THE HOLY SPIRIT.—IS IT A PERSON?

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 13, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 40.

Read the full edition

THE HOLY SPIRIT.—IS IT A PERSON?

BY T. R. WILLIAMSON.
(Tallmadge, Ohio.)
The only way in which any doctrine of human belief can be established upon Scripture so as to be depended upon as true Christian teaching, is to examine every passage in Scripture which refers to that doctrine.
In doing this with reference to the term “Holy Ghost” or “Holy Spirit,” it would seem to be impossible to conclude that a person is meant, or that any other idea is intended by these terms, than that of an influence. I do not propose in this short article to go into a long examination of all Bible testimony upon this subject; that would be impossible; but I wish merely to give texts and deductions from them which point to the scriptural idea, at least as I see it.
In the first place, I know of no passage in all the Bible where any undoubted individual personality is spoken of in any other way than as a person. Search, and when you find a person mentioned, it is always as a person, and never in such doubtful terms as to allow of an influence being mistaken for a person. God, the Father, and the Son, are very frequently spoken of, or alluded to, but always as persons, never in such a way as to make their personality depend upon an inference. I recall a passage in Genesis, where Satan is called a serpent, and in Revelation he is called a dragon and a serpent, but he is spoken of as Satan in connection with these terms, and his personality is apparent. The text reads, “That old serpent called the Devil, and Satan.” Rev. 12: 9. We may be baptized in the name of a person, but not with a person. In Matt. 3: 11 and Acts 11: 16 the saints are spoken of as being baptized with the Holy Ghost, as if that were the material used in the place of water. We never read of people being baptized with the Father, or with the Son, but we do read of their being baptized with water, with fire, and with the Holy Ghost.
No one is ever filled with a person. If the 120 disciples in the upper room, on the day of Pentecost were all filled with the Holy Ghost, and the Holy Ghost is a person, then there must have been 120 Holy Ghosts, else how could so many be filled with one person? The same is true of persons all over the world; there are said to be millions who believe. Does one person, at the same moment, fill all these over the whole earth’s surface? To ask such a question is to compel an answer in the negative.
Every person mentioned in the Scriptures, nearly as often as the Holy Spirit, has a name of his own, as Jehovah, Michael, Gabriel, Moses, Joshua; but here is something mentioned from the creation till the consummation, and always mentioned just as other impersonal objects are mentioned, as the Holy Ghost, the Holy Spirit, the Comforter, etc.
While Jesus is often called the Son, and Jehovah is often called the Father, the Spirit is always the Spirit, with never a personal name.
Again: the Father has been seen; for the Scripture says “they saw the God of Israel;” the Son has been seen, but where is the record in all the Bible that any eye, even that of God, ever saw the Holy Ghost? Any person can and must be seen, sometime, somewhere, but here is something for which personality is claimed, that, so far as we can discover, no eye, human or divine, ever looked upon. A very doubtful personality, truly. It will not do to cite as an objection to this, the dove at Jesus’ baptism or the tongues of fire at Pentecost; for the dove was only the appearance of a dove, only one in form, “like a dove.” “Cloven tongues like as of fire,” are the words used, not the Holy Spirit was visible, but just the tokens of its presence. Again: no person in Scripture ever takes a shape lower than that which belongs to that person, except Satan; for even in those cases where angels took the form of men, and in the incarnation of Christ, there was a change only in degree, and not in shape, as man is in the image or form of God. The glory of the personage was vailed, but the form remained the same, as John says in Rev. 21: 17: “The measure of a man, that is, of the angel.” But the Holy Spirit which is said to be a person, has taken the shape of a dove, and of tongues of fire.
It is said that the Holy Spirit is in a few instances designated by the pronoun “he,” which denotes a person; but we have this form of speech in Psalms 19, where the sun is the object spoken of. “His going forth is from the end of the heaven, and his circuit unto the ends of it,” and yet no Christian claims personality for the sun. It is said that the Holy Spirit speaks, and that nothing but a person can speak, but Habakkuk says: “For the stone shall cry out of the wall, and the beam out of the timber shall answer it.” Are these persons? “The voice of thy brother’s blood crieth unto me from the ground.” Is the blood therefore a person? “If these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out.” Would that make the stones persons?
It may be said that the Spirit could be in many people over the earth at one time, as easily as Jesus could be in many assemblies of the righteous; for he says, “Where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them; but it must be remembered that it is by this very Holy Spirit, his representative, that he is present. His own bodily, personal presence is not in every place at once. He said to his disciples, “It is expedient for you that I go away: for if I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you.” Jesus is a person, with a material body, and the only way in which he could manifest himself in all places at once was by going away.
He was confined, as to his presence, to whatever locality he happened to be in, and that is true of him still, and he must send the Holy Spirit as his representative to make known his presence. It is claimed that Gen. 1: 2 must be spoken of as a person, as it is said that the Spirit moving upon the face of the waters is indicative of personal action, as if some one should speak of a hen brooding over her chickens or her eggs.
Josephus says, in speaking of this passage, “That a wind moved upon the surface of the great deep.” Genesis says God “breathed into his nostrils the breath (or spirit) of life.” “The Spirit of God is in my nostrils.” Job 27: 3. “He breathed on them, and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost.” John 20: 22. “There came a sound from heaven as of a rushing mighty wind.” Acts 2: 2.
Certainly, it would seem clear from these passages that no personality is ascribed to the Holy Ghost. When was the presence of a person ever suddenly introduced where it had not been before, by some one else breathing upon those assembled there? Rev. 4: 5 tells us of seven lamps of fire which are the seven spirits of God. Are there then seven persons known as the Holy Spirit? and is the nearest representation of the Holy Spirit, which it is claimed is a living being, to be found in a lamp which has no life whatever? In conclusion, let me quote the second commandment: “Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them.”
Nothing is to be made to represent God. People say the Holy Ghost is God, and yet the only visible similitude of it ever seen was a form “like a dove,” “cloven tongues like as of fire,” and “seven lamps of fire.” We find God himself, then, if this be true, setting aside his own commandment, and giving a likeness or representation of God.
It was said by the Lord Jesus, “I and my Father are one.” If there are three persons in the Godhead, why did he not include all three in one? Why did he only say, “I and my Father are one,” if the Holy Spirit is a member of the Godhead, one with the Father and the Son? Why this ignoring of the third person of the Trinity?
There can be but one answer. The Holy Ghost, or Spirit (for the words are the same) is simply an influence from God, a manifestation of his power, that pervades the whole universe, even as the air covers the earth and makes every atom of matter in every world, and all the limitless depths of space between the worlds, rife with the presence of Jehovah the Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ, the Father’s glorious Son.