AdventAI

NEITHER REASON NOR SCRIPTURE.

By W. H. Falconer

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 36., September 15, 1891

BY. W. H. FALCONER.

(Chapin, Mich.)

A tract on the subject of the “Sabbath,” by Rev. B. T. Roberts, was recently handed me by an acquaintance, with the request that I give it a careful reading. I have done so, and following are some of the thoughts suggested by its perusal. The author starts out with this bold assertion: “Never was zeal so misdirected as that which is expended to persuade Christians to observe what we call the seventh day of the week, for the Sabbath. These efforts have neither reason nor Scripture for their support.” (Italics his.) Then on the last page, in speaking of the evidence he has produced in support of the first day of the week as the Sabbath, he says, “If the testimony here given cannot be impeached, then let it be received as conclusive, as it really is.”

Putting these two statements together, we must arrive at the following conclusions: 1. The true Sabbath must be supported by both reason and Scripture. 2. The seventh day of the week has not this support. Hence, 3. The seventh day of the week cannot be the true Sabbath. But, 1. The most conclusive evidence has been produced for the first-day-of-the-week Sabbath. 2. Conclusive evidence must be that afforded by both reason and Scripture. Hence, 3. The first-day of the week as the Sabbath is supported by both reason and Scripture, and consequently is the true Sabbath. These conclusions, however, rest on the truthfulness of the assertions quoted. Their veracity depends on whether the testimony produced by Mr. Roberts can be impeached or not. He says it cannot. Let us examine it and see.

As evidence that the efforts in behalf of the seventh day of the week are not supported by reason, he quotes Mark 2:27: “The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath,” and says: “But man gets just as much benefit from resting on the first day of the week as on the seventh. His body, his mind, and his soul are equally refreshed. As far as the man is concerned, it does not make a particle of difference on which day of the seven he rests from his labors.”

His argument amounts to just this: “The Sabbath was made for man; therefore man has a right to say which day he will keep as the Sabbath. In fact, it makes man Lord of the Sabbath day, instead of Christ. Paul told the Thessalonians about the “man of sin” who would put himself in the place of God, showing himself that he was God. We have always understood that he referred to the papacy; but what shall we say when we see professed Protestants doing the same thing? Is it not an evidence that they have imbibed too freely the contents of the golden cup of Rev. 17:1–5, and are drunken on the wine of Babylon? How long before such people will be ready to erect the image to the papal beast?”

Now let us examine his statement a little closer. Can man derive just as much benefit from resting on one day as another? Are his body, his mind, and his soul equally refreshed? As far as body and mind are concerned, this may be true; yet we hear the psalmist say, “A good understanding have all they that do his commandments.” Ps. 111:10. But when it comes to soul refreshment, we take issue with Mr. Roberts. We understand by soul refreshment, that he refers to the blessings of God; “righteousness, and peace, and joy in the Holy Ghost.” The Lord says, “If thou turn away thy foot from the Sabbath, from doing thy pleasure on my holy day; and call the Sabbath a delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable; and shalt honor him, not doing thine own ways, nor finding thine own pleasure, nor speaking thine own words: then shalt thou delight thyself in the Lord; and I will cause thee to ride upon the high places of the earth, and feed thee with the heritage of Jacob thy father.” Isa. 58:13, 14. Here we have the promise that we shall delight ourselves in the Lord if we keep the Sabbath as God designed it to be kept. But this promise was made in regard to a particular day. When God made the Sabbath, he made it of a particular day, and placed his blessing and sanctification upon that day. If Mr. Roberts will produce one text of Scripture which shows that God has ever removed his blessing and sanctification from that particular day, and promises to place them upon any day a man may choose to keep, then, and not till then, will we admit his statement as true.

