From Sunday Laws to Sabbath Truth

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 9, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 23.

Read the full edition

FROM SUNDAY LAWS TO SABBATH TRUTH.

As the readers of the last few numbers of the REVIEW may have observed, the citizens of the city of Bradford, Pa., appear to be considerably stirred up over the question of enforced Sunday observance. There are some Seventh-day Adventists and Seventh-day Baptists in the place, and a petition has been circulated in the city, and signed by 500 citizens, asking the city council to pass an ordinance declaring that “all persons are hereby forbidden to perform any worldly employment or business whatsoever, within the city of Bradford, on the Lord’s day, commonly called Sunday.” Both Bro. I. N. Rhodes (S. D. Adventist) and Mr. G. H. Lyon (S. D. Baptist) have written articles in the city daily papers, against the proceeding. A Mr. Duffee, however, took occasion to divert the issue a little, and ask some questions through the Bradford Daily Record, on the law, directing them particularly to Mr. Lyon. But as the opportunity seemed favorable, upon request, we took occasion to answer them, the editor publishing the answers under the caption, “The Sunday Question. An answer to Mr. E. E. Duffee by a Seventh-day Adventist. Straight on the Question of Religious Legislation, but Wrong on the Question of the Sabbath.” The following is the article containing the questions and answers, as it appeared in the Record of May 29:—
“EDITOR BRADFORD Daily Record: We notice that in the Record of May 23, Mr. Duffee joins in the denunciations of the proposed enactment of a Sunday law, and of any law that has as a basis the worship of God. We are glad to know that he is straight on the question of religious legislation, or, in other words, of a union of Church and State; but he asks some questions which, as they are evidently aimed at Sabbatarians in general, we take the liberty to answer. Before doing so, however, we wish to state that Mr. Lyon’s article was aimed at religious legislation. Mr. Duffee evades discussing this question, and introduces an altogether different subject, that of which day is the Sabbath. We simply follow him into the field to which he himself has gone.
“Question 1.—By what means does a man obtain the Spirit of God?
“Answer.—By faith. Gal. 3:2, 14. But in turn we might ask, How did man lose the Spirit of God? The answer is found in Isa. 59:2: ‘But your iniquities have separated between you and your God, and your sins have hid his face from you.’ And the apostle John tells us that ‘sin is the transgression of the law.’ 1 John 3:4.
“Ques. 2.—Will the keeping of the law gain us salvation?
“Ans.—The question is not pertinent, from the simple fact that none of us have kept the law. ‘All have sinned, and come short of the glory of God.’ Rom. 3:23. Salvation cannot, therefore, be obtained in that way. But there is one thing that is also certain, and that is that salvation is not gained by breaking the law of God. No man can go on and knowingly continue to violate the law of God, and be saved. If this be not the case, will Mr. Duffee or any other professed Christian please tell us which one of the ten commandments of God they can knowingly continue to transgress and be saved? To those who have professed the name of Christ, Paul asks ‘Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?’ and answers the question by a ‘God forbid.’ Rom. 6:1, 2. But now, we ask, can Mr. Duffee or any one else know whether he is continuing in sin or not? Paul says that ‘by the law is the knowledge of sin.’ Rom. 3:20. Has Mr. Duffee any other means of knowing what sin is than this? If he has, he has got ahead of Paul.
“Mr. D. emphatically denies that the kingdom of God is ‘obtainable by faithful observance of God’s law as recorded by Moses.’ We would remind him, however, that the keeping of the ten commandments as given by God on Mt. Sinai, is very intimately connected with obtaining this kingdom. A rich young man once said to Christ: ‘Good master, what good thing shall I do, that I may have eternal life?’ The Master’s answer was, ‘If thou wilt enter into life, keep the commandments;’ and in answer to the question ‘Which?’ Christ quoted a number of the ten commandments to show to what commandments he referred—those of the decalogue. But a man can keep the commandments only after he is converted, and he can become converted only by exercising faith in Jesus Christ. So it is by faith that a man can keep the commandments and finally be saved.
“Ques. 3.—Is it by the works of the law, or by faith that we are justified?
“Ans.—It is by faith, and not by works, for our works do not justify us, but rather condemn us; as Paul, in Rom. 3:20, says: ‘Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight; for by the law is the knowledge of sin.’ But it should not be forgotten that we are justified only by faith in One in whom there was no sin, who never violated the law of God; as Paul in 2 Cor. 5:21, again says: ‘For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.’ Our faith, therefore, which justifies, is faith in a law-abiding Redeemer. Hence we see that faith in Christ does not annul or do away with the law of God. Paul’s conclusion, after reasoning upon this very point, is: ‘Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.’ Rom. 3:31.
“Ques. 4.—What is religion?
“Ans.—Many answers might be given to this; but it is sufficient to say that any religion which ignores the law of God is not the religion of Jesus Christ; for both he and his apostles taught and enforced perpetuity of that immutable law.
“Ques. 5.—Is [are] the ten commandments binding, and still in force, the same as when delivered to Moses?
“Ans.—From the above reasoning and scriptural citations, it is needless to further answer this question. It is already answered. But if they are not binding and still in force, we would ask Mr. Duffee why it is that Methodists, Baptists, Presbyterians, and nearly all Christian denominations, continue to print them in their disciplines, manuals, and confessions of faith, and teach them as binding and still in force. (See Methodist Catechism, No. 2, chap. 6; Baptist Church Manual, art. 12; etc., etc.) Let him pitch into these churches first, and then when he has righted them upon the point, assume to instruct Sabbatarians.
“Ques. 6.—Is it lawful for man to change, deduct, or add to the laws of God?
“Ans.—No, indeed; and for that very reason no man, Mr. Duffee nor anybody else, has a right to teach that the first day of the week is the Sabbath, when the law of God and all revelation declare that the seventh day, and the seventh only, is the Sabbath.
“Following these questions, Mr. Duffee says: ‘Now, if Mr. Lyon will answer me these questions, I will endeavor to show him that the seventh day is not the Sabbath, and will also try to show him that the first day of the week, or the Lord’s day, is the proper day for observance.’ We do not know whether Mr. Lyon has answered the questions or not; but we have, and he can make his endeavors and efforts in these directions for our benefit, as well as for Mr. Lyon, if he sees fit. But before he begins, we have this to say to him: that after God has said, ‘The seventh day is the Sabbath,’ for any man to say that he will endeavor to show that the seventh day is not the Sabbath, can only be to throw an insult into the face of God himself; and as to his efforts to show that the first day of the week is the Sabbath, or the Lord’s day, or the proper day for observance, had Mr. Duffee from ‘beyond the bounds of time and space’ to do it in, from the Bible, he could not do it; for the Bible nowhere calls the first day of the week the Sabbath, the Lord’s day, or by any other sacred or holy title.
“Yours for the Bible Sabbath.”
W. A. COLCORD.