TRUTH AND UNITY

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 2, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 22.

Read the full edition

TRUTH AND UNITY.

BY ELDER G. E. FIFIELD.
(South Lancaster, Mass.)
“Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth. As thou hast sent me into the world, even so have I also sent them into the world. And for their sakes I sanctify myself, that they also might be sanctified through the truth. Neither pray I for these alone, but for them also which shall believe on me through their word; that they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us: that the world may believe that thou hast sent me.” John 17: 17-21.
The Christian world is at present divided into some hundreds of sects, each professing to be Christian, and to base its belief on the Bible, and yet each teaching a faith different from that of all the others, and, in some respects at least, contradictory to them; each claiming to have the truth, and yet each antagonizing all others who make the same claim, till the theological world is a wild storm-tossed ocean, whereon many a fragile bark is hopelessly wrecked ere its anchor is cast by faith, within the vail. Small wonder that there are so many agnostics, and, what is fully as bad, so many among even the church-members who declare that the Bible is a “fiddle on which any tune can be played.” Meanwhile, one large body, professedly Christian (the Roman Catholics), preserve on the outside the semblance of unity, and are constantly taunting Protestants with their lack of such unity, as an evidence that God is not with them. The Protestants, thorned into action of some kind by this unanswerable charge of the Romanists, are either making desperate attempts at a kind of false unity by means of alliance or confederation, or they are declaring that all this diversity of creed and opinion is of God, and that more good can be accomplished by a divided Church than by a united Church. As a prominent speaker in the national convention of the Evangelical Alliance held in Boston last winter, expressed it: “Just as a handful of quicksilver, dashed to the floor, breaks up into a thousand glittering globules, each reflecting a full-orbed sun, so the Christian Church has broken up into many sects, yet each reflects to the world a full-orbed Christ.”
Some, they say, are more easily reached by the Baptists, some by the Methodists, and some by the Presbyterians, etc., etc., and so the Church is more comprehensive and cosmopolitan in its work than if it were a unit.
Of this last position it need only be said that it flatly contradicts not only reason and the Scripture, but also the universally acknowledged facts of experience. It is one of the first principles of reasoning that all truth agrees with truth. There can be no two truths in the universe that contradict. If two propositions contradict, it is positive evidence that one of them is false, and both may be; for two falsehoods can contradict, and a truth and a falsehood can contradict; but two truths, never. Now, all the divisions in the Church are the result of the contradictory doctrines taught by the Church; and all the contradiction in the Church is the result of the error in the Church. This all must admit. We may say that all the truth is in our creed, and all the error in our neighbor’s creed; but still the error is the cause of the contradiction, and therefore of the division. To say, therefore, that the Church is a greater power on account of this division, is simply to say that it is a greater power on account of its error; and that is to say that error is more potent than truth. Now, all truth is from God, and all error is from the father of lies. To say that error is more potent for good than the truth, is therefore the same as to say that Satan is more potent for good than God; and that would be simply to dethrone God, and make Satan supreme in God’s stead.
Moreover, the Church, according to the Scripture, is to be the “pillar and ground of the truth;” i. e., God’s means of teaching his truth to the world. How can the error of Satan in the Church make it more capable of teaching the truth of God?—Evidently it cannot; so from all this we say that the position that the divided Church is more powerful for good than the Church united would be, is opposed to reason. It is likewise opposed to Scripture. Christ, in that wonderful prayer to the Father, besought that the Church might be sanctified through the truth, that they might be one as he and the Father were one, that the world might believe that the Father had sent him. And Paul earnestly pleaded with the church in Corinth, where Christianity first manifested a tendency to divide into sects, to all speak the same thing, that there might be no divisions among them; but that they might be perfectly joined together in the same mind, and in the same judgment. 1 Cor. 1: 10. Then he indignantly asks, “Is Christ divided?” as much as to say that a divided church would not, and could not in each of its parts, “reflect a full-orbed Christ.”
The Church is the army of God fighting for the right. An army that is divided into hundreds of sects, each fighting for different things, is no longer an army at all, but rather a mob. The power of unity and the weakness of division are well known, and are always recognized in the army; and this is no less manifest in the Church. If the Church had been one through all the centuries, always and everywhere revealing to the world the same great and glorious scheme of redemption, divine in its infinite adaptation to human needs and human aspirations, always and everywhere telling the same story of God’s tender love, the world would have believed on Jesus, and thousands who now have no faith, and no hope for the future, would have been resting in his love.
From all this, it is seen that the teaching of the Church so popular to-day, that God designed all this diversity of belief and this division of the Church, is a fraud. At the best it is but a sickly apology for what they know to be their greatest manifestation of weakness; it is their only reply to an unanswerable argument in proof of their departure from God, and their contamination with worldly errors. From the prayer of Jesus, as well as from reason and experience, unity is seen to be desirable, the one thing desirable, if the Church would have power. Many see this; hence the effort at alliance and confederation of the churches, and the attempt to unite on certain points, and compel others to accept the national creed. Herein lies a new mistake and a new danger. The idea of the strength of unity and the weakness of division, which lies at the root of all this attempt at the establishment of a national creed, is a true idea; but the method of obtaining unity is a false one, and can result only in a false unity, the unity of the Roman Church, held together in one by an infallible pope with power to enforce his infallible laws.
All the persecution of the world is the result of the world’s oft-repeated attempt to attain and maintain unity in that way. All the unity ever attainable in that way is simply the unity which results from the spiritual and intellectual death of the masses, who under the pressure of law and public opinion, refuse to think, and to walk in the light for themselves, because such thinking and walking have become so dangerous. They now let some other one man (the pope) do their thinking for them, and as he agrees with himself, there is unity. Such unity is always bought at the expense of life, and the price is too great. Better life with diversity than death with unity; but there need be neither.
(Concluded next week.)