THE PROPOSED SIXTEENTH AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 26, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 4.

Read the full edition

THE PROPOSED SIXTEENTH AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION.

Opinions of Leading American Citizens.

THE New York Independent has interested itself in the proposed sixteenth amendment to the national Constitution, noticed in the REVIEW of Jan. 5, and has obtained expressions of opinion from a large number of leading citizens in different States relative to the advisability of the measure. These expressions show that leading minds in this country are still fully awake to the value of the American principle of the total separation of Church and State, both in national and State affairs, and to the importance of its preservation. The ideas of these leading men, and the words in which they are expressed, will without doubt claim the interest of our readers, to whose attention the subject of the relation of the Church and State has been so prominently brought. The amendment itself, that our readers may have it before them, is as follows:—
No State shall pass any law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or use its property or credit, or any money raised by taxation, or authorize either to be used for the purpose of founding, maintaining, or aiding, by appropriation, payment for services, expenses, or otherwise, any church, religious denomination, or religious society, or any institution, society, or undertaking which is wholly, or in part, under sectarian or ecclesiastical control.
We give only short extracts from the printed opinions which appear in the above-named journal.
The following is from the Hon. Dorman B. Eaton of New York City, who contributes an article under the heading of “Separation of Religion from Government”:—
By the salutary denial of authority to do so,—which is the substance of the proposed amendment,—the States will be prevented from evading and defeating the fundamental principles and purposes of the national Constitution in regard to the freedom and independence of religion and its complete separation from politics. The original declarations of the Constitution will be enforced in practice. Very few citizens, we must think, can be found, who desire, or will attempt to justify, the doing of anything which this amendment prohibits, unless, indeed, their judgments have been warped by the great pecuniary interests which they themselves, or the church, sects, or societies to which they belong, may have in prospective appropriations or favors which this amendment would prevent. American citizens must indeed be rare who can wish to see, or can see without indignation and a sense of national peril, our elections and legislatures opened to the degrading and corrupting competitions of churches, sects, and religious societies; of priests, rectors, and bishops; of ministers, deacons, and trustees, for the largest appropriation they can extort from the public treasury of the people, for the greatest amount of spoils they can win by the bribery, the flattery, the coercion of voters, politicians, and law-makers. Nothing could do more than such a competition—the prostitution of the noble forces of religion for mere selfish ends—to disgrace republican government, to bring religion into contempt, to degrade and corrupt our public administration and all political and official life.
The Hon. John Jay of New York City, in an article on “The Bearing of the Amendment on Religious Freedom,” says:—
The principle embodied in the proposed sixteenth amendment is the fundamental principle of equal religious freedom, based upon the guarantee—to which both parties are pledged—of the complete separation of Church and State. It is intended to protect that principle from encroachment by State legislation precisely as it is protected from congressional interference, by the first amendment to the national Constitution, by the voluntary surrender by the States, binding as a part of the constitutional compact, of all power to restrict the religious freedom of the people, or to tax them for the benefit of any church, religious denomination, institution, society, or undertaking, which is wholly or in part under sectarian or ecclesiastical control.
William Reed Huntington, D. D., rector of Grace Episcopal church, New York City, writing on “Why the Amendment Should be Adopted,” says:—
In a word, the aim of this movement is to guarantee a fair field for the experiment, which our fathers deliberately determined should here be tried, of separating the administration of religion as completely as possible from governmental control. In view of the success which has thus far attended the working of our American method, it is, perhaps, a little late in the day to speak of it as an experiment. Even so conservative a mind as Mr. Balfour's seems, if we may judge from a recent utterance at Glasgow, to recognize the proved futility of schemes for making men religious by legislation. But even admitting our experiment to have been, from the first day until now, an experiment only, we are determined that as an experiment, it shall be fairly and fully tried before being pronounced a failure.
Gen. Thomas J. Morgan, Commissioner of Indian Affairs, says:—
The proposed sixteenth amendment provides that “no State shall pass any law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. This is simply an extension of the prohibition which rests now upon the general government so as to include State governments. There is no new principle involved, and consequently it would seem that whatever reason there may be for the first amendment applies with equal or perhaps increased weight in favor of the sixteenth. If it is unwise for Congress to pass any law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, it certainly is unwise for any State to pass a similar law. . . . Experience has shown that there is need of some such prohibition, in order to prevent the abuse or violation, by State legislation, of the accepted principle of the separation of Church and State as enunciated in the first.”
