Review of Article on Page 147

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 10, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 10.

Read the full edition

Review of Article on Page 147.

1. It is not a little surprising that any one who favors the principles of interpretation adopted by Adventists should for a moment suppose that the dashing to pieces and removing of earthly kingdoms is a moral revolution to be accomplished by the preaching of the truth. This is exactly the way the opponents of Adventists interpret the smiting and dashing to pieces of the great image of Daniel 2, by the stone cut out of the mountain without hands. And if this work has been going on already for sixteen years, as Bro. R. holds, we ask, What has yet been accomplished?—Nothing. The image is not yet very badly damaged. It does not know that anything yet has smitten it. And at this rate, what will be accomplished in the next twenty-four years, during which he says this work is to go on?—Nothing at all. Besides, the image is to be smitten by a stone cut “out of the mountain without hands,” not by a “broadsword” in the hands of the Church.
2. The Scriptures teach that the time of the end began at the end of the 1260 years, in 1798, not in 1874. A period of forty years set apart as a “harvest” time corresponding to the forty connecting the Jewish and the gospel dispensation, we know nothing about, as the Scriptures say nothing about any such time?
3. We now come to the texts, Ps. 110 : 1 and 1 Cor. 15 : 24-26, upon the application of which so much depends. That these two portions of Scripture apply to the same time and the same events, is evident. Bro. R., if we understand his position, places the end of the reign and the giving up of the kingdom by Christ, at the end of the thousand years; we place them at the beginning of that time. On these points we take issue; and here we are a thousand years apart. Let us, then, look carefully at what the inspired writers say on this point, and let us abide by their testimony.
Ps. 110 : 1 brings to view the Father and the Son in converse respecting the great transaction they are carrying forward with reference to this world. Thus: “The Lord [Jehovah, the Father] said unto my Lord [Christ, the Son], Sit thou [the Son] at my [the Father’s] right hand, until I [the Father] make thine [the Son’s] enemies thy footstool;” or which would be the same thing, “till I put thine enemies under thy feet.”
The Son at the Father’s right hand is, of course, upon his throne (Heb. 8 : 1), and if on his throne, then reigning with him. Rev. 3 : 21. If the saints are ever to reign with Christ, as they certainly are (Rev. 20 : 4), then Christ at some time reigns with his Father upon his throne.
In harmony with this is the testimony of Zech. 6 : 12, 13: “Behold the man whose name is The BRANCH [i. e., Christ]; and he shall grow up out of his place, and he shall build the temple of the Lord [i. e., the temple of Jehovah, and this refers to the part Christ is to act in bringing back the world to God, and establishing his authority over men]: even he shall . . . sit and rule upon his throne; and he shall be a priest upon his throne; and the counsel of peace shall be between them both.” This speaks of Christ’s reigning upon the throne with his Father, in harmony with the other texts referred to, and applies at the same time. But here another fact is added; namely, that he is at the same time a priest upon his throne. So the reign of Christ with his Father upon his throne is at some time while he is fulfilling the office of priest.
In the light of these facts, let us paraphrase Ps. 110 : 1. We may suppose the Father addressing the Son in some such terms as these: “Sit thou, my Son, on my right hand; reign with me, and be a priest upon my throne, until I put all thine enemies under thy feet.” This is something that God does, not the Son; and something that takes place in heaven, not on earth; for Christ performs no part of his priestly ministry upon this earth. Heb. 8 : 4.
4. We will now prove that this reign and this kingdom is the same as that spoken of in 1 Cor. 15 : 24-26; or, rather, we will let Paul prove it; for one glance at his statements will show this very clearly: “Then cometh the end, when he [Christ] shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father.” This cannot be Christ’s own throne, of which he speaks in Rev. 3 : 21; for when he once takes that throne, which is the throne of his father David, Gabriel himself assures us that he shall reign forever, and that of his kingdom there shall positively be “no end.” Luke 1 : 32, 33. It must, therefore, be the kingdom which he holds in connection with his Father, of which he also speaks in Rev. 3 : 21, which is the same as that spoken of in Ps. 110 : 1. And that this is the one which he gives up, is further evident from the fact that he is to hold this only to a certain time; namely, till God puts his enemies under his feet. And as God at a certain time inducted him into this office,—“Sit thou at my right hand,”—so, the object having been accomplished for which he sits there, he, as a matter of course, surrenders to the Father what he then received from him.
We now read on in 1 Cor. 15 : 24: “When he shall have put down all rule and all authority and power.” Who is it that puts down all rule and authority and power?—God the Father, according to Ps. 110 : 1. What rule and authority and power does he put down?—All that is opposed to the Son—“Thine enemies.” How does he (God) put these opposing forces down?—He makes them his (Christ’s) footstool, or puts his enemies under his feet. Verse 25: “For he must reign.” Who must reign?—Christ must reign on the throne with his Father: “Sit thou,” or reign, “at my right hand,” says the Father to the Son. Ps. 110 : 1. Paul continues, “till he hath put all enemies under his feet.” Whose enemies are here referred to?—Christ’s enemies. “Thine enemies,” says God to the Son, in the psalm quoted. Who subdues these enemies?—God the Father: “Till I make thine enemies thy footstool.” Under whose feet are these enemies put?—Under Christ’s feet: “Till I make thine enemies thy footstool.” Thus the parallel is easily traced between Ps. 110 : 1 and 1 Cor. 15 : 24, 25. And it is demonstrated that both passages refer to the same time and the same events.
