WAS CHRIST THE MESSIAH AT HIS BIRTH?
By William H. Littlejohn
BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN. Those familiar with the great advent movement of 1844 need not be told that Mr. Miller and his co-laborers employed the 9th chapter of Daniel as a key with which to unlock the mysteries of the preceding chapter. The position usually assumed by them was that everything contained in the 8th chapter of Daniel, excepting the time from which the 2300 days of verse 14 were to be computed, was so fully explained by the angel to Daniel that the latter must have comprehended its import. Gabriel, reasoned they, would have enlightened the prophet fully in regard to the commencement of the days, had not the latter fainted, thereby preventing the heavenly messenger from completing his work. It was, as they thought, the special object of the second visit of the angel on whom the injunction had been laid, to make the seer understand the vision, to carry out that injunction. The correctness of their theory in this matter is rendered more than probable by the circumstance that Gabriel at the beginning of his second interview with the prophet, calls upon him to “understand the matter and consider the vision.” As the vision of the 8th chapter of Daniel was the last one that had been granted to him, and as that contained something which he confessed that he did not comprehend, the prophet would naturally have inferred that Gabriel wished him to center his mind upon that vision. Again: as Gabriel opened his instruction with the words, “seventy weeks are determined [cut off] upon thy people,” it will be seen that time was the burden of his message. Putting that circumstance alongside of the fact that it was the matter of the time of the commencement of the 2300 days in regard to which Daniel was left in the dark when the vision of the 8th chapter closed, the conviction becomes irresistible that Mr. Miller and his followers were justified in deciding that Dan. 9: 22-27 furnished the key to Dan. 8: 13,14. Such a conclusion, however, leads to very important results, as will be seen hereafter. The angel announced to Daniel that seventy weeks, or 490 years, allowing a prophetic day to equal a literal year, were determined (cut off) upon his people; i. e., the Jews. But from what were they cut off?—Manifestly a longer period of time. That period could be no other than the 2300 days of Dan. 8: 13,14, since they furnish the only period of time to which allusion had been made in the 8th chapter of the prophet’s book. As a consequence, we have but to find the commencement of the seventy weeks in order to discover that also of the 2300 days, since they must begin at the same point of time. But how shall we ascertain where to begin the computation of the seventy weeks? That problem is not difficult of solution. Those weeks were to cover the whole time during which the Jews were to remain the peculiar people of God. Where, then, was the point reached when they ceased to be such any longer? The reply is found in chapter 9: 26,27. Those verses cover the space allotted to the last week of the seventy. According to their terms, Christ was to confirm the new covenant with the Hebrew people for one week. In the midst of that week he (Christ) was to be cut off, or crucified. The point of his crucifixion, consequently, is identical with the middle of the last of the seventy weeks. As a prophetic week is equal to seven literal years, add three and a half years to the spring of A. D. 31, when Christ was put to death, and you will reach the termination of the seventy weeks in the autumn of A. D. 34. At about that time Stephen was martyred, and a train of events was set in motion that culminated in the selection of Saul, one of his murderers, to carry the gospel to the Gentiles. Acts 9: 13-16. These occurrences furnished a fitting land-mark to designate the epoch of the casting off of the peculiar people of God, on account of their rejection of Christ and his work. Measuring backward 490 years, (seventy weeks), we reach B. C. 457. That year, therefore, must furnish the commencement alike of the seventy weeks and the 2300 days of Dan. 8: 14. By an easy computation, it is found that 2300 days, or 2300 literal years, reached to A. D. 1844. But what was to occur at the end of those days? The angel said to Daniel that they would reach to the cleansing of the sanctuary. The Adventists of 1844, mistaking the earth for the sanctuary, fell into the error that the latter date would mark the end of all things, since at that date, as they believed, this planet would be dissolved in the great conflagration of the last day. When the clouds and mist of the terrible disappointment through which they had passed, drifted away in part, it was discovered by certain ones who had been driven to a closer search of the Scriptures by their recent disappointment, that the earth was not the sanctuary, and that it was never styled such in the word