The Rich Man and the Beggar That Was Laid at His Gate.
By Wolcott H. Littlejohn
BY ELDER WOLCOTT H. LITTLEJOHN. All are familiar with the utterances of our Lord, respecting the rich man and Lazarus. His remarks on that subject will be found in Luke 16:19–31. What he said in that connection, is usually styled a parable. Notwithstanding this fact, the account is generally treated as though it were a literal narration of historic verities. The unfairness of such a course is readily discerned. If it be a parable pure and simple, it should never be made the basis of a doctrinal argument, as most scholars will agree. If it is a matter of history, then it is competent to press it into the service of any theory that it will support. Nay, more; every dogma that cannot be harmonized with all of its details, must be false. It is the proper office of parables to illustrate and enforce well-known truths. In this sphere they can be employed with telling effect. Usually they have but one objective point. This is set home with great power many times, in the use of auxiliaries that are not true in themselves. Take, for example, the parable employed by Jotham against the man of Shechem. Judges 9:8–15. In it he represents the trees and the bramble as engaging in a discussion over the matter of selecting a king to rule over them. Every school-boy knows that such a thing never really transpired. Trees neither talk together nor are they ruled over by a king. The man to whom Jotham was speaking knew this very well; nevertheless his apologue conveyed to them; with telling effect, an important moral. Do you ask how, if these things be true, it is possible to justify the use of such parables? I answer, that their employment is perfectly legitimate so long as the rules that govern their construction are understood. Having said this much respecting the nature and use of parables, the objective point of this article is reached, i. e., the bearing of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus upon the natural immortality of the soul. One would not be far out of the way were he to declare that in the hands of modern theologians it has become the main pillar for the support of this doctrine. In most instances, notwithstanding the general admission of this class that the account is a parable, when they approach the subject of the state of the dead, they seem to forget its true nature, and handle it as though it were an unvarnished record of things that actually took place. You will observe, say they, that our Lord declares that Lazarus was carried to Abraham’s bosom, and that the rich man lifted up his eyes in hell. Having premised this much, they argue that it would impeach the veracity of Christ were it proved that his statements were not strictly true. Putting this and that together, the conclusion is reached that it must have been the disembodied spirits of the men in question that went respectively to Abraham’s bosom and to hell, and therefore that the existence of the soul separate from the body is an established fact. It will be observed that the foundation of the whole argument is the assumption that the account in question, though a parable, deals in nothing but events that actually took place. It has already been shown that the law of parables does not require that they should deal simply in facts. If therefore the story of the rich man and Lazarus is a parable, as is generally conceded, no one has the right to insist that its statements should be received as true in every particular. Without taking advantage of the concession of most Biblical scholars on this point, it is proposed to prove the parabolical nature of the story of the rich man and Lazarus from the context. Before doing so, it is but just to conceive that, as claimed, the parable relates to events which, if they took place at all, must have transpired between the death of the characters brought to view and the final judgment. It is useless to insist, as some do who otherwise agree with us in the main, that the transactions narrated, relate to a period that will not be reached until the resurrection of the wicked dead. That event will not occur until one thousand years after the second advent of Christ. Rev. 20:4–6. To suppose therefore that the rich man should have been so utterly ignorant of the things that had transpired as to conceive that men could be still living under Moses and the prophets, or that he still had five brethren in the land of Judea that could be saved, were a messenger sent to them by Abraham, would be to attribute to him a folly such as to render him exempt from moral accountability. All who have passed through the terrific scenes of the last judgment and witnessed the final separation of the righteous and the wicked, assuredly will not be ignorant of the fact that probation has closed, and that the end of this world’s history has been reached. But to return to our task: Is the story of the rich man and Lazarus a historic verity? Did the things there related ever take place? If they did, then our friends have a strong presumptive argument favoring the conscious state of the dead between death and the resurrection. If the events so graphically given by our Lord can be shown to be impossible in the very nature of things, then the necessary inference is that he, as he often did, was speaking parabolically. But if such was the case, then his language should not be made the foundation of a belief in the immortality of the soul. The features of the parable to which attention will be called at this time are these: 1. Abraham’s bosom; 2. Hell; 3. The tongues, fingers, and eyes of the spirits; 