HEARING AT THE IOWA LEGISLATURE

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 12, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 15.

Read the full edition

HEARING AT THE IOWA LEGISLATURE.

In harmony with the concerted effort that has been put forth in every State legislature in session this season, which is but the outgrowth of a planned effort in this direction, the friends of Sunday-closing began almost on the opening day to influence the present sitting of the Iowa Legislature some way to place itself on record as in sympathy with the effort of religious people to secure the closing of the World's Fair on Sunday.
Three or four different forms of petitions have been presented, almost wholly, as was explained at the hearing, by the religious element of the State. One asked that the State appropriation be made contingent on Sunday closing of the gates; another wished only the Iowa exhibit closed, while another, and perhaps the principle one, asked for the passage of a resolution memorializing the Columbian commission to close the gates of the Fair on Sunday, without any reference, whatever, to the appropriation. It was offered by Representative Wilson, and reads as follows:—
Whereas, It has been proposed to open the doors of the Columbian Exposition in 1893, upon the Sabbath-day, contrary to the honorable custom of our nation and in direct violation of the statutes of the State of Illinois, within the borders of which it is held, and also in violation of the laws of almost every other State in the Union; and,—
Whereas, The preservation of the Sabbath as a day of rest, is necessary, not only for the well-being of the church, which gives us our prized name of a Christian nation; but also for the stability of the State, for the physical welfare of the people and for the preservation of the rights and interests of the working men; and,—
Whereas, The proposed action would be a long step toward permanent disregard of the Sabbath as a day of rest; therefore,—
Be it Resolved by the General Assembly of the State of Iowa, Sec. 1, That we respectfully petition the commissioners of the Exposition to keep the doors closed upon the first day of the week, commonly called the Sabbath.
SEC. 2, That a copy of these resolutions be sent to the commissioners.
All these resolutions and petitions were referred to a committee of nine of the members of the legislature, appointed to consider them in common with others. When it was learned that there was a probability of their being called up for action, the writer secured an interview with the chairman and other members of the committee, and presented to them his ideas of this sort of legislation, and after talking the matter over, Dr. Young, the chairman, kindly consented to give a representative of the Religious Liberty Association a hearing before the committee some time previous to its being called up for final disposal, and said he would notify us of the date.
The hearing was asked for on Wednesday, March 16, and we were notified to appear, but we informed the committee that our representative, Elder A. T. Jones, whom we desired to have speak before the committee, was then in another State, and would not be here until the following Monday. So the chairman secured the postponement of the consideration of the resolution till a later date, and appointed Tuesday, March 22, as the date of the hearing. The committee were all present, and together with a few of our brethren, composed the audience, which met in one of the committee rooms. Quite a little time was taken up in transacting routine work before the hearing was reached, and there was but half an hour allotted to Elder Jones in which to present what he had to say. But, short as the time was, he showed conclusively that the proposed action was wholly beyond the jurisdiction of the legislature; as according to the first article of the State constitution, the Iowa Legislature had no right to pass any laws or take any steps that would favor or in any way connect with religion; that this same reason applied with equal force to similar action by any State legislature; for every State constitution has a like clause, all of which were derived from that memorable clause in the national Constitution prohibiting Congress from making any law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. Then to make the statements clearer, he reviewed the history of that clause, showed how it came to be placed in the national Constitution, and what was the real intent of its framers.
The hearing was cut short before the full development of the points which Elder Jones designed to get before the committee, but the speech was listened to apparently with much interest, and elicited frequent interrogations, so much so that at one time the chairman rapped on the table and said: “Here, gentlemen, we gave this man a half hour, but we are taking all the time,” whereupon one of the members immediately spoke up, “We'll give him more time, then; we want to know about this matter.”
One asked the question whether the speaker did not think that the interests of the church demanded legislative action in closing the gates of the Exposition on Sunday. “No,” said Elder Jones, “Christ says the gates of hell shall not prevail against the church. How, then, can the gates of the Columbian Exposition affect it?”
The question was asked whether the commissioners had any right to shut away those who wanted to go to the Fair on Sunday in response to a petition from those who did not want to go, and the answer was, “Assuredly not. Those who do not care to go, can stay away, and those who want to go can do so without any interference to those who do not want to go; for the going or remaining away is wholly an individual matter.”
Then it was suggested by one of the committee that in view of the fact that the Exposition was an international affair, not a State or even a national thing, it would certainly be unjust to foreign exhibitors who do not regard the day as they would thus be required to do, as long as they were in part at least contributory to its success.
Another query was raised as to whether or not the Seventh-day people were petitioning for the opening of the gates, to which it was replied that they are not; that their opposition is to the gate's being closed on Sunday by legislative action; which, as they hold, is a question wholly outside the jurisdiction of civil law, as it is contrary to the Constitution of the United States and of every State in the Union. The idea was also developed that to close the gates on Sunday and compel the people to remain away, would not advance the interests of Sabbath-keeping; for if the day was not regarded to the Lord, it was not regarded at all; that if a man did not care to go to the Exposition because of regarding the day to the Lord, he was not compelled to; so if a man did not regard Sunday as unto the Lord, he should not be compelled to show the day deference out of respect to the Columbian Exposition.
A friend of the bill soberly inquired whether it was not right to have laws to compel people to keep the Sabbath, and the answer was that it was not right in any sense; that it was simply to compel religious observance, and the State has no right to enact laws with respect to religion and the enforcement of religious observances. Upon this it was observed by certain of the committee that if the State could not legislate upon religion, then we might as well abolish all our moral laws. Quite a number of other interesting points were brought out, but these are sufficient to show the drift of the minds of the committee.
After the hearing was passed, several of the members remained to talk further concerning the question, one of them purchased a copy of “Two Republics,” and promised to bring it to the notice of other members. As we were leaving the room, another one said: “That committee has something to think over now that they have not had before.” Another one said: “I don't believe this question of Sunday-closing of the World's Fair will be called up at all at this session now.”
He further said: “The facts are, we have been besieged by the religious element of our constituency for closing the Capitol building on Sunday, shutting off the Sunday pay of the employees, action against Sunday newspapers, until life is pretty near a burden.”
The question of the State appropriation to the World's Fair was called up the following Friday, and passed, but the Sunday clause was left entirely out, and we are also told that the Sunday-rest resolutions and petitions are forever killed; so take it all in all, the friends of religious liberty feel that the hearing had its effect, and are glad for the effort. Elder Jones the next day visited Governor Boise, presented him with a copy of his late work, which was gratefully accepted, and was asked for a further interview. It will be recalled that the governor had a little experience during his late campaign in the way the religious element of the State undertook to defeat his re-election and dictate what should be the policy of the governor. In his inaugural he referred to religious interference at some length, and his statements were Jeffersonian, pure, and simple.
W. E. CONNELL.