of God. The sanctuary of this dispensation, as they learned, was the great antitype of the Mosaic tabernacle and the temple of Solomon. (See Ex. 25: 1-9; Acts 7: 44; Heb. 8: 1-8; 9: 22-24.) Otherwise expressed, they learned that God has a temple in heaven, which is the true sanctuary, pitched by God himself and not by man (Heb. 8: 1, 2), and that the earthly buildings and the priesthood and services simply prefigured the heavenly temple, its services, etc. By comparing types with antitypes, through the guidance of the Mosaic ritual, they discovered that the earthly sanctuary was cleansed on the day of atonement, and that the services of that most solemn occasion pointed unmistakably to the judgment scene in heaven as its antitype, since it evidently foreshadowed the final blotting out of sins. (See Acts 3: 19-21; Lev. 16: 29, 30.) The year 1844 A. D., therefore, became to them the precise epoch at which the investigative judgment was inaugurated in heaven, instead of the period at which the earth should have been destroyed by fire. (See Dan. 7: 8-11.) Forty-seven years have elapsed since the great disappointment that occurred on the tenth day of the seventh month of 1844. From that time to this the body of Advent believers has been characterized by two great divisions. They are generally known as Seventh-day Adventists and First-day Adventists. The latter class has been divided and subdivided into sects and factions, differing widely from each other. Their principal occupation seems to be that of readjusting the dates laid down by William Miller, and fixing new periods for the coming of Christ. Repeated disappointments have somewhat cooled their ardor and shaken their confidence, but still they seem to hanker for time messages. With Seventh-day Adventists the case has been different. From the necessity of the situation, they can never be time-setters. Holding, as they do, in the main, to the accuracy of Mr. Miller’s dates, they claim to have corrected his mistake in regard to the event to transpire in A. D. 1844, and are now patiently awaiting the close of the investigative judgment for the revelation of the Son of man. They rejoice because they believe that event is near, even at the door. Matt. 24: 33. A word more in regard to the date fixed upon by them in common with Mr. Miller for the commencement of the seventy weeks, and the objective point of this article will be reached. Did the weeks in question actually begin to run in B. C. 457? The basis of the calculation already furnished, would seem to be trustworthy; but it may be well to fortify it somewhat. In Dan. 9: 25 the angel gives to us additional data for the beginning of the seventy weeks, and therefore of the 2300 days, or years. He says, “Know therefore and understand, that from the going forth of the commandment to restore and to build Jerusalem, unto the Messiah the Prince, shall be seven weeks, and threescore and two weeks: the street shall be built again, and the wall, even in troublous times.” From the foregoing scripture it is obvious that a commandment to restore and build Jerusalem must furnish the starting point from which the seventy weeks and the 2300 days are to be computed. That commandment was to authorize the building and restoration of the city of Jerusalem. The restoration of that city necessitated the restoration to it of its ancient polity, so far as its laws and worship were concerned. There is one, and but one, commandment of this kind, found in the Bible. That is recorded in Ezra 7: 11-27. It was issued B. C. 457, or at the precise point of time where the 2300 days should begin, according to our first calculation. They would terminate, therefore, in A. D. 1844, as argued above. Thus are the commencement and ending of the days that were to reach to the cleansing of the sanctuary, confirmed by the two distinct lines of computation. They are made still more sure by the circumstance that the manifestation of Christ, or the Anointed One, in A. D. 27, when he was anointed with the “Holy Ghost and with power” (Acts 10: 37, 38; Luke 3: 21, 22), and his cutting off, or crucifixion, just sixty-two and a half weeks from the date of the completion of the street and wall of the city, B. C. 408, precisely meet the demands of the prophecy. Where coincidences so marked as these exist, it is sure that the right clue to the interpretation of the prophecy has been hit upon. Now a word in reply to the objection hinted at above. By some of the First-day Adventists who have pet theories that they would like to palm off upon a credulous public, it is urged that the whole of the foregoing exegesis is erroneous, since it is based upon the conception that Jesus did not become the Messiah until his baptism. He was, say they, the Messiah at the date of his birth, and consequently, all the dates of the prophecy must conform to that fact. To this objection it might be replied that there676 are just four decrees, if they may all be