SUNDAY FROM CUSTOM NOT FROM STATUTE

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 10, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 44.

Read the full edition

SUNDAY FROM CUSTOM NOT FROM STATUTE.

At a district meeting of the American Sabbath Union recently held in Chicago, Rev. Galusha Johnson read a paper on the subject of “Scripture Doctrine of the Sabbath.” After setting forth the Scripture on this subject, both from the Old and the New Testament, in a clear and lucid manner, the paper closed with this question: “If we admit the Sabbath, and Sabbath law, why not keep the seventh day of the week?” Then followed a discussion of the paper, by those present. The author of the paper held that Constantine only recognized an existing institution, when he issued his Sunday edict. Rev. C. A. Blanchard, the President of Wheaton College, made this remarkable statement: “In courts of law there are many cases on the docket that are not based on the statute, but simply on the practice and usage of courts. So with the change of the Sabbath. We do not claim to have any command for the change of the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first, but we have the example of the apostles, and the church since their days.” And this he considered very strong and conclusive evidence in favor of the observance of Sunday.
If the example of the so-called Christian Church is to be taken as evidence in favor of the divine appointment of an institution in one case, without regard to whether it conflicts with the word of God or not, then why not apply this rule in every case? why make any exception?
President Blanchard would hardly admit this argument in favor of the doctrine of purgatory, which is as old an institution as the observance of Sunday in the Christian Church. In fact, the foundation of this doctrine is found in the writings of heathen philosophers who lived centuries before there was any Christian Church.
Certainly purgatory has all in its favor that he claims for the institution of Sunday. And why reject the doctrine of the adoration of the Virgin, saint worship, and prayers for the dead? These, with a long list of like observances, stand upon the same foundation, and have an equal right to the claim of having the example of the church in their favor, and are still held sacred by the most powerful, and far the most numerous branch of the professed Christian Church; and yet President Blanchard rejects all these, because they do not have the authority of the word of God, or, in other words, are not “based on the statute.”
The only argument that can be used in favor of the Sunday institution that is not applicable to the others named, is the fact that God did institute the Sabbath, and blessed and sanctified it. But this was the seventh day of the week and not the first. The Lord has never removed his sanctification from the seventh day of the week, and as the usages of courts never change facts, so if all the professed Christian Church should unite in observing the first day of the week instead of the seventh, it would not change the fact that God rested on the seventh day, and blessed and sanctified it.
President Blanchard’s magnificent ability and eminent learning have not led him to reason in the manner that he does, and he does not in other matters. But we fear that his zeal for Sunday and Sunday laws, leads him to do violence to his better judgment. ALLEN MOON.