Dr. Talmage’s paper, The Christian Herald and Signs of our Times, seems to be peculiarly unfortunate in its efforts at prophetic instruction—unfortunate as to the particular “school of the prophets” which secures admission to its columns. It recently ladled out to its readers some of the vagaries of the renowned Baxter, and is now doing the same thing for Lieut. Totten. In its issue of July 3, it devotes a half-page article to “An Epitome of Professor Totten’s Views on Prophetic Chronology.” These are set forth with no dissent, and while they are not positively indorsed, they are presented with the air of one who supposes he is doing the public a favor by making them known.
It will only be necessary to speak of two points to show to any reader of the Review the nature of Mr. T.’s views. He draws the usual wonderful conclusions from the prophetic period of 2520 years—a prophetic period which does not exist. And as the period itself is wholly imaginary, so the deductions based upon it are imaginary also.
But the way the seventy weeks of Daniel 9 are handled, can hardly be, like the foregoing, the result of carelessness. The “seventieth heptad” seems to be a delightful term, and is introduced as follows: “If, as the professor believes, the final end of the dispensation should be on or about Passover day, 1899, then the years from 1892 to that date will be the seven years comprehended in Daniel’s seventieth week. (Dan. 9 : 27.)”
Indeed! How do you know these years will be the seven comprehended in Daniel’s seventieth week? Why not say that these will be the last seven years in which Noah was building the ark? There would be just as much connection between the two. Who does not know that the seventy weeks are one connected period? Where does the prophecy intimate that they are to be taken and applied in detached sections? Everybody admits that there is no break in them till the end of the sixty-nine weeks. What right, then, has any one to tear the seventieth week away from the rest, and throw in over 1800 years before it is fulfilled? This looks to us like the sheerest nonsense and the most reckless wrestling of the prophetic word. To fit the scheme of these interpreters, a period of seven years seems to be wanted to close out this dispensation; and knowing not where else to find them, to give it all a prophetic air, they seize the last week of Daniel’s seventy.
The events which he predicts to transpire in this week are equally wild with the application of the week itself. In the seven years between 1892 and 1899, we are told, antichrist is to be manifested, and negotiate a covenant with the Jews to restore their nationality; a new ten-horned confederacy is to be formed, and put forth blasphemous pretensions, and “in the midst of the week” violate this covenant with the Jews, etc. But the prophecy of Daniel’s seventieth week says nothing about any such work as this. This is all gratuitous. It was in the midst of the week, according to the prophecy, that the Messiah was to be cut off, not a covenant with the Jews to be violated.
“The sixty-nine weeks,” he says, “ended at Calvary, and the parenthetic period, of which Daniel knew nothing, began. The final week of the seventy, the last seven years of this dispensation, still remain to be fulfilled.” At Calvary the Messiah was cut off; but that was in the midst (middle) of the last week of the seventy, not at the end of the sixty-nine weeks. By the “parenthetic period,” he means the years that have intervened between the death of Christ and the present time, and to continue to the close of this century. A pretty big parenthesis to throw in where the sacred writer himself has not placed any. But nothing was ever better said than that Daniel “knew nothing” of this “parenthetic period” between his sixty-ninth and seventieth weeks. That is strictly true. He knew nothing about it. And we may add that any one else who knows anything about it, is wise above what is written.
What conceivable pretext there can be for thus treating the seventy weeks is beyond our comprehension. They all stand together. They were cut off from the period of 2300 days, and allotted to the Jewish dispensation and the Jewish people, who were then the depositaries of the truth of God in the earth. At the end of sixty-nine weeks the Messiah appeared and entered upon his work of confirming the new covenant. Dan. 9 : 27; Mark 1 : 15. In the middle of the last or seventieth week, he was cut off on the cross, and caused the sacrifice and oblation (ceremonial and typical offerings) to cease. According to chronological dates, he continued his ministry from the autumn of A. D. 27, three and a half years (half of a prophetic week) to the spring of A. D. 31, and was there crucified, as the prophecy foretold. Three and a half years more remained, and the whole period ended in A. D. 34. The Jewish people were then no longer to be regarded as the special people of the Lord, and the apostles soon turned to the Gentiles. Adding to this latter date 1810 years to make up the 2300, we are brought to 1844. Since then Christ has been engaged in the work of cleansing the heavenly sanctuary (Dan. 8 : 14; Heb. 9 : 23), the last brief work he does preparatory to his second coming. Such an application is simple, straightforward, clear, and scriptural.
In their appropriate stages, grand and sublime, the prophecies of God are moving on to their accomplishment; and it is to be inexpressibly regretted that right in this focal time such speculations, which can only mislead and confuse, should be put forth from sources in which the generality of people will be more disposed to place confidence than in any other.