[For the past few weeks some interesting correspondence has been passing through the columns of the Canadian Baptist, on the Sabbath question. Some very pertinent questions were asked in regard to the authority for Sunday observance, and the editor of the Baptist turned over the perplexing problems to one Elder Denovan, a few points from which were given in a recent REVIEW. The following under the heading, “Church History on the Subject of Sabbath Observance,” is from the issue of July 30, and one would think it would be rather damaging to Elder D.’s “indisputable facts.” We are glad to know that the Baptists are getting the benefit of these points. The Sabbath question is the leading theme of the day. It has come time for the world to be fully enlightened in regard to it, and the subject is bound to come to the front. A. O. T.]
Elder Denovan, in the Baptist of the 16th inst., says: “It is an indisputable fact of history that the apostolic church observed the Lord’s day as sacred, and after the destruction of the temple and the un-Judaizing of the church membership, the first day of the week—the Lord’s day—became the weekly Sabbath.”
Let us see what some church historians say on this point: Socrates (A. D. 439) says, “Such as dwell at Rome fast three weeks before Easter, except the Sabbath and Sunday. . . . Again, touching the communion, these are Sunday customs, for although all the churches throughout the whole world do celebrate and receive the holy mysteries each returning week upon the Sabbath, yet the people inhabiting Alexandria and Rome, from an old tradition, refuse thus to do. The Egyptians who are neighbors to the Alexandrians, together with the Thebans, celebrate the communion on the Sabbath.”
Sozomen (A. D. 324–415) says: “Likewise some meet both upon the Sabbath and upon the day after the Sabbath, as at Constantinople, and among almost all others. At Rome and Alexandria they do not. Among the Egyptians, likewise, in many cities and villages, there is also a sacred custom among all of meeting on the evening after the Sabbath, when the sacred mysteries are partaken of.”
“The old tradition,” of Rome, referred to by Socrates, is thus stated in the modern “Catechism of Perseverance,” 1876: Question, “Why has God chosen one day in seven for us to render him our homage?” Answer, “1st, To establish order and unity in our worship; 2nd, To remind us of the obligation to worship him; 3rd, To preserve exterior worship. Among Christians this day is Sunday.” Question, “Why Sunday?” Answer, “For very wise reasons: 1st, to show that all the Jewish ceremonies are abolished; 2nd, to honor the greatest mysteries of religion; for the Sunday corresponds to the first day of the world, to the day of resurrection of our Lord, and to the descent of the Holy Ghost on the apostles.” The teaching of Rome on this subject is the belief of the great majority of Protestants. It rests on the same foundation of tradition which that church makes the ground of belief in the sacrament of water-sprinkling unbelieving infants, and the belief that Mary, in heaven, has an office “similar to that of our Lord,” in which she intercedes for us, pleads our cause, and dispenses with a liberal hand the graces of God.” (Catechism of Perseverance, page 404.) Observe that “one day in seven” means any day in seven, whereas God says, “the seventh day.” Elder Denovan says correctly that the commandment means “the seventh (after the six days’ work) is the Sabbath of the Lord.” But he makes this a reason for the seventh day before the six days’ work. Observe, that in the Romish Catechism the reasons assigned for the divine choice of the seventh day are not those given in Gen. 2:3; also, that the Sabbath is not a Jewish ceremony, and that Scripture nowhere states that our Lord arose on the first day of the week, but that he “rose again the third day according to the Scriptures,” and that it is very doubtful if the day of Pentecost was on Monday. Lightfoot says, moreover, that Acts 2:1 means “when the day of Pentecost was fully past.” Two Sabbaths are mentioned in Scripture, the Sabbath of ceremonial ordinance (Lev. 23:24, 32, 39), “besides the Sabbaths of the Lord” (38th verse), which are the Sabbaths of the decalogue, and were instituted at the creation. The Jewish ceremonial Sabbaths were a shadow of things to come, and were taken away when the High-priest of the new order came. “The reason ceasing, the law itself ceases,” say the jurists. But the reason for the fourth commandment has not ceased.
Dr. Schaff’s Church History says: “In the celebration of Sunday, as it was introduced by Constantine, and still continues on the whole continent of Europe, the cultus of the old sun-god Apollo mingles with the remembrance of the resurrection of Christ.” On the other two continents of the Old World, where hatred of the Jew was not an essential article of faith, the Armenian Church, the Nestorian Church, and the Abyssinian Church observed the seventh-day Sabbath, and where Romish influence has not corrupted them, members of these churches observe the (so-called Jewish) Sabbath still. (See Dean Stanley’s Lectures on the Eastern Church, Gobat’s Journal of Three Years’ Residence in Abyssinia.) The Portuguese lit the fires of the Inquisition of the Christians of Malabar in the seventeenth century, because they found them worshiping God in their assemblies on the seventh day of the week, and eschewing pork. They were “conjured by the bowels of the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ,” voluntarily to confess such crimes, and as proof of their repentance, to tell who had joined them in observing the law of Moses and assembling on the Sabbath day. The Spanish language,—it is wonderful how much history is hidden in etymology,—containing definite church history in the use of the word Sabado for Saturday, and Domingo, or Lord’s day, for Sunday. The word “Sabbath,” applied to Sunday, seems to be an invention of the Puritans, being used for Sunday by no known writer before their time.—Historicus.