AdventAI

IGNORANCE OR DISHONESTY—WHICH?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 5., February 3, 1891

There is published in Boston, Mass., a magazine called, The Children’s New-Church Magazine. There is going through this publication a story entitled, “Teresa, or, The Ten Commandments,” in which the commandments are taken up in order and commented upon. In its February (1891) number, it reaches that commandment which in the Roman Catholic and Lutheran churches is called the third, but in all others, the fourth commandment; namely, the Sabbath commandment. In a way calculated to arrest and impress the minds of children, it dilates upon this commandment.

It endeavors to make the commandment teach Sunday; and can the reader imagine how it attempts to do this? In past volumes of the REVIEW we have quoted from authors who claimed that Nehemiah ordered the gates of Jerusalem to be shut on Sunday, and reproved the people sharply for not keeping that day; and others who claimed that the Israelites kept Sunday in the wilderness, and one who even claimed that God rested on Sunday, and blessed it at the creation. But now comes another, who claims that Christ, by precept and example, taught the people of his day to keep Sunday.

We know the intelligent reader will be inclined at first thought, to pronounce this a slander, as it seems impossible that any one should so affront the knowledge of every New Testament reader, as to set up such a claim. But we will let the article speak for itself; we will let it press its own claims up against the buzz-saw of truth, to be speedily reduced to sawdust and destruction. In the passage we quote below, there are no italics in the original; so the reader will understand that the italics are our own, and that we emphasize the passages to call special attention to them. On page 43, we find the following:—

“‘Sunday is still the Lord’s own day, and our Lord has told us himself how we may please him best on that day. He has not given us a commandment about keeping Sunday in so many words, but he tells us that the Sabbath is made for man, and this is quite enough. It means that we are to keep Sunday in such a way as will do good both to our bodies and souls.’”

“‘Do you think it could be called the best way if people were only selfish and lazy, Shirley?’”

“‘But we are told not to do any work on Sunday, Aunt Letty,’ persisted Shirley.”

“‘Do you not remember how the Lord Jesus set us an example about this?’ said her aunt, gently. ‘He allowed his disciples to gather wheat on Sunday, when they were hungry, and he cured the impotent man, at the pool of Bethesda, on Sunday. Then there was the poor man with the withered hand, who was healed in spite of the bitter remonstrances of the Pharisees.’”

“‘And he saith unto them, Is it lawful to do good on the Sabbath day, or to do evil? To save life or to kill?’ My dear child, we should not be following in the footsteps of our Lord if we kept Sunday in a selfish way. The commandment teaches us not to do unnecessary work—work that hinders ourselves or others from going to church, for example. But at the same time we are taught by the Lord Jesus to do all the good we can on Sunday, and never to be afraid of helping others.”

There are laws against forgery, and securing money under false pretenses, and cruelty to animals and to children. Cannot some means be devised to prevent the latter from being imposed upon by such teaching? for we insist that it is cruelty to them to instill into their young and unsuspecting minds such utterly false ideas. What reader of the New Testament does not know that every utterance of Christ in reference to the Sabbath had reference to the seventh day, not to the first?

“Aunt Letty,” to be sure, does not have the hardihood to assert that Christ has given any commandment about Sunday “in so many words” (which is a little surprising in view of her other assertions), but she falls back behind a presumptuous “he means,” and so declares that, though he says one thing, he means another? Would it not be fully as becoming, and much more truthful, to allow that the Son of God knew what he wanted to say, and meant what he said, rather than to assert that he has told us how we may please him, and taught us his will, and set us an example, about keeping a day, in reference to which, so far as the record goes, he never said a single word nor performed a single act.