5. The putting of these enemies under Christ’s feet is their destruction: for Paul goes right on and says: “The last enemy that shall be destroyed [that is, put under Christ’s feet] is death.”
We now ask the reader to consider carefully all these facts: (1.) Christ at some time reigns, not on his own throne, but with his Father on his throne; he is a king upon his throne during this time, or holds a kingdom conjointly with his Father. (2.) During the same time he is a priest on this throne with his Father. (3.) This reign is limited; for it lasts only till his enemies are made his footstool. (4.) It is God who makes Christ’s enemies his footstool. (5.) When Christ takes his own throne, he reigns forever: that kingdom he never gives up.
6. The next question is to locate this reign of Christ with his Father, by finding the time of its commencement and termination. And on this point there cannot be one moment’s doubt or hesitancy; for the testimony here is, if possible, more explicit than on the other points. This reign began when God exalted Jesus to his own right hand in the heavenly places. Eph. 2 : 20-22. Then in promise and purpose all things were put under him, to be carried out literally when this period of kingship and priesthood shall close; as Paul in Heb. 2 : 8 says: “Thou hast put all things in subjection under his feet;” that is, in purpose; but he adds: “But now we see not yet all things put under him.” And this period of his reign as priest with his Father will close when he closes his work as priest and makes his second advent to this earth. These points once established, the central, vital, and controlling division of this whole question is forever settled.
Turn, then, to the testimony of Paul in Heb. 10 : 12, where, speaking of Christ, he says: “But this man, after he had offered one sacrifice for sins forever, sat down on the right hand of God.” No one can deny that this testimony applies to the time when Christ, after his death on the cross, ascended to God, and sat down on the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens. Heb. 8 : 1. What does he do, and for what does he wait, while there? Hear the apostle further (Heb. 10 : 13): “From henceforth expecting till his enemies be made his footstool:” or, awaiting the time when they will be made his footstool. And when will they be made his footstool?—At the conclusion of this period of his reign, which is also synchronous with the period of his priesthood, and will end with that work; for when he comes, he is no longer priest, but has assumed a title, glorious to his people, but awful to his enemies—“King of kings, and Lord of lords.” Rev. 19 : 16.
We do not see how it is possible to misunderstand this testimony. Paul positively assures us that Christ assumed this position at the right hand of God when he ascended. Christ says himself that he is seated with his Father on his throne. From the time of his ascension he has been reigning with the Father on his throne. He has had a kingdom conjointly with him. There also he has been a priest, as the prophet declared he would be during this time. He was to hold this position by the appointment of God till his enemies were made his footstool; and Paul declares that from the time Christ ascended, he has been waiting till his enemies be made his footstool. This locates this reign of Christ as plainly as language, and as positively as inspiration, can do it, in and during the priesthood of Christ, or what is called the gospel dispensation. To deny this, is to deny the plainest testimony of the sacred Scriptures; and we marvel how any man can do it. Of course, it tears every Age to Come theory into fragments, and this is probably why some do it. To illustrate: A man builds an engine, and puts the drive-wheels on the smoke-stack, and then adjusts all his connections accordingly: steam-chests, cylinders, pitman-rods, steam-pipes, cut-offs, etc., are all adjusted to that arrangement. But the engineer comes along and says, “That will never do. Those drive-wheels do not belong there. They must be taken down and placed under the boiler, to rest on the track.” And when that is done, what becomes of the man’s engine?—It is torn to fragments, and every part must be refitted. Just so with every Age to Come theory when the two reigns of Christ are given their proper places respectively, and the right events are attributed to the thousand years of Revelation 20.
Bro. R. thinks this is making Christ share with Satan in the kingdom of this world. Not at all. Satan, to be sure, is the god of this world so far as reigning in the hearts of the children of disobedience is concerned. But does any one suppose that God has abdicated his throne in reference to this world? Does he not still rule in the kingdom of men, and appoint over it whomsoever he will? Dan. 5 : 21. Does he not have a throne of grace for mankind? and on this throne is not our Lord associated with his Father?
7. The seven times. This is made to be a prophetic period, marking the end of the times of the Gentiles. And here we find how our brother terminates his calculation in 1914. But we are happy to inform him that there is no such prophetic period in all the Bible as seven times, or 2,520 years. It is simply a myth. The Greek word in Lev. 26 : 18, 24, 28, is in both the Hebrew and Greek simply an adverb—“seven fold”—and has no reference at all to any prophetic period.