Rev. R. S. Mac Arthur, pastor of Calvary Baptist church, New York City, utters the following stirring words:—
The time has come when we must emphasize every distinct American principle. We must lift up our voices as one man against the diversion of public moneys for sectarian ends. The separation of Church and State must be made clear and distinct. . . . The entire separation of Church and State must be maintained, or the enjoyment of liberty among naturalized citizens of various countries and creeds is an utter impossibility. I give this movement my unqualified endorsement. Indeed, I cannot conceive how any citizen, whether of native or foreign birth, can be loyal to this republic and oppose this amendment. . . . The time certainly has come when every American must insist upon the absolute separation between Church and State, or the days of the American republic will be numbered. God help us to prize the liberties which were secured at so great a cost for the citizens of this favored land!
Prof. David Kinley of Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, writes:—
The most pressing, immediate danger is the growing influence of religious sectarianism in politics. Nothing will be so fatal to our progress as the predominance of the church, as an organization, over the State. The public school, especially, should be kept free from its control. This is a matter on which the trumpet of American citizenship should give no uncertain sound. “No union of Church and State,” “No sectarian appropriations,” “No division of the common school fund,” must be our mottoes, if we would avoid the dangers that threaten.
The American Baptist Home Missionary Society indorses the amendment in these words:—
This body heartily approves the object of the National League for the Protection of American Institutions, and regards its action as timely, and as providing a safeguard against very grave existing abuses, and yet graver possible dangers. This body approves of the proposed amendment to the national Constitution, and urges that Congress take the needful steps for its adoption.
Albert J. Russell, State Superintendent Public Instruction, Tallahassee, Fla., says:—
Our country does need something of the kind very much just now, taking in all the circumstances without and within, and while there is no occasion for fear if our people are awakened and aroused, and made to feel that eternal vigilance as given by our fathers, is the price of human liberty, and especially American liberty, they must be awakened and put upon their guard.
Numerous other names appear with brief indorsements of the proposed amendment, among them being the names of Hon. William Strong, Ex-Justice of the United States Supreme Court, Hon. Henry Hitchcock, Ex-President American Bar Association, Bishops John Scarborough and H. B. Whipple, of the Protestant Episcopal Church, and Bishop W. F. Mallalieu of the Methodist Episcopal Church. Communications from W. F. Crafts, Rev. Herrick Johnson, Rev. David McAllister, and other apostles of “National Reform” and American Sabbath Unionism, could they have been printed along-side the above, would no doubt have made interesting reading, but of course were not forthcoming.
It is interesting in this connection to note the fact that an amendment similar to the one now proposed was suggested by President Grant and introduced by James G. Blaine into Congress in December, 1875, received in the House 180 ayes to 7 noes, and in the Senate 28 ayes to 16 noes, thus failing to pass in the latter body by the necessary two-thirds majority; also that both the Republican and Democratic parties have in public convention indorsed the principle of the proposed amendment, the former at Cincinnati, June 15, 1876, and the latter at St. Louis, on the following 28th day of the same month. Whether the present attempt will be more successful than that of 1875, or whether less so, is a matter of uncertainty. The strong indorsement it has thus far received is, of course, encouraging to the hope of its continuing, and ultimate success.
But should the measure pass Congress and be ratified by three fourths of the States, so as to become in fact the sixteenth amendment to our national Constitution, it would not by any means follow that religious liberty in this country would not still be invaded as it has been up to the present time; for the determination of whether any State law was or was not one which infringed the provisions of the amendment, might so result as to leave the heavy hand of persecution free to continue its oppression, under the guise of a civil necessity. It is doubtful if the amendment would prove anything more than a somewhat formidable barrier across the path of the movement for the enactment and enforcement of laws for the observance of the pagan Sabbath. But it would no doubt strike a direct blow at the pernicious system of State appropriations for sectarian schools, which, it is to be hoped, would prove a fatal one.
The preservation of American rights and liberties can be aided, but not wholly secured, by Constitutional provisions, so long as the public mind remains uneducated to know just what such liberties are, and to discern when they are violated; for without this, the interpretation given such provisions may not be such as to make them strike with fatal effect against the evil which they are intended to destroy. Education is the great need of the hour, and nothing can take its place. L. A. S.