COUNTER QUESTIONS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 19, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 20.

Read the full edition

COUNTER QUESTIONS.

Observers of the Sabbath sometimes, and very properly, ask the zealous advocates of Sunday-keeping to show where there is one instance of any divine being resting on Sunday, to make it a rest-day; where there is one text which states that that day was ever blessed and made holy time, one text which contains the first intimation of a law for its observance, and one text which shows that Christ or his apostles ever observed it as a Sabbath.
These are all essential elements in a sabbatic institution, and where they do not exist, as not one of them does exist in connection with Sunday, it is folly to claim a Sabbath.
But some Sunday advocates are verdant enough to think that they can offset these decisive facts by some counter questions, not indeed on the Sunday question, but in reference to the seventh day, to show that that day is not binding on Christians, as if this would establish the Sunday institution, even if it could be proved. And they seem to have given the subject so little thought as to suppose that they can ask some unanswerable questions in reference to the Sabbath, as damaging to that institution, as the questions above suggested are to the Sunday. One O. A. Newton tries it in the Ohio City Times, of April 23, 1891; and the following is the result:—
“1. Please show in the Holy Scriptures where any man from Adam to the exodus of the children of Israel out of Egypt, was commanded to keep the seventh-day Sabbath.”
Easily enough. Did he ever read Gen. 2:3? That plainly states that “God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it.” Will he now take any common dictionary, and look up the meaning of the word “sanctify,” so as to learn what God did to, with, and about, the seventh day? He will find that to sanctify anything is to set it apart to a holy and religious use. To sanctify a day as God sanctified the seventh day in Eden, to religious uses, would and could be nothing else than to tell man (for whom the Sabbath was made, Mark 2:27) not to use the day for secular purposes, but in the service of the Lord. And this was a command for him to keep the Sabbath; for the fourth commandment (Ex. 20:11) assures us that the day which God thus dealt with in Eden, was the Sabbath day, when this blessing and sanctification were placed upon it. Therefore Gen. 2:3 is a record, just as plain as need be given, that God commanded Adam to keep the seventh day as the Sabbath. God having rested during the seventh day, the day thereby became the Sabbath, or rest day, of the Lord; then he blessed and sanctified it, and it is exactly as if the record had been worded as follows: “And God blessed the Sabbath day, and commanded Adam to keep it holy.” So much for our friend’s first question,—a conclusion to which any one must come upon a little candid consideration of the subject.
His second question reads as follows:—
“2. Show me where, by divine authority, any nation or people, except the Jews or their proselytes, was commanded to observe the seventh-day Sabbath.”
Indeed! Was Adam a Jew? This question is sufficiently answered by the answer to the first. The Sabbath being given to Adam, the father of the human family, was of course given through him to all his posterity. And what does our Lord say on this point?—“The Sabbath was made for man.” “Man” is here used in its generic sense— the whole family, all men. Are there no men in the world but Jews and their proselytes? And as we have seen, it rested on a commandment; hence all men were under commandment to keep it.
But further, the fourth commandment itself shows that the Sabbath is of universal obligation. It says, “Nor thy stranger that is within thy gates.” Were these strangers “Jews or their proselytes”?—Certainly not. They might have come from every nation under heaven, but the command was the same. Now, if it was their duty to keep the Sabbath whenever they came in contact with that people whom God had set apart for himself, were they not under just as much obligation to keep it everywhere? In other words, did any moral obligations originate from association with the Jewish people, so that men would be bound by them while they were with the Jews, but be released from them when they were away? Therefore Gen. 2:3; Ex. 20:11; and Mark 2:27, to say nothing of Isaiah, chapter 56, answer the second question. The third and last deals with a familiar sophism, as follows:—
“3. Put your finger on the passage that tells us when and where God took away the penalty for the violation of the seventh-day Sabbath, and did not abolish the day itself; and still further, if the penalty still remains in force, what would be the result now as regards ‘Sabbath-day keepers’ in general?”
It is strange that the enmity men bear to the Sabbath is so all-absorbing that they can think of nothing else. We might retort by saying, “Put your finger on the passage where God took away the penalty for idolatry (as in Deut. 13:6-10), and did not abolish the law itself.” Does Mr. N. believe that men are now just as much at liberty to violate the law against idolatry, as they are to violate the law for the seventh-day Sabbath? He must, according to his own reasoning. And so of all the ten commandments; for the penalty of death was attached to them all under the Mosaic system. Will he take the ground that men may now go after other gods, worship idols, blaspheme, lie, steal, commit adultery, etc., because the death penalty against these things is not now inflicted? If not, let him not argue thus about the Sabbath.
But he wants a passage. We can give it to him. Will he please put his finger on Col. 2:14-17. The death penalty was attached to the violation of the commandments simply as they were made a part of the civil constitution of the Jewish people, under the theocracy. But the accessories of the law in this relation, did not affect the law at all as the moral law of God, nor the relation of the people thereto as such. Col. 2:14-17 states that that whole Mosaic economy has passed away, the ceremonial and civil constitution of that dispensation with all that was shadowy connected with it. But that did not affect the moral law at all, nor our relation to it; for no part of that law was, or is, in any degree typical and shadowy.