ALL MADE RIGHTEOUS.
“Please explain Rom. 5: 18, 19, in reference to the claim that the ‘all’ and ‘many’ who are made righteous by ‘one’ (Christ) are the same ‘all’ and ‘many’ that are made sinners by the ‘one’ (Adam), and that therefore this scripture teaches the salvation of all.” J. W. R.
Answer.—The “all” and “many,” in each instance, cover the same number, and that is, the whole human family from Adam to the end. Within the limitations of the subject Paul is here discussing, just as many as are made sinners in Adam, are made righteous in Christ; and the terms take in all men. But this does not prove that all men are to be saved to eternal life, as will plainly appear from a brief consideration of the circumstances of the case.
Verse 12 reads: “Wherefore as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned; or (margin) ‘in whom [Adam] all have sinned.’” The facts here stated are, that (1) by the act of Adam sin came into the world; (2) by this sin death also came into the world; (3) death then necessarily passed upon all men; that is, all who should ever live in this world became subject to death; for Adam could not transmit to his posterity any higher nature than that which he himself possessed, which was then subject to death; and then (4) all men must be considered to have sinned in Adam so far as to become subject to this death; for death comes only by sin; and all, irrespective of their own personal characters, are subject to death. So far, but no farther, were all “made sinners,” by one man’s (Adam’s) disobedience.
A plan of redemption through Christ was then presented, by the provisions of which Adam was placed on a new probation, and a probation was secured for all his posterity on their own account. They were all, irrespective of character, subject to death; their life must, after awhile, come to an end; but by the provision made, an opportunity was given them to use their life-time in such a way that their own actions and character would determine their eternal destiny, without any reference to what Adam had done. But some one might rise up and say, How can this be? I am already subject to death through Adam; the time will come when I must die; what is the use, then, of my trying to seek eternal life through the plan of salvation? The reply is, that this very plan provides that all men shall be released from the death they die in Adam, that they may give account of themselves to God. And as this death comes upon all indiscriminately, upon good and bad alike, without respect to character, so the resurrection from this death will come to all alike, good and bad, without respect to character, that they may be judged for life or death, upon their own personal account.
This resurrection of all men to life, must, according to the plan of redemption, be an absolute certainty; for it would be utterly impossible that a person’s actions, during a period of time which is to him terminated by death, could be taken as the determining factors of his eternal destiny, unless he is raised from that death to be judged in reference to those actions, that he “may receive the things done in his body, according to that he hath done, whether it be good or bad.” 2 Cor. 5: 10.
This includes both good and bad. And this is called in 1 Cor. 15: 22, being made alive in Christ: “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.” Some one may say, I can understand how this could be with reference to the righteous; but how can it be so in the cases of the wicked?—In this way: when the plan of salvation was laid, it necessitated, as stated above, the restoration of allp. 73 men to life from the death they die in Adam; Christ is the author of that plan; in him and through him it will be carried out. And all who are made alive through the necessary workings of that plan, abstractly considered, without any reference to their characters, may be properly said, on account of Christ’s relation to the plan, to be made alive in Christ. In Adam, as the sinner, all die; in Christ, as a part of his redemptive plan, all are made alive. And this prepares us for the application of Rom. 5: 19; for those who die in Adam are called “sinners”; therefore all who are released from that death in Christ must, so far, be called “righteous”; that is, all men, indiscriminately, are made sinners in Adam just so far as to be subject to death, and no farther; and all men, indiscriminately, are accounted righteous in Christ, just so far as to be released from that death, and no farther.
But all this determines nobody’s salvation; for being released from the Adamic death, and thus placed beyond the effects of his fall, every person’s own life and individual experience then comes into the account, to determine his eternal destiny: if he is found righteous, he lives on eternally; if a sinner, he goes into the second death, which is eternal because no provision is made for a resurrection therefrom.
The thought may occur to some that this cannot be a correct presentation of the subject, inasmuch as character does have something to do with the resurrection; for the righteous dead rise first, before the wicked are raised; and the righteous are raised in honor, glory, and incorruption. To which it may be replied, that the resurrection itself depends on the redemptive plan, not on individual character; but those features named above are only concomitants of the resurrection, in the cases of the righteous; and these, without affecting at all the propositions above set forth, do depend on character, to be determined by the investigative judgment, which precedes the second coming of Christ.