IN THE QUESTION CHAIR

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 12, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 19.

Read the full edition

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

MATT. 15:11. WHAT DEFILES A MAN?

I MEET with people who claim that Matt. 15:11 is a conclusive passage against what we consider the health and temperance reform: “Not that which goeth into the mouth defileth a man; but that which cometh out of the mouth, this defileth a man.” How would you explain this? F. H.
Answer.—Our Lord in response to a request from his disciples for him to explain the parable, gives them a further insight into his meaning, as recorded in verses 15–20. He here shows that he refers to the spiritual nature of man, not to his physical. For the things that come out of the mouth are the expressions of evil principles that have their origin in the heart. “Out of the heart,” he says, “proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, false witness, blasphemies.” A man is defiled when these things exist in his nature, and the expression of them through the lips is evidence of it.
But does Christ mean to say that none of our physical actions have any connection with the defilement of a man?—By no means: for we are commanded to eat and drink “to the glory of God.” 1 Cor. 10:31. We can therefore eat and drink in a way which is not to the glory of God. And are not those who do this defiled?—Most assuredly; for they are walking after the flesh and not after the Spirit. Rom. 8:13. Again: We read that no drunkard shall inherit the kingdom of God. 1 Cor. 6:10. What makes a man a drunkard?—The intoxicating liquor that goes into his mouth. And yet again: Gluttony is associated with drunkenness, as a sin to be equally condemned. Deut. 21:20; Prov. 23:21; 1 Pet. 4:2–4. But according to the use our friends make of Matt. 15:11, a man might use opium and tobacco, drink liquor, be a glutton, and go to all the excesses of banqueting and reveling which Peter so severely condemns, and yet be undefiled before God! This certainly cannot be; hence such an application of Matt. 15:11 cannot be correct.
A reference to verse 2 of Matt. 15, shows us further to what our Lord had reference. The scribes and Pharisees, reproached the disciples for transgressing the traditions of the elders, because they washed not their hands before eating. The Jews enjoined the washing of hands before they ate, lest a minute particle of something which was forbidden by the Levitical law, adhering to their hands, should become mingled with their food, and so be eaten by them. And if such a thing should happen, they would consider themselves defiled and unclean. Christ put their traditions to scorn by saying that taking into their mouths and systems any such little particle of food, even if it was of a nature condemned by their law, did not affect their moral condition; but if their hearts were full of evil thoughts, lying, theft, adultery, and blasphemy, which things come out of the mouth, not go into it (and which was the very condition of those sticklers for hand-washings, to whom he spoke), this was what defiled and made them unclean. He had no reference to gross habits of life by which a person shows that he is walking after the flesh and not after the Spirit, a victim of temptation, and a slave of lust; no reference to the excessive and gluttonous use of even lawful food, nor to the use of unhealthful food like the flesh of the swine, nor to the use of narcotics and stimulants like tobacco and whiskey, which benumb the moral sensibilities and dethrone the reason. But it is only on these things that the health and temperance reform is endeavoring to correct the habits of the people.

2 COR. 6:14. UNEQUALLY YOKED.

“Be not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness? and what communion hath light with darkness?” Please explain and oblige. J. L.
Ans.—These words are addressed to those who believe. With a believer, his belief, or his connection with the cause of his Master, whom he has engaged to follow, is, or should be, the all-important thing. To be “unequally yoked,” is to enter into any relation in which his belief, or religious interest, is placed at a disadvantage, by being interfered with or restricted. This would cut us off from all connection or co-operation with unbelievers when our belief, or religious obligations, would require us to pursue one course of action, and the unbelief of the one with whom we are connected would prompt him to pursue another. Two cannot walk together unless they are agreed; and God does not design that his people shall ever abandon or compromise their faith for the sake of union. The apostle sets forth the principle fully in verses following. But we can co-operate with any class of people for the promulgation of any reform, so far as that reform is concerned; for if the reform is such as is in harmony with a consistent and scriptural belief, and all are agreed in efforts to accomplish it, so far they are not to us “unbelievers,” nor we to them. But as soon as we come to points on which we do not agree, the relation is at once changed. Thus we can co-operate with different denominations in the temperance work, and in all efforts to elevate society socially, mentally, and morally. But we could not give aid or countenance to those enlisted in the cause of intemperance, while we are for temperance. Nor could we join in a campaign to elevate the first day of the week as the Sabbath, when we know that that day is not the Sabbath, but that the seventh day is. For what communion hath light with darkness? Carrying the principle out still farther, a seventh-day minister could not officiate for a first-day congregation, agreeing to keep silent on the Sabbath question. Nor could a believer properly unite with a secret society; for there is nothing in a consistent belief which requires to be said or done in secret. Our Lord set an example for his followers when he said, “I spake openly to the world; . . . and in secret have I said nothing.”
Undoubtedly the text also applies to the marriage relation. Some think it has its chief application here. Dr. Clarke does not think that this was the subject the apostle had particularly in mind, though admitting that the exhortation may be so applied. Of a believing man marrying an unconverted woman, or a believing woman marrying an unconverted man, he says: “Such persons cannot say this petition of the Lord’s prayer, ‘Lead us not into temptation.’ They plunge into it of their own accord.” The circumstances of such a union generally show at least the appropriateness of the apostle’s exhortation as applied thereto. When a believer marries an unbeliever, one of three things must invariably follow. The believer will (1) win the unbeliever to the ways of religion, or (2) be drawn away from the faith by the unbeliever, or (3) be obliged to endure a life-long trial. While the first sometimes takes place, for which we have reason to feel profoundly thankful, is it not more frequently one of the latter two? At least there are two chances against one that the move will result disastrously to the believer; and it is too hazardous a risk to be lightly taken. From language Paul elsewhere uses (1 Cor. 7:39), it is plain to be seen that the general rule in such cases is, “Only in the Lord;” and it is not safe to presume on too many exceptions.
In brief, the text seems to teach this: that no alliance should be contracted, no union formed, no relation entered into, in which sincere belief in the word of God, and the earnest practice of all Christian duties, will not have free play as the controlling element of one’s nature.