Review of Article on Page 164

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 17, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 11.

Read the full edition

Review of Article on Page 164

THE MILLENNIAL DAWN.—NO. 3.

Review of Article on Page 164.

What our brother means by saying, as he did last week, that we call the second coming of Christ “the third ‘parousia,’” we do not know; for we have never held such a position, and have never used such an expression.
As the present paper is devoted principally to a discussion of Rev. 20: 5, it will only be necessary for us here to recapitulate some of the arguments we presented on this subject in the REVIEW of Jan. 28, 1890. The text reads as follows: “But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.”
We can readily understand why this text gives the nightmare to every Age to Come theory. If only the righteous dead have part in the first resurrection, as this and the following verse declare, and no others are alive till the thousand years end, what of all the finely painted pictures and pleasant songs of Christ at the head of a company of his chosen followers reigning over unconverted men, and bringing them to a knowledge of the gospel, thus putting his enemies under his feet during this time?—They vanish into thin air. And so this text must be treated in some way so that it shall not preclude the living of men upon this earth during the thousand years. This is attempted in two ways: the first is to call the text an interpolation, and throw it out; the second is to deprive the word “live” of its literal meaning. But neither of these ways, nor both together, will accomplish the end in view.
In proof that the text is not genuine, the claim is urged that it is not found in the Sinaitic manuscript. To which we replied, that the Sinaitic manuscript has been before the world ever since 1859, and eminent scholars who show that they have consulted the manuscript by quoting it upon other texts, say nothing about its omission on this. Thus, the Emphatic Diaglott says nothing about its being omitted in the Sinaitic, though noticing its omission in the Vatican and Syriac. Its omission in the Vatican is attributed to an oversight, as it is found in A. B. C.,—three of the oldest manuscripts extant.
Alford, in his New Testament, notices the variations of the Sinaitic manuscript in other places, but says nothing of its omitting this text in this place. On the other hand, he utters a sharp criticism upon some who misinterpret the text.
But more than this, Tertullian, A. D. 200, whose writings antedate any manuscript whatsoever, in vol. 3, page 431, quotes the text as it stands in the Common Version, and treats it as a genuine portion of the book of Revelation. If, therefore, it is omitted in the Sinaitic, such omission must be accounted for as in the Vatican,—as an error of transcribers. It is such considerations as these, doubtless, which have led such modern and close critics as Meyer, the great German commentator, and the authors of the Revised Version to retain the passage as genuine.
But we showed further, that even if we throw out the first clause of Rev. 20: 5, it does not materially affect the question; for the great fact still remains, that there are to be two resurrections, as is plainly shown by other scriptures; and that in the first resurrection the righteous only are included, and in the second, the wicked only; that some time elapses between them; and the only time that can be found is the thousand years of Revelation 20. This fact is fatal to every conception of a reign of Christ and his saints on earth among men during this time.
Another turn is now taken to avoid this dilemma; and that is, as set forth in the article under review, that the “living again” does not mean a raising up to life from the dead, but only the bringing of men back to the original perfection they lost in Adam; and to accomplish this, the whole life of Adam, 930 years, is added to the present allotment of seventy years, making up the thousand years. But this, it strikes us, is doing a little better by the degenerate reprobates of these last days, than by the father of the race himself. If the language, “The rest of the dead lived not again,” is not to be taken in its literal and obvious sense, then we are all afloat in regard to the interpretation of the Scriptures. Those who live and reign with Christ, live in contrast with the condition they were in when they were “beheaded.” Verse 4. But if this means only a state of perfection, how is it that this class reach it at once, while in the cases of the others it takes a thousand years to accomplish it? And if life in the one case means perfection, then the second death (verses 6, 14) means, not destruction, but only humiliation and degradation. If language can be used in such an illegitimate manner for such an illegitimate purpose, then let us say nothing more about the arguments of those who defend Sunday-keeping and the immortality of the soul; for no worse break was ever made by any of them than this. A position dependent upon such support ought not to find any countenance among Seventh-day Adventists.
Beyond this millennial age, says Bro. R., revelation is silent, and so he stops. It would be well for his position if revelation was silent there. But that is just the trouble; it is not silent, and what it says sounds the death-knell of his theory. “The rest of the dead,” who come up on the breadth of the earth, are deceived by Satan, and with him destroyed. And thus, according to the Age to Come theory, whatever is gained during the thousand years, is lost at its close. The sun which had shone so fairly for a thousand years, is eclipsed at last. The dark shadow of rebellion and apostasy falls upon the triumphs which the gospel had made for a thousand years. This is the fatal flaw in all these schemes. The Bible presents no such inconsistency. How much better to take the statements of the Scripture as they stand in consecutive order, and in their plain, obvious meaning; namely, that when Christ comes, he comes not to be where his people are, but to take them to be where he is, in the mansions he has gone to prepare for them (John 14: 1–3); that they have right to the tree of life which is in the city, the New Jerusalem (Rev. 22: 1, 2); that then is heard in heaven the voice of much people, chanting the songs of the redeemed (Rev. 15: 2, 3; 19: 1); that the saints do not possess the earth till it is made new; and it is not made new till the wicked are destroyed at the end of the thousand years (2 Pet. 3: 7; Rev. 20: 9–11); that the thousand years which the saints spend with Christ in the New Jerusalem in heaven, is none too long a time for them to accomplish the work of judgment committed unto them, the judgment of evil angels and a wicked world (Dan. 7: 22; Rev. 20: 4; 1 Cor. 6: 2, 3); that the city does not come down till the end of the thousand years, and the saints then descend with it, and then the wicked, being raised, can come up around the camp of the saints as Rev. 20: 9 declares; and then the judgment written against them is executed, fire from heaven devours them, the perdition of ungodly men comes (2 Pet. 3: 7), the earth melts with fervent heat and flees away (verses 10–12; Rev. 20: 11), then to be succeeded by a new heavens and new earth wherein the righteous shall evermore dwell. Rev. 21: 5, 1; 2 Pet. 3: 13. With such a view all is harmonious. Why not accept it?
One point, however, may occur to the reader which may not look to him exactly harmonious and plain; and that is, 1 Cor. 15: 26: “The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death.” This we place at the beginning of the thousand years; and it may be asked how death is then destroyed, when death itself is not cast into the lake of fire till the end of the thousand years, according to Rev. 20: 14. The answer is, that the enemies spoken of in 1 Corinthians 15, are the enemies of Christ and his people. Death is one of these; for if he can hold them forever under his power, Christ can never give them the promised kingdom. But as such enemy, he shall be destroyed; and he is destroyed so far as the Lord’s people are concerned, when they are released forever from his power, as they are at the coming of Christ. As the enemy of the wicked, death is never to be destroyed; but this is not the apostle’s subject in 1 Corinthians 15.