of the Sabbath, but it is one of those great land-marks which show that a change of this kind was taking place. This edict, however, does not directly show that Sunday was taking the place of the Sabbath, but simply that it was beginning to be observed as the Sabbath. But we come down half a century later, and we find direct and unmistakable proof that it was assuming the form of a supplanter of the seventh-day Sabbath, the day blessed and set apart by God. The twenty-ninth canon passed at the Council of Laodicea, in A. D. 364, reads as follows:— “Christians shall not Judaize, and be idle on Saturday, but shall work on that day. But the Lord’s day they shall especially honor, and as being Christians, shall, if possible, do no work on that day. If, however, they are found Judaizing, let them be shut out from Christ.”—Hefele’s Hist. Councils, vol. 2, p. 316. This clearly indicates the character the man-made institution was assuming at this time,—an antagonistic supplanter of the divinely appointed day of rest. It will be observed that the canon is itself an evidence that the keeping of the seventh day had not, even at this late date, wholly ceased. There would have been no occasion for the passing of such an order, had there not been Christians who still had respect for the Lord’s Sabbath. But the two institutions could not well occupy the same field at the same time. One must retire. Notice the antagonism. Of the seventh day God said, “In it thou shalt not do any work.” This canon of the same day says, You “shall work on that day.” Of the first day, included with the other of “the six working-days” (Eze. 46: 1), God said, “Shalt thou [thou shalt] work.” Of the same day, this canon says, “Do no work on that day.” Thus was the change slowly but surely, step by step, being brought about, until finally Sunday observance among the professed Christian Church had wholly supplanted the keeping of the Sabbath of the Lord. Thus did a practice, at first simple and apparently innocent, develop, under the direction of the enemy of all righteousness, into a vain tradition and commandment of man, and become a positive and monster evil. And by whom was this change made? It is said by some, if there was such a change as Seventh-day Adventists claim there was, they ought to be able to tell just when it was made, and by whom. In reply, we might ask when the apostasy took place. Paul said there should come a “falling away.” Just when did this occur? Can any one tell? All must admit that it was gradual. A change was likewise made in the ordinance of baptism, sprinkling taking the place of immersion. When did this occur? Again all are forced to say, It was gradual. And so it was with the change of the Sabbath,—it was gradual; but it is none the less a fact. The change was made, and was made by that power that was to “think to change times and laws” (Dan. 7: 25); by that church among which there was to come “a falling away,” and in which “that man of sin [was to] be revealed.” 2 Thess. 2: 3. Alexander Campbell well expressed it in the Bible Advocate of January, 1848, when he said:— “If it be changed, it was that august person changed it who changes times and laws, ex officio. I think his name is Dr. Antichrist.” W. A. C.