OVERSHOT THE MARK

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 17, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 20.

Read the full edition

OVERSHOT THE MARK.

The first amendment to the Constitution declares “the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and petition the government for redress of grievances.” This provision was a good one; it allows the humblest citizen to be heard, and the government is bound to listen to his complaint and to redress his grievance if he has any. Probably there never was a time since the Constitution was ratified, when the privilege of petitioning Congress was exercised so freely as at the present time. Those good but misguided people who see great danger to morality and religion in the opening the World's Fair on Sunday, have undertaken to flood Congress with “machine petitions” that the Fair shall be closed on Sunday.
But in their eagerness to accomplish their purpose, they have far exceeded the bounds of the constitutional right to petition, and have assumed the right to couple their petitions with a threat. That is to say, their “machine petitions,” which are gotten up especially for the purpose, have a clause declaring that unless the senators and representatives, whose constituents they are, shall vote to close the Fair on Sunday, they will withdraw their patronage from them at the polls, and thus of course prevent their re-election. The following is the exact wording of a resolution which accompanies each petition:—
“Resolved, that we do hereby pledge ourselves and each other that we will from this time henceforth, refuse to vote or support for any office or position of trust, any member of Congress, either senator or representative, who shall vote for any further aid of any kind to the World's Fair, except it be on the conditions named in these resolutions.”
In the insertion of the above resolution in the petitions sent to Congress, they have overshot the mark; as the threat completely nullifies the petition. Such documents cannot be counted as petitions, but as threats. To ask for a dollar, at the same time enforcing the demand with a loaded pistol, changes a beggar into a robber. This is a good illustration of the domineering spirit which has apparently seized upon the American clergy. They threaten congressmen that they will not support them at the elections, and the commissioners that they will not patronize the Fair, unless they comply with their wishes, and bring the whole people under the control of the church. Of their action in this case, the Detroit Tribune of May 11, says:—
“Any legislation procured under duress would be easily demonstrated to be unlawful and therefore unconstitutional. In other words, it would be no legislation whatever.”
Senator Vest has declared that he will not pay any attention to such petitions, and it would seem as though every senator who has any self-respect would take the same position. M. E. K.