A LEAFLET upon the subject of the Sabbath has been sent to this Office, with the request that it be reviewed. The title of the leaflet is, “Why do Christians Observe the First, or Lord’s Day, as Sabbath? and Why do We Call it Sunday?” The title itself is a curious mixture of ignorance and error. The writer does not ask, “Why do Christians observe Sunday, or the first day of the week, as the Sabbath?” but “Why do Christians observe the first, or Lord’s day, as Sabbath?” We would “first” like to know what he means by “first,” whether it is the first day of the month, year, or the first day he began to write his leaflet. The title gives no clue by which we can find out his meaning. He has either failed to express himself, or else he had no clear thought to express. A great portion of the Christian church, popularly so-called, do not call the first day of the week the Sabbath, and they would scorn the idea of so doing. They call it Sunday, as the majority of men still do.
The article commences by asking the following question: “What Scripture basis have the Seventh-day Christians to stand upon?” He does not, however, make an attempt to find the Scripture basis which seventh-day Christians have to stand upon, but devotes himself energetically to the task of finding an unscriptural basis for Sunday-keepers to stand upon! This will become apparent as we proceed.
We will notice his most noteworthy points as briefly as possible, to see if he answers his own question, “What Scripture basis have the seventh-day Christians to stand upon?” He devotes his first statement to Constantine, and tells how he became an adherent to Christianity. But as Constantine had nothing to do with the “Scripture basis” of the seventh day or any other day, we feel that he has jumped the track already, and is off upon a side issue. He then tries to introduce a basis for Sunday, as may be seen by the following:—
“Under the designation ‘the Lord’s day’ (Rev. 1:10), this day was, from the resurrection of Christ onward, the most sacred day of the week to Christians; and when they observed but one day of rest in the week, from secular labor and for the worship of God, the Lord’s day was that day.”
This is the old worn-out dodge of assuming the very thing upon which they should give proof, that the “Lord’s day” of Rev. 1:10 is the same as the first day of the week. Assuming the thing to be proved, for the proof, is called a master stroke in argument; and it is only used when one has a poor cause to sustain. When he can prove what he assumes, that the first day of the week is called the “Lord’s day” in the Scriptures, then his succeeding statement that “constructively and practically the first day of the week became the Christian Sabbath,” shall receive due attention. We would, however, remark that only a little over sixty years before the Revelation was written, Jesus, speaking of the seventh day of the week, or Saturday, as all admit, said: “The Son of man is Lord even of the Sabbath day.” And as the Son of man is Lord of the Sabbath, and as “the seventh day is the Sabbath” (Scripture basis), it therefore follows that the seventh day is the Lord’s day, and that the Lord’s day is the seventh day, or the Sabbath. We would further remark that Jesus, speaking in A. D. 31, and describing scenes which were to take place in A. D. 70, only 26 years before the Revelation was written, cautioned his disciples in reference to the Sabbath (Matt. 24:20), and said not a word about the first day being sacred; and we would call attention to the fact that in the Gospel of John, which critics acknowledge to have been written after the book of Revelation was written, whenever John has occasion to mention the first day of the week, as he did in describing the events connected with Christ’s resurrection, he always called it the first day of the week, and nothing more; while he invariably spoke of the seventh day as the Sabbath.
Again we quote: “Honest Christians who are well taught, drink from the New Testament Sabbatic stream nearer the fountain; namely, above, and not below the point where the beast, the false489prophet, and the scarlet-dressed harlot reinstituted Babylonianism, etc.”
A very pretty comparison, with which we fully concur. “Honest Christians” drink above a certain point. Very good. Where is that point? We may not agree with the writer as to the exact place where we shall drive the stake, and say, “All above this point is clear, and all below is turbid and polluted;” but as the writer uses the term “New Testament Sabbatic stream,” we shall, with his apparent consent, drive our stake where the inspired writers of the Scriptures cease to speak, and we shall say that above this point all is clear. Paul said the “mystery of iniquity” worked in his day, and this was the beginning of the “scarlet-colored harlot.” Outside of apostolic teaching the stream was beginning to be polluted then. We must not drink below this point unless we want to drink from the polluted channels of thought which developed into the “man of sin.” As Sunday observance cannot be found in the “New Testament Sabbatic stream,” it must have had its origin in that lower stream along whose banks so many vile and noxious weeds originated. We prefer the clear stream, and would kindly invite the author of this suggestive comparison to take his next draught higher up!
“Undoubtedly ‘numerous’ persons who observe the first day of the week as the Sabbath are ignorant how to controvert the claims of seventh-day Sabbatarians, even as many seventh-dayites work on the seventh day and go to church on the Lord’s day, in communities where the Lord’s day is observed by other professed Christians. For now ‘we know’ only ‘in part,’ and ‘blessed is he that condemneth not himself in that thing which he alloweth.’”
The statement, wedged into the middle of the above paragraph, and which has no relation to what precedes or follows it, that seventh-day people “work on the seventh day and go to church on the Lord’s day,” by which Sunday is meant, is simply a figment of the imagination; and why he made it at all, and especially where he did, is more than we can understand. Taking out this untruthful and irrelevant sentence, this is what he says: “Undoubtedly numerous persons observe the first day of the week who are ignorant how to controvert the claims of Sabbatarians, . . . for now we know only in part.” The absolute truthfulness of the above statement has been painfully apparent to us for a long time, and we have never realized it more than immediately after perusing the positions we are now reviewing. But why should people be so ignorant? The Scriptures are able to make us “wise unto salvation.” Those who keep God’s law are not ignorant. Says the psalmist, “I understand more than the ancients, because I keep thy precepts.” Those who go not to the Scriptures for knowledge, but drink from that lower stream, are wise in tradition, but not wise unto salvation. The things of which Paul says we know only in part, were not of moral duty.
