Are Sunday Laws Religious Laws?

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 27, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 42.

Read the full edition

Are Sunday Laws Religious Laws?

Rev. J. P. Mills, Secretary Sixth District of the American Sabbath Union, in combating a statement made in regard to his work, that those favoring Sunday laws, “would have the American people make laws forcing religious observances,” says:—
“I deny. No man would oppose such legislation more strongly than I. I often say to the State, ‘Hands off of religious affairs. Let the Church take care of her own.’ So far as the religious observance of the Sabbath is concerned, the State has nothing to do with it. And I here add, no State Sunday law in force to-day is a religious law. So says every Supreme Court of every State having a Sunday law. The Sunday laws are purely civil laws, based on good and sufficient civil reasons; the peace and good order of society. Judge White of Pittsburgh, Pa., recently gave a decision in which occur these expressions, ‘Our Act of Assembly of 1794, prohibiting the carrying on of world’s employment on the Sabbath day, and similar acts, were not intended to enforce the performance of a religious duty,’ and again, ‘The civil laws do not prescribe moral and religious duties and impose penalties for neglecting them.’ Judge Thurman of Ohio, said in a discussion upon the Sunday law of that State, and quoted favorably by Judges in many States, that ‘We are there to regard the statute under consideration as a mere municipal or police regulation,’ and again, ‘It is essentially but a civil regulation.’ His argument was that notwithstanding the day set apart by the civil law was the same day as that observed by the Christians, and it is spoken of as the Lord’s day in the law, ‘Yet,’ he says, ‘this does not change the character of the enactment.’”
The architect that drew up the draft of the Sunday institution was the Church of Rome; it was builded and first occupied by that church, so far as its connection with Christianity is concerned; it has been accepted by a large majority of Christians in more modern times. Now how can an institution. that is purely a church creation, and fostered and maintained solely by the church, be, from one point of view entirely and wholly religious, and shifting the vision a little, have it just as fully and positively civil? We give the conundrum, and may get a reply; but an answer is an impossibility.
The statement of Mr. Mills, however, is the expression of a sentiment that is rapidly gaining ground. The advocates for Sunday laws know that there is such a strong feeling against religious legislation in this country, that it would be useless ever to think of getting such laws, unless the religious phase is covered up. And so with much earnestness, they are trying to draw the civil cloak about Sunday laws, but the covering is so transparent that the religious character of the institution is still left exposed to full view. That many judges have decided that Sunday is a civil institution, does not overthrow the fact that it is purely religious. It only shows that even the guardians of justice are yielding to the popular clamor, and that the indications are seen on every hand, showing the near fulfillment of Rev. 13:11–17. Will we be ready for the issue when it comes? A. O. T.