Mr. Roberts, however, is aware of these facts, and in order to dodge them, and make his assertion hold good, he endeavors to prove that any day of the week (especially the first) may be the seventh day of the commandment. He says: “They represent it [the commandment] as teaching that ‘the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.’ It does not say so. Why?—Because it does not mean it.” Mr. Roberts knows better than this. He knows that it does mean the seventh day of the week, and here is proof of it. He calls the seventh day of the week the “Jewish Sabbath.”—Page 16. By “Jewish Sabbath,” he means the Sabbath kept by the Jews. But why did the Jews keep the seventh day of the week?—Plainly because the commandment meant and required that very thing; and if it meant and required it then, it means and requires it now. That the commandment does mean the seventh day of the week can easily be shown from a careful reading of Luke 23:56; 24:1: “And they returned, and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment. Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulcher, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.” Here we have the following facts stated: 1. The disciples rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment. 2. The very next day was the first day of the week. Hence, 3. The day before the first day of the week is the Sabbath according to the commandment. Now, there being just seven days in a week, it follows that the day before the first day of the week is the seventh day of the week, and is the Sabbath according to the commandment.

In the light of these facts, what becomes of the assertion that seventh-day advocates have no support from reason or Scripture? Its falsity is apparent. “O Israel, thy prophets are like the foxes in the deserts.”

After demonstrating to his own satisfaction that it does not make a particle of difference which day of the seven a man keeps, Mr. Roberts next endeavors to prove that it does make a difference, and that Christians should observe the first day of the week as the Sabbath. He says (page 6): “Christ stated that he had authority over the Sabbath to make any change respecting it that he thought proper. ‘And he said unto them, That the Son of man is Lord also of the Sabbath.’ Luke 6:5.” We inquire, Of what was Christ talking when he made this statement? The Jews had accused him of Sabbath-breaking. He had proved to them that works of mercy were lawful on the Sabbath day, and as proof that he knew what constituted proper Sabbath observance, he said: “The Son of man is Lord even of the Sabbath day.” (See Matt. 12:1–13.) There is not the least intimation of the change of the Sabbath. Does not our friend here contradict his statement that the commandment only means one day in seven? Does he not virtually acknowledge that the Sabbath could be changed from the seventh to the first day of the week only by the authority of Christ? We look in vain for such authority, and the fact remains that Christ did not teach the change of the Sabbath.

Again I quote as follows: “From the very day on which Christ rose, we find his disciples meeting together on the first day of the week for Christian worship and fellowship. They called it the Lord’s day.” If unqualified assertions could prove a doctrine true, then certainly Mr. Roberts has fully substantiated the first-day Sabbath; but unfortunately for his cause, we are directed to “prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” The Scriptures are the standard by which to prove doctrines, and they will thoroughly furnish a man unto all good works. We challenge Mr. Roberts and all others of his way of thinking, to prove from the Scriptures that the disciples called the first-day of the week the Lord’s day. It cannot be done. But how about those meetings for religious worship on that day? He begins by quoting John 20:19, 26. Verse 19 mentions the fact that Christ appeared to the disciples on the evening after his resurrection. This was not a religious meeting. They were eating their evening meal. They did not believe the Saviour was risen, and he upbraided them because of their unbelief; but there is no intimation that they held a meeting for “Christian worship.” Mark 16:14. Verse 26 refers to another appearance of the Saviour, for the purpose of proving to Thomas that he was risen. There is no mention of a religious meeting, and furthermore, instead of being on the next first day of the week, it was after eight days, which was certainly more than a week later.

After quoting these texts, he says: “The meetings of the disciples on each eighth day have the more force from the very fact of their being only incidentally recorded.” We fail to see the force of incidents that never occurred. More than this, our friend started out to prove that these meetings came on each first day of the week, and, lo! now he says they were on each eighth day. Does he wish us to understand that the first day of the week comes on each eighth day? If so, then there must be eight days in a week.

His next reference is to Acts 20:6, 7. From this he argues that it was the custom to hold religious meetings on that day, to celebrate the Lord’s supper, and that Christians observed this day as their day of worship. It is true that the disciples on this occasion did assemble on the first day of the week for a religious meeting, but that they partook of the Lord’s supper remains to be proved. This is the only religious meeting on that day recorded in the Bible, and instead of proving a custom, it proves to be only an exception. The custom of the disciples is plainly stated in Acts 13:14, 42, 44; 16:12, 13; 17:2; 18:4, 11. Here we find it was their custom to hold religious meetings on the seventh day. It says it was their custom (Acts 17:2), and we have eighty-four instances in proof of it, against one for the first day.