“If the apostles of Christ, and their successors, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, quietly celebrated Christian worship on the first day of the week, and only went to seventh-day assemblies as Jews, or for the purpose of preaching the gospel to Jews, as seems to be the case, then we are justified in believing that the Lord Jesus intended that a change in Sabbath observance should occur.”
Let us analyze the above statement. “We are justified in believing that the Lord Jesus intended that a change in Sabbath observance should occur.” Upon what grounds? The whole statement rests upon an “if” and a “seems to be,” but where is the proof that they did so? There is none or he would give us something better than an “if” and a “seems so.” This being the case, we would ask, if they did not, what then? Then there is nothing for this Sunday argument to do but “quietly” to expire.
“The Jewish mode of Sabbath observance was shattered into fragments by the Saviour, both in his own conduct and in the acts which he commanded and defended in his disciples.”
Suppose the Jewish mode of Sabbath observance was shattered by Christ, this would not destroy the Sabbath, which does not and never did rest on “Jewish mode.” Jesus also shattered the mode of keeping the sixth and seventh commandments, but the commandments themselves were not impaired. Jesus certainly kept the Sabbath as it was binding then, or else he was a sinner. The disciples kept the Sabbath, not according to the “Jewish mode,” but “according to the commandment.” Luke 23:56. Baptists shatter the mode of baptism as practiced by some other denominations of Christians, but they do not destroy the ordinance. On the contrary they are trying to preserve it in its purity.
“The first day of the week thus observed was called the ‘Lord’s day,’ by Ignatius, A. D. 101; by Pliny, a ‘stated day.’ In ‘Teaching of the Apostles,’ about A. D. 140, it is called the Lord’s (day understood).”
That John called the first day of the week the Lord’s day is pure assumption. The term first day of the week is not in the book of Revelation at all. The so-called letters of Ignatius were not found till the sixteenth century. Eight of them were at once pronounced to be spurious, and the others have always been held in doubt. No one ever quotes from them to prove any doctrine, but those who cannot find proof anywhere else. Dr. Killen says of them, “They are the last shifts of a grave imposture.” But even allowing them to be genuine, the expression “Lord’s day” is not found in the original. The term used is the “Lord’s life.” (See Cyc. Bib. Lit., Art. “Lord’s Day.”) Pliny speaks of a stated day, but he does not say what day it was. No one knows who wrote the “Teaching of the Apostles.” The apostles did not write it. Our friend is again drinking too far down the stream. The “Acts of the Apostles,” and their letters as recorded in the New Testament, are the only authorized apostolic teaching.
“The seventh day of God’s great creation week was, of course, if we make each a day of twenty-four hours, the first day of man’s week. This was his rest, or Sabbath day. The greater part of the nations, among whom the Jews were anciently planted and scattered, kept that first day as their sacred day. It was Sunday.”
The seventh day of the creation week was not the first day of man’s week. Man was created on the sixth day. That was the first day of his life. Man did not establish the week. It was already established when man was created. The Sabbath was related to God’s work of creation as a whole. Adam had no more right to fix the day of the week in relation to his creation than every other person has. Adam took the week where he found it, and all mankind have done the same thing. The fact that the heathen nations kept Sunday furnishes no “scripture” for its observance. Sunday was Baal’s day; and keeping Sunday was worshiping Baal. The above argument proceeds on the hypothesis that the heathen nations were right, and the people of God were wrong. The Sinaitic Sabbath was the Sabbath of creation; for to creation reference is made in the law itself. The article concludes thus:—
“Therefore it comes to pass that we as Christians do constantly hallow as Sabbath, or sacred rest and worship, the first day of the first Adam in the first creation, and the first day of the second Adam in the new creation, and call it the Lord’s day.”
We have shown that the first day of the first Adam was really the sixth day of the week; for man was created on that day. Adam must have been a man of extraordinary ability to jump from the sixth day clear over the Sabbath into the first day of the next week for his first day! But even if he could perform such an acrobatic feat, it would not change the day of the Sabbath which was established by God in relation to his work of creation, and not in reference to the particular time of the creation of man. The second Adam has left no command or example for observing any other day than the one ordained in the fourth commandment; and as it is utterly impossible for any man, or all of them together, to hallow a Sabbath, the Sabbath specifically ordained by God is all the Sabbath there is. A Sabbath built upon some supposed foundation will surely be built upon sand. We shall do right if we do what God has commanded in his word. That word sets apart the seventh day for the Sabbath. This is a “Scripture basis.” Our author starts out to find “what Scripture basis seventh-day Christians have to stand upon,” but makes no attempt to find it, although the Bible is full of it; but instead, he allows himself to be diverted from his purpose, and starts out upon the fruitless task of finding a “Scripture basis” for the keeping of the first day, and is only able to find some unscriptural and fraudulent man-made reasons.
He has acted with precisely the same amount of wisdom that a man would who, starting out in the autumn to find some apples, turns his back upon the orchard, and plunges into a wild and inextricable thicket of wild mountain brush and brake. There we are compelled to leave him.