Dr. Lyman Abbott having asserted in the Christian Union that a man might keep all the ten commandments, and yet be such a man as would not be allowed in decent society in New York City, wide notice has been given to the remark by both the religious and secular press of the country. The agitation has called out the following article from the New York Observer, which is both a rebuke of the insult which Mr. Abbott offered to the perfect and holy law of God, and an able defense of the commandments themselves, and is so good that our readers will be glad to peruse it entire. It was in the issue of Jan. 28, 1892:—
The Chicago Inter Ocean is not a religious newspaper, but like many another secular journal, it is quick to detect inconsistencies in statements of religious faith. So we are not surprised to find it giving utterance to such a sentiment as the following:—
“When Dr. Abbott says that a man may keep all the ten commandments and still ‘not be allowed in decent society in New York,’ one scarcely knows what to think of New York or of Dr. Abbott. How any man can love God with his whole heart, as he is required to do in the ten commandments, and his neighbor as himself, and yet be guilty of ‘leering and evil imaginings’ so severely condemned by Christ in his exposition of the commandments, is a difficulty much harder to explain than any Dr. Abbott has enumerated.”
It is surprising indeed that a minister of the gospel should so belittle the law of Sinai; but that Dr. Abbott means just what the language quoted suggests, is evident from what he further says in the Christian Union of last week.
He tells us that “the ten commandments are not, and do not purport to be, the moral ideal for the human race. They are a series of statutes for the government of society. They embody those fundamental principles which are absolutely essential to social order, and as an embodiment of such principles, are not only wonderful for the age in which they were given, but in conciseness and comprehensiveness have never been surpassed in any statement of social ethics since.”p. 103
Really this is very kind. In this age of superior wisdom we wonder that these leading theologians can find anything good to say of so antique a document as the law. The apostle Paul regarded the law very differently, but we suppose that, like the commandments themselves, Paul’s comments are “wonderful for the age in which they were given,” but out of date now. The psalmist David eulogized the law to a remarkable degree. He attributed to it convicting and converting power, but the light of these later days had not dawned on David. Let us look to more recent sources of light. We are told that “the ten commandments are not, and do not purport to be, the moral ideal for the human race.” We have always regarded the decalogue as the highest moral ideal. Taught by St. Paul, who was in turn taught by the Holy Spirit, we have regarded the law as holy, just, and good, so much so that in our sense of inherent peccability and moral weakness, we have exclaimed, “It is high, I cannot attain unto it.” We have supposed that the law was given to represent God’s moral requirements, and by its unsullied luster so to reflect to sinful man his own evil nature that he would be led to seek divine mercy and regenerating grace.
We had supposed that what the law could not do through the weakness of the flesh, God had sent his Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, yet without sin, to accomplish. And the result to be gained was that the righteousness of this same law might be fulfilled in us. Now we learn that there is inherent weakness in the law as well as in human nature. Moreover we have always regarded the perfect obedience to God’s law manifested by Christ, as a sweet and acceptable offering unto God in the penitent sinner’s behalf. We have sung with intelligence and with reason, as we presumed, the words—
“Jesus, thy blood and righteousness, My beauty are, my glorious dress,”
but now again we learn that the law was a very low ideal of morality. A man might keep all the ten commandments, and still “not be allowed in decent society in New York.” This statement startles us. We have been disturbed already by the comments made on the immoralities of the patriarchs; for it is certainly astounding to discover that Abraham, called the friend of God, was too immoral to be admitted to a New York drawing-room. This is the more startling, because the words of Christ had led us to look forward to sitting down in the kingdom with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
To this startling intelligence is added the statement that even the law-abiding might have been too immoral for decent society in New York. The law hitherto regarded as the standard of the highest morality, must henceforth be looked upon as very far from such. It cannot therefore have been divine; it must have been merely of human design and promulgation. Such a view throws discredit on the whole story of the giving of the ten commandments. So much so indeed that either the story is legend and fiction, or else the account of a fraud perpetrated by Moses on the Israelites. For either of these conclusions we are not yet prepared.