The next reference is to 1 Cor. 16:1, 2: “Now concerning the collection for the saints,p. 564 as I have given order to the churches of Galatia, even so do ye. Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come.” He says that this means that collections were taken up on the first day of the week. It means nothing of the kind; for it says, “Let every one of you lay by him in store.” When a man lays by him in store, he does not put it in the contribution box. This text simply refers to a practice which the disciples were to carry on at their own homes, and which is still followed by the majority of S. D. Adventists.

On page 10 he says, “It was doubtless to the first day of the week the revelator refers. ‘I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day.’ Rev. 1:10.” Doubtless the revelator refers to no such thing. The Lord never claimed but one day as his. That is “the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” the seventh-day; the day of which Christ is Lord, and upon which the disciples rested; “the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” (See Ex. 20:10; Isa. 58:13; Mark 2:28; Luke 23:56, etc.)

Mr. Roberts next calls upon the fathers to bear testimony in support of his man-made institution, and this is where he finds his most conclusive evidence. Right here let it be said that the example of any man, or any set of men, is not the standard of morality. The example of Christ is the only perfect example, and we ought not to follow the example of any man any further than he follows Christ. The law of Jehovah is the only perfect standard. Christ obeyed that law, and declared that not a jot or tittle should pass till heaven and earth passed away. That law still says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” and it means the seventh day of the week now just as much as it did to the Jews or to the disciples. Luke 23:56; 24:1. “Sin is the transgression of the law.” “By the law is the knowledge of sin,” and thus I know that Mr. Roberts and all others sin when they trample under foot the Sabbath of Jehovah. “The wages of sin is death,” and those who prefer to believe Mr. Roberts instead of the Bible, will find to their dismay that it does make a difference which day of the seven they keep.

After quoting from the fathers, he says: “Now, what will you do with the testimony of these witnesses? They are unimpeachable. In any court the testimony would be conclusive of such witnesses as Christ, St. Luke, St. Paul, Ignatius, Justin Martyr, Dionysius, Tertullian, Eusebius.” We have no disposition to reject or impeach the testimony of such witnesses as Christ, St. Luke, or St. Paul. Their testimony is conclusive in support of the seventh day as the Sabbath. As for the other witnesses, we are astonished that their testimony should be placed beside that of Christ, Luke, and Paul, as of equal authority. Everbody knows, or ought to know, that the epistles of Ignatius are forgeries. Mr. Roberts must know, if he is a student of Church history, that these epistles are repudiated by such men as Mosheim, Schaff, and others; and when he presents such testimony as unimpeachable, it shows plainly that he is either ignorant or dishonest.

But what shall be done with the testimony of the other fathers? We will do with it as Dr. Adam Clarke did—reject it. He said, “In points of doctrine their authority is with me nothing.” Any one who has read them knows that they teach every heresy of which the Roman Catholic Church is guilty, and I am certain that their testimony will not be accepted in the court of heaven. If Mr. Roberts accepts their testimony as so conclusive for the Sunday Sabbath, why does he not accept it for image-worship, the sign of the cross, and the multitude of other things for which they bear testimony just as conclusive. If we are to accept their teachings as truth, and put them in practice, we shall find ourselves landed squarely in the papal church. Let us be consistent,—either repudiate their authority altogether, and be Protestants in principle as well as in name, or acknowledge their testimony as conclusive on all points, and become good Roman Catholics.

Men may hide their eyes from God’s Sabbath, they may trample it under their feet, they may call it that “old Jewish Sabbath,” they may call it dishonorable, and deceive others by their assertions; but the day is coming when the fire will try every man’s work of what sort it is, and then they will find that those who have made void the commandments of God by their traditions are vain worshipers. “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”

Let us remove our feet from the Sabbath, and call it a delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable, and honor him; so shall we delight in the Lord; and in the earth made new it will be our joy from Sabbath to Sabbath to come before God in that beautiful city of gold, and ascribe glory and honor to Him that sitteth upon the throne, and to the Lamb forever and ever.