IN THE QUESTION CHAIR

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 4, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 31.

Read the full edition

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

MARK 1: 12. CHRIST'S TEMPTATION.

What spirit was it that drove Christ into the wilderness, according to Mark 1: 12? M. E. S.
Answer.—The same undoubtedly that is spoken of by the other evangelists when describing the same occurrence. Luke records it thus: “And Jesus being full of the Holy Ghost returned from Jordan, and was led by the Spirit into the wilderness.” Luke 4: 1. There can be no doubt that the Holy Spirit is here referred to. Matthew, Mark, and Luke all use different words relative to the action of which Jesus was the subject. But as all refer to the same transaction, they must be used with the same meaning. So the word translated in Mark 1: 12 “driveth,” might have been translated “led up,” as in Matthew, or simply “led,” as in Luke. Christ’s long period of meditation and fasting, and afterward of temptation, was doubtless a part of the wisely arranged experience through which he was to pass in his mission here among men. On this point Daniel Curry says: “No doubt Jesus came from his baptism in a widely changed frame of mind, and with a deep and clear consciousness of his own proper divinity; and, accordingly, under the influence of the indwelling Spirit, he retired into the solitudes of the desert for prayer and meditation, and to wait for further instruction in respect to his Messianic mission.”

ROM. 2: 13; 3: 20. LAW AND JUSTIFICATION.

How can Rom. 2: 13 be harmonized with Rom. 3: 20? How can one be justified by doing the law, and yet not be justified by the deeds of the law? J. W. B.
Ans.—If the statement of Rom. 2: 13 was that by doing the law we are justified, it would be difficult to harmonize the two passages. But the declaration is quite different from that; namely, “But the doers of the law shall be justified.” This text only mentions the special class who will be justified, but not the means by which they will be justified. Justification comes through Christ, but it comes only to the keepers of the law. The reason why none can be justified by the deeds of the law, is stated in 3: 20. By the law is the knowledge of sin; and all are sinners; and hence the law instead of showing that any are just, shows that all are guilty. Law can never cancel the transgression of itself, and make the transgressor just. Something else must remove from him the guilt of his sin, his transgression of the law, and bring him back into harmony with that standard of right. But no one can be in harmony with the law unless his desires, intentions, and efforts are to keep the law; and into such a position no one can bring himself; for “the carnal mind is enmity against God; for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.” So it is evident that no one can be justified by Christ while he lives on at enmity with God, and not subject to, but transgressing his holy law. But when he repents and seeks pardon, he receives through Christ forgiveness for his past sins, and the new nature, the spiritual mind which is subject to the law, in place of the carnal mind which is not. Then he is justified, and though he has broken the law, he is accounted in Christ as though he had kept it, and in him is enabled to keep it in the future. In this line only lies justification; and hence Paul could truly say that the doers of the law (and such only) will be justified; and thus bear his wonderful testimony to the strength and perpetuity of the law of God. So while justification does not come to us by doing the law, it comes to us only in doing it—in the person of Christ for the past, in the strength of Christ for the future.

THE BONDMAID AND FREEWOMAN.

Please explain the 24th and 25th verses of Galatians 4. It is being quoted here (Arkansas) for the purpose of showing that the Lord’s Sabbath is done away. A READER.
Ans.—This scripture cannot be legitimately used for any such purpose. Paul was not discussing the perpetuity of the moral law, of which the Sabbath is a part, nor did this moral law constitute the old covenant represented by Agar. False teachers were seeking to draw the Galatian Christians back under the services of the Mosaic system, which had then passed away (Gal. 2: 4; 6: 12; Acts 15: 5); and the apostle was trying to undeceive and save them. To do this, he exposed the fallacy of these false teachers, and by the allegory introduced in Gal. 4: 21–31, shows what position those would bring themselves into who went back to circumcision and the law of Moses. They would be in the same condition with respect to the promises of God that Ishmael was in with respect to the Abrahamic estate when he and his mother had been cast out from the family of Abraham, and he cut off from the heirship.
Paul’s illustration is consistent and forcible when applied at the right time and for the right purpose. There was a time in Ishmael’s experience which was a turning-point in his career. It was after Isaac, the spiritual seed, was born, and Ishmael persecuted him by mocking, at the feast that Abraham made on the day he was weaned. Gen. 21: 8–10. Then the sentence went forth that he, the son of Agar, should not be heir with Isaac, the son of Sarah.
So there was a turning-point in the history of the Jews. It was when Christ, the promised spiritual seed in the full sense, had come. The former dispensation had then served its purpose. The offerings, sacrifices, and typical services which had for nearly 1,500 years been pointing them and the world forward to Christ, had then met their object in Christ. The shadow had reached the substance. The Jews, through the very system of religion they had been practicing, should have been ready to receive him. But instead of this, they rejected him and his followers, and persecuted them as Ishmael mocked Isaac. And then they were cut off from being the special people of God, as Agar and Ishmael were cut off from the family of Abraham. Then whoever continued in that obsolete system, or went back to it after it had been superseded by the liberty of the gospel, went into a condition represented by bondage.
Then Paul’s allegory, in the scripture before us, applied. It could not apply before. By it he showed the Galatian brethren that if they, after the gospel had come, went back to circumcision and the Mosaic system, they put themselves in the hopeless condition that Agar and Ishmael were in after they had been cast out from the family of Abraham. Thus his argument has no bearing on the question of the perpetuity of the moral law, and the still binding obligation of the Sabbath.