Dr. Abbott’s views would lead us still further. In disposing of the decalogue so summarily as he does, as simply a code of social ethics suited only to a by-gone age, he takes an attitude opposite to the teachings of the Old Testament. But we presume that he is prepared to throw that overboard, at least so far as it may be deemed an authority. A similar fate must be in store for the New Testament; for the New Testament is very plain in its teachings that the Son of God became incarnate in order to insure the working out in us of the righteousness of the law. But if even when completed, the law leaves so much to be secured; if it yet leaves so wide open the gate to immorality, it is difficult to see why the Son of God should have come on the mission he did or have been at such pains to pay the penalty of the broken law or to insure its fulfillment first in our behalf and then in us. Dr. Abbott diminishes the importance of the law; he makes void the law, and as viewed by him, it becomes “of none effect.” Here certainly is where Dr. Abbott and Paul differ, and we claim that these new views are in direct antagonism to the teachings of Christ. We shall not be surprised to learn before long that Christ taught only so far as his audience could comprehend, and that they were not ready for the latter-day light. Christ magnified the law, and made it honorable by his words and by his life. Till the newer light dazzles and bewilders us, we shall continue to believe and to teach that Christ came to fulfill the law. We shall believe that it was so complete a revelation of the divine character and will, and of the divine requirements at the hands of man, and so thorough an ideal of morality, that its fulfillment was worthy the great mission of Christ.
Dr. Abbott tells us that Christ made it perfectly apparent that the ten commandments do not embody the ideal of human life, because he added other laws. Thus Dr. Abbott says:—
“It was said to them of old time, he says, Thou shalt not kill; but I say, Thou shalt not be angry without a cause: Thou shalt not commit adultery; but I say, Thou shalt not entertain lustful thoughts: Thou shalt not forswear thyself; but I say, Thou shalt not use expletives to enforce affirmation and denials. These are not merely interpretations of the ten commandments; they are added laws. The ten commandments are social; the laws of the Sermon on the Mount are personal, individual, spiritual. And this distinction Christ makes still clearer when, in his last interview with his disciples, he says to them, ‘A new commandment give I unto you, That ye love one another as I have loved you.’”
This seems to us a perversion of the purpose of Christ. The self-righteous Pharisees sought to carry out the letter of the law, but had no realization of its spiritual meaning. “Thou shalt not kill,” said the law. Christ sought to show that this was a sort of seed truth, which when brought to foliage and fruitage meant the end of all unkindness in the human heart. It was seen by Christ’s teaching that one could break that commandment without ever staining his hands in blood. He proclaimed the necessity of obedience to the very spirit of the law, and so did with the law just what Israel ought to have done with it long years before. He made it the plumb-line by which life’s motives should be tested, and lifted it above the letter into the spirit. In the light thus shed by it, the best of mere human life is seen to be imperfect. The law is and always has been a mirror in which man can see the sinfulness of his own natural heart.
Moreover Christ distinctly showed that the law was active, aggressive, positive, not simply negative, denunciatory, and prohibitory. This he showed by the parable of the Good Samaritan, and he summed up the whole law in few words; namely, love to God and love to man. Then lest his disciples then and now should say, We love God, and yet not bear love to one another, he adds: “A new commandment give I unto you, That ye love one another as I have loved you.” It does not take a very long step to reach the conclusion that Sinai and Calvary proclaimed the same gospel of love. The belittling of the law does grave dishonor to the life, teachings, and sacrifice of Christ.
Of the law God said: “This do and thou shalt live.” Accepting Dr. Abbott’s theory, men could be so bad that they “would not be allowed in decent society in New York,” and yet they could please God. Though they should perfectly keep the ten commandments and thus insure life, they might be immoral and vile. We do not believe that. We rather express our conviction in the words:—
“The best obedience of my hands Dares not appear before thy throne, But faith can answer thy demands By pleading what my Lord has done.”
Dr. Abbott talks of the law as a mere social code. Christ did not so treat it. He gave no substitutes for the ten commandments in his Sermon on the Mount. He simply showed their spiritual significance, and applied their spiritual principles to individual human beings. “Self-sacrificing love,” says Dr. Abbott, “is the Christian ideal. It is not found in the ten commandments.” The story of the Good Samaritan was a story of self-sacrifice, and it was Christ’s illustration of the fulfillment of the ten commandments. The sacrifice of Calvary was the parable of the Good Samaritan enacted in the fullest possible sense. The cross was the most marvelous and concentrated display of justice, purity, holiness, and self-sacrificing love that ever was; and yet it was nothing but a fulfilling of the ten commandments.