Reform Judaism and the Sunday Services Question

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 13, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 40.

Read the full edition

Reform Judaism and the Sunday Services Question

For a number of years past, as our readers are aware, the question of establishing Sunday services for the Jews, and passing the Sabbath worship over to that day, has been extensively agitated among that people. Inasmuch as the Jews are so generally inclined to sacrifice their Sabbath convictions at the shrine of Mammon, and over-ride the Sabbatic institution for the sake of gain, it has been thought that by taking the day recognized in this country, by the Government and the churches, as a day of rest—a day when the Jew cannot follow his worldly pursuits—and making that a day of worship, it would tend to keep alive in his mind the Sabbatic idea, without interfering with his commercial passion. Dr. K. Kohler of the Sinai Congregation, Chicago, has been an earnest advocate of this plan, arguing that: “Reform Judaism would rather see the Sabbath observed on Sunday than not at all.”
But a change has come over the spirit of his dream; and in the Menorah Monthly (New York) of Sept. 1891, Dr. K. states his present position. He says:—
“Having for eighteen years been one of the chief advocates of a Sunday service for the Jews, often standing forth in its defense single-handed, I consider it not merely my privilege, but my duty, to state publicly that I have found sufficient reason to change my views on the subject.”
For this change of views Dr. K. assigns two reasons. The first is that where these Sunday services have been held by the Jews, it does not foster, as designed, but rather destroys, the Sabbatic idea. “Laxity,” he says, “appears to be the result. Skepticism and agnosticism are on the increase. The danger line, in fact, has been reached. The first dire consequence of the Chicago Sabbath success is that the ancient Sabbath has been ruled out. ‘Died from consumption’ is the official burial permit for the old Jewish Sabbath.”
The second reason he gives why the transfer from the Sabbath to Sunday should not be encouraged, is “the changed attitude of the world toward the Jew and the principles he represents.” In this he refers to the barbarous persecutions now carried on in Russia and some other European countries, against the Jews. It is unfortunate that most of the experience of the Jewish people has been with those miserable travesties of Christianity, represented by the Roman Catholic and Greek churches. But the Protestant Church is fast drinking in the same spirit, and in the following caustic exclamations, Dr. K. gives too true a forecast of the animus of the so-called Christian world in these last days, which will be manifested not only against the Jews, but against Christians also, if they are not in harmony with the coming politico-ecclesiastical machine. He says:—
“What a mockery has this so-called Christian civilization turned out to be! What a sham and a fraud has this era of tolerance and enlightenment become! The Middle Ages, with all their cruel bloodthirstiness, with their abominable hatred and fanaticism, have come back.”
In view of this state of things, he utters a rallying cry to his Jewish brethren to return to their duty. The following are his remarkable words, which we give with the italics as we find them:—
“Our duty to-day is to maintain our Jewish identity and preserve our Jewish institutions without faltering, without yielding. We must, with united forces, rally around our sacred Sabbath. The time has arrived for a universal effort to reconquer the lost Sabbath of the Jew.”
Is there not in this a hopeful indication? If such a Sabbath reform should be inaugurated among the Jews, and a genuine zeal and enthusiasm be aroused among them on this question, would it not tend to dispose them favorably to the truth, to learn that true Christianity does not antagonize the Sabbath, but that there is a class of Christians earnestly contending for the same Sabbath reform, setting forth in their true relations to each other the law and the gospel, the Mosaic economy and the work of Christ, discarding the superstitions, errors, and intolerance of the Dark Ages, and manifesting that interest and love for all men which was characteristic of the Master? And through this channel may it not be that many of that people may be brought to know and love the truth as it is in Jesus? Let us at least so hope and pray.