called such, that could possibly be taken to answer to the one that the prophet mentions. They are these; the first, that of Cyrus, B. C. 536; the second, that of Darius, B. C. 519; the third, that of Artaxerxes, B. C. 457; the fourth (the letter of Artaxerxes, given to Nehemiah), B. C. 444. Now granting that the sixty-nine weeks that were to reach to the Messiah the Prince, ought to terminate at the birth of Christ; then the first of these decrees will be found to be too early by fifty-three years, the second too early by thirty-six years, the third too late by twenty-seven years, and the fourth too late by thirty-nine years. It would seem that facts like these are sufficiently ponderous to crush any unfortunate theory that might collide with them. There is, nevertheless, in the text itself proof even more damaging to the theory in question, than the facts just cited. The scripture that is occupying our attention for the moment, teaches that sixty-nine weeks, if computed from the decree that the angel had in his mind, would reach to the “Messiah the Prince.” Now granting for the sake of the argument, that Christ was the Messiah at his birth, as is claimed, then the sixty-nine weeks should have terminated with that event, instead of ending twenty-seven years later, as they did. But that is not all. Assuredly, the seventieth week must stand in juxtaposition with the sixty-ninth week; that is, it must follow it in order. But as seen above, Christ was to be crucified in the midst, or middle, of the seventieth week. A prophetic week is seven years. The middle of that week would be just three and a half years from its commencement, and the same from the end of the sixty-ninth week. As a consequence, if our friends are right, Christ should have been crucified in the middle of A. D. 4, or when he was just three and a half years old. The merest tyro knows that this was not the fact. Christ did not enter upon his ministry until he was thirty years of age, and he was not crucified until three and a half years later than that event. The subject might be left here, as one that has been disposed of effectually once and forever. But let the measuring line be applied again. The street and the wall were completed in B. C. 408. (See Prideaux Con., Vol. 1, p. 322.) From that point (chap. 9: 25) 62 weeks, or 434 years, were to reach to the week in which Christ was to be cut off, or crucified. This they did exactly, if Jesus, in the sense of the prophecy, became to us the Messiah in A. D. 27, when he was baptized. If, however, he was the Messiah the Prince at birth, then the sixty-two weeks reach twenty-seven years beyond his birth, since 434 years, if computed from B. C. 408, would reach to A. D. 27, or twenty-seven years this side of the birth of Christ. What, then, shall be done with the theory passing in review? If it is sound, then Gabriel is impeached; that is, the events of history disprove the accuracy of his predictions. If, upon the other hand, the interpretation offered by Seventh-day Adventists be accepted, all is harmony. History and prophecy march hand in hand, the one verifying by its record in a most wonderful manner the predictions that the other has made. As a result, the Bible is proved to be the word of God, and the cavils of the infidel are so answered as to put him to the blush. Furthermore, one of the grandest and most solemn religious movements that has taken place since the beginning of the Christian era, is snatched from reproach, and upon it is placed the signet of divine authenticity. Accept the doctrine that the cleansing of the sanctuary mentioned in Dan. 8: 14 refers to the investigative judgment, and the mistake of the Adventists of 1844 is explained, and the church has laid upon it the solemn obligation of proclaiming the hour of God’s judgment come, agreeably to Rev. 14: 6, 7. In concluding this article, candor demands the acknowledgment that there are a very few passages that seem to give color to the opinion that Jesus was the Messiah at his birth. One of them is found in Luke 2: 10, 11. There the language of the angel, if construed independently of all other testimony, would seem to intimate that the infant Saviour was the Messiah at his birth, since the original word in the Greek, there translated “Christ,” means the same as the Hebrew term “Messiah.” In this article it is not possible to attempt to explain at length how it is that Jesus could properly be styled the Messiah at birth. Suffice it to say that the expression must have been used in an accommodated sense. That is, he was called the Christ in his infancy, by way of anticipating his ultimate anointing “with the Holy Ghost and with power.” Acts 10: 38. Such an interpretation is both logical and admissible according to Scripture usage. But to press the point that Jesus was the Messiah at his birth in the sense of the prophecy of Dan. 9: 25, is to do so at the cost of overturning the reliability of that prophecy itself.