4. Water as an agent for cooling the tongue; 5. The gulf; 6. The conversation between the rich man and Abraham. Taking up the points mentioned above in their proper order, they will be discussed as follows:— 1. Abraham’s bosom is mentioned nowhere in the Scriptures, save in this connection. If it is really a place where Abraham and the blessed reside, how singular that it should have been spoken of but once. Does not this silence more than intimate that it has no existence in fact? Do you say that it must be heaven, since Abraham is there? The reply is that such a view would bring heaven and hell so near each other that the inhabitants of these places could both see and converse with each other—a proximity, the thought of which certainly would shock one of refined sensibilities. But more upon this point anon. 2. Hell is spoken of in the parable, as the place to which the rich man went at death, and was tormented. In the Scriptures, the244 wicked are represented as being reserved to the day of judgment, to be punished. Job 21:30; 2 Pet. 2:9. The judgment is still future; Acts 17:31. How is it, then, that the rich man can be undergoing his punishment at this time? The hell, or lake of fire, pointed out in the word of God as the place in which the unrighteous will receive their doom, will be made upon the surface of this earth, from the fire that will come down from heaven, upon it at the resurrection of the wicked, one thousand years after the second advent of Christ. Rev. 20:4–9. This being true, the theory of hell, found in the parable, cannot be harmonized with that of the Scriptures. 3. Tongues, fingers, and eyes, are very useful adjuncts to the human body. It is difficult to see, however, in what respect such appendages could be serviceable to disembodied spirits so ethereal in their nature that, according to the modern theory, they are lighter than the most attenuated gas known to science. Do you reply that doubtless we will have those organs in heaven? I answer, Yes; but we shall have tangible bodies also. 1 Cor. 15:40–54. To sum up: The theory that spirits, such as those in question, have tongues, eyes, and fingers, is too absurd to admit of discussion. 4. That water would be of service in cooling the physical tongue of a physical man placed in conditions similar to those of the rich man, is admitted; but the case is very different when you talk about a disembodied spirit, so called. If such a one has a tongue at all, it must of necessity be invisible, intangible, and imponderable. To talk of spiritual water would be nonsense. To talk of literal water as an agent to be employed in the cooling of a spirit tongue, is equally ridiculous. To ask as the rich man did, that Lazarus should be made to dip the tip of his ghostly finger in literal water and place it on the ghostly tongue of the former, is the very quintessence of folly. It is to be presumed that the rich man in his lifetime was possessed of ordinary shrewdness. How it is that he lost his wit so suddenly and so completely, in the spirit land, it is left for our friends to account. 5. The “gulf.” Abraham is represented as saying that between him and the wicked in hell, a gulf intervened so wide that no one could pass over it, were he thus inclined. The design of the gulf, therefore, was to prevent all intercourse between the damned and the redeemed. Remembering now that this gulf was not so wide but that the spirits in question could recognize each other and carry on a conversation across it, it is time to inquire what had become of that attribute of spirit being that enables it to dart from place to place with that lightning-like rapidity which virtually annihilates space. Can an intelligent answer be given to this query? Should it be suggested that perhaps the individuals in question, after all, were in the possession of bodies, and that these bodies prevented them from passing the gulf, the reply is that if such be the case, then our discussion is at an end; since by common consent disembodied spirits are spirits without bodies. 6. In the parable, Abraham and the rich man are spoken of as engaging in conversation. The rich man prefers a certain request. Abraham offers certain conclusive reasons why such request could not be granted. One of two things is certain, either the Scripture conception of the condition of the dead, or that of the parable, is at fault. That such is the case, the following citations will prove: “The living know that they shall die: but the dead know not anything.” Eccl. 9:5. “Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man, in whom there is no help. His breath goeth forth, he returneth to the earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146:3, 4. “Their love, and their hatred, and their envy, is now perished.” Eccl. 9:6. “Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.” Eccl. 9:10. If the “dead know nothing,” if their “thoughts perish,” if “their love, and their hatred, and their envy, is now perished,” if “there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave,” then it cannot be true that the dead Abraham and the dead rich man did, as a matter of fact, talk with each other after death, as the parable represents them as doing. In every instance in the Scriptures where the dead are alluded to—except in cases where a parable or personification is employed—the dead are spoken of as though they were incapable of thought. Which will you do, reader, base your conceptions upon this subject on those declarations of the word of God that are free from figure and obscurity, or on those that confessedly partake of the nature of the parable or the apologue?