THE RELIABILITY OF CHURCH HISTORIANS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 12, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 28.

Read the full edition

THE RELIABILITY OF CHURCH HISTORIANS.

(Concluded.)
But how little Dr. Bohmer dreamed of any apostolic appointment, yes, how positively he protested against any such idea, is seen from the following paragraphs. After considering 1 Cor. 16: 2 and Acts 20:7, also Justin Martyr, he draws the following conclusion:—
“The early Christians assembled surely in the original mother church (as Tertullian calls it), which was gathered at Jerusalem every day, and poured forth their united prayers, and preferred therefore by no means any certain day to any other, for it is well to be observed that we read nowhere that the apostles had ever held any consultations concerning the appointment of a certain day, nor given any command; if this had happened, Luke would surely not have omitted to mention it, as he does not pass institutions of minor importance. Yes, even the Acts of the Apostles show in the most decisive manner that the Jewish believers had never departed from their custom, but had been the most tenacious adherents to the custom of their fathers; therefore we must also conclude that they, according to their wonted custom, assembled on the Sabbath. The apostles desired no difference of days, and decidedly persisted upon liberty, and would not prescribe any laws or holy days. . . . How could one therefore believe that they should have prescribed to all the churches that they should keep the first day holy? How easy one can, therefore, from all this, guess that it cannot be ascribed to the law, nor to the apostolic command, but to the mere custom that the Christians had holy assemblies on this day.”
In a more emphatic manner neither Hartmann nor Dr. Bohmer could deny the assertion of Mosheim. But how did this man dare to rest his assertion on these writers? Surely he must have been hard up for proofs, to refer to positive statements against his theories as “unexceptionable testimonies” for them. In common life we know how such men would be considered. But we are not done as yet. We want to see whether we cannot learn something about Mosheim’s own opinions in this Sunday question. While he has been careful in his church history to avoid this subject, he has written in another work, called “Sittenlehre,” or “Christian Ethics,” quite a dissertation on Sunday, and there we find the following wonderful statement from his own pen:—
“The books of the New Testament do not state that the apostles have appointed a certain day for the assemblies of the Christians to the service of God.”
A plainer contradiction of his own words would be impossible. Thus we have not only the two witnesses to which Mosheim refers, against himself, but also Mosheim against Mosheim. Now whom or what shall we believe? This is the simple outcome: When men begin to deviate from the plain word of God and devise their own wisdom, it will always turn into folly, be they ever so eminent. This lack of Scripture texts Mosheim tries to make up by a lengthy argument, arguing from the nature of the case; but how little he succeeds, a German college president, Dr. Henke of Barmen, shows. We give his whole statement, so that the reader may get some idea of the position Mosheim takes on the Sunday question, and how he fails:—
“Mosheim tried to discover a middle course between the old and new doctrine. (Sittenlehre, Helmstädt 1752, Band V.) [Mosheim says:] ‘The obligation of the Christian to keep Sunday, cannot be proven from the Old Testament and from the Sabbath law given to the Jews. (p. 448.) Besides, Paul teaches that the Sabbath was done away; but that Sunday has taken the place of Sabbath, and Sabbath has thus been introduced anew, neither Paul nor any other apostle teaches.’ (p. 449.) If the opponents claim that God had given, right after creation, the Sabbath as an eternal law, then it should be demanded of them that they should also retain the seventh day to be kept. But in case they say that the apostles had power to change the Sabbath into Sunday, then they must first show the proof, and this cannot be furnished; for Mosheim truthfully and fittingly remarks, ‘Things occurred can only be proven by testimonies.’ (p. 454.) But in the Scriptures we read nothing of such an appointment from these men. Mosheim’s opinion is this: the apostles had authority to found churches and to organize them, therefore their appointments and institutions must be looked upon as coming from the Lord. (p. 461.) The laws of the apostles are either laws only for a definite time, or commandments forever binding. (p. 463.) Now the question comes, Have the apostles set apart a certain time to the service of God forever? The books of the New Testament contain no testimony concerning this. But Mosheim continues, ‘The nature of the thing’ stands for the lack of testimonies. But right here we appeal to Mosheim’s own words against Mosheim, ‘Things occurred can only be proven by testimonies.’ We might perhaps from the nature of a matter admit a supposition that something not testified to might have happened; but this we can only admit for periods, of which the historical testimonies are altogether too incomplete, but regarding a time with as rich a literature as the New Testament, never. And it is not at all allowable to set instead a supposition a certainty, on which we afterward build a doctrine, which binds our conscience. Also the question whether the apostles have appointed Sunday as the Christian day of worship, Mosheim answers in the affirmative. But we also know from history that the Sabbath had in Christendom the same right and the same honor, besides the Sunday, for nearly two hundred years after the apostolic age. Mosheim declares Sunday to be an ‘eternal’ institution, because the resurrection has eternal significance. (pp. 484, 485.) But in the life of Christ finally everything has an eternal signification. But can we without any special authority from the Scriptures, which according to Mosheim’s own statements are wanting with Sunday, tie to all the great events in the life of Christ, ceremonies, and declare them to be of the same eternal significance as those events?—By no means. Such would only be human ordinances, against which Christ himself has protested.” (Matthew 15.)
From the above statement of this German college president, though himself a Sunday-keeper, and writing in favor of Sunday, we can plainly see how Mosheim, by trying to invent a new theory to substantiate Sunday, simply contradicts himself. With what feelings Mosheim undertook to write on this subject, his words in the beginning of his treatise show:—
“I must openly confess that I have doubted for some time whether I should treat the doctrine concerning the Sabbath, as it is usually called, or Sunday, or not. As often as I presented to myself the intimate connection of this matter with the doctrine of public worship, as often I judged that I could not let it untouched. But as often as the multitude of treatises came to my mind and the different manners in which it was treated, as often I was ready to change this conclusion.”
This admission speaks for itself. When Mosheim was writing this church history, it was an easy matter to turn it off with a simple assertion by referring to two other authors; but when it came to prove the matter, he looked in vain for the divine command, or for the “express appointment of the apostles,” and instead of the “united testimonies of the most credible writers,” as Maclaine twists Mosheim’s words, he saw but a babel of theories, which scared him from the task for some time. But finally he became more courageous, and at the beginning of the eighteenth century he hoped to make Sunday-keepers happy by a new course of reasonings which would prove that they were right after all.
But lo, he simply added another to the multitudes of theories concerning Sunday, to be exploded by the next writer; and ever since, they have been busy writing essay after essay, inventing theory after theory. They can surely only be pitied in their unthankful task!
And on the assertion of such a man as Mosheim, ministers, theologians, and lay members dare to rest their assertions concerning Sunday, as though he was almost infallible. Yes, they will produce his simple assertion, which he rests on two other men, which say just the opposite from what he does, and even in spite of his own contradictions, hold it up against the plain word of God! If any one wishes to build on such a sandy foundation, he is to be pitied. One thing we have clearly proved, that church historians, at the best, have, when writing about the Sunday question in the first two centuries after the apostolic age, nothing more than the word of God, which we all have, and they not only disagree among themselves, but Mosheim with Mosheim. How grateful can we be for the plain, simple, and harmonious truths of this last message; and while others try to legalize a human ordinance held up by a network of contradictions, assertions, and untruths, the Lord in his boundless mercy has turned our eyes to the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. Great men err in their own wisdom, and worship in vain, observing the ordinances of men, but the simple may turn to the commandments of God; for it makes wise the simple, and enlightens his eyes. L. R. C.