SHALL WE HAVE CHURCH AND STATE UNITED?
By M. E. K.
There is no more noteworthy sign of the times than the common practice of late of speaking of the Christian people of this country as the church, or the Church in America. No particular church is meant, but at the same time there is a definite meaning to the words. Christianity in general is meant, especially those phases of it which are seen in the leading religious bodies. Joseph Cook has been reported as saying that he was opposed to a union of Church and State in this country, but he was in favor of a union between Christianity and the State. This is simply a distinction without a difference. The church is the living exponent of Christianity. If there was no Christianity, there could be no church. How could Christianity come into contact with the State but through the Church? The thing would be impossible. But as true Christianity is entirely opposed to a union of itself with the State, it therefore follows that any union of that nature cannot be a union of Christianity, or of the Church with the State, but only a union of that which purports to be Christianity or the Church with the State. We know from historical facts that the first union of the Church with the State was accomplished in the days of Constantine, and that the organization then claiming to be the church was foretold by Paul under the expressive title of “The Mystery of Iniquity,” the first steps toward which were being taken even in his time. National churches are established in all the Christian countries of the Old World, and in many of the New, and in every country where they exist they are a curse and a damage to the people. The countries thus shackled to the dead forms of Christianity known as the State or national church, have made some degree of progress toward religious liberty; but that progress has been made in spite of the national churches, and not at all with their full consent and co-operation. They have advanced as far as toleration, and that is just as far toward religious liberty as it is possible for a national church to go. The very existence of a national church precludes the possibility of such a condition as true religious liberty. And even religious liberty in this restricted sense is a product of American thought, declaring liberty of conscience as well as the rights of the people, as opposed to the tyranny of kings. This spiritual and civic freedom so wisely guaranteed to us by the Constitution, has been the cause of our unexampled growth. This country has never been entirely free, however, from ecclesiastical bigots who would gladly forge again the fetters of church domination, which our fathers would not bear. In late years this spirit has made rapid growth. They have learned the futility of one denomination of Christians trying to get the control of the government; and as combines and trusts are the order of the day, the church people are about to adopt this plan and organize a religious, or more properly, an irreligious trust. Thus will a national church be born on American soil, and the religious people of the country will feel as did the Israelites when they made Saul king—that now they are like the nations around them. It should also be remembered that it may not be necessary for the Church and State to enter into a formal compact in order to form a union of Church and State. The traditions of this country are so strong against such a course that it probably will never be done, but precisely the same results may be achieved in another way. The union may exist in sufficient strength to become a powerful factor in this country, and still not have an open, avowed existence. When the representatives of the people of this country, out of deference to the leading denominations of Christians, shall be induced to legislate in directions harmonizing with the wishes and purposes of these bodies, and upon subjects which pertain wholly to religious matters, church ordinances, etc.; and in return for this service rendered them, the politicians, who as representatives of the people, vote upon these measures in Congress, expect to receive the cordial support of those bodies whose bidding they have done, to continue them in their office as legislators, will there not be in such a tacit acknowledgment of the mutual dependent relations of the Church and the State a collusion sufficient to warrant the statement that this would constitute a union of Church and State in this country? Just such a work as we have above outlined is now taking place right before our eyes in the halls of Congress. The churches, or more correctly, the church, for they are acting in harmony, is bringing upon the members of Congress a mighty influence to cause them by a Sunday-closing clause in the World’s Fair appropriation bill, to establish the church holiday of Sunday by the highest legislative assembly in this country. There is no question that many of the senators and representatives, who themselves see clearly this departure from the foundation principles upon which our government was established, are so eager to retain their positions, and so fearful of losing the votes of the church people, who, with much the same spirit as the crusaders, are trying, as they express it, to “take this country for God,” that they do not dare to vote according to their honest convictions in the matter. There are some senators, however, we are glad to say, who can see the danger, and are independent enough to stand stiffly against this encroachment upon the rights of the people. Such a man is Senator Morgan of Alabama, who in speaking upon this point declared:— “To-day there is attempted a union of Church and State. Who but the church makes the demand? Not one church, but many churches. Not only, Mr. President, is it the union of Church and State, but it is an attempted union of politics and religion.” “Legislation in England, in Germany, in the United States, and elsewhere for the protection of the Puritanic sentiment in respect to the observance of the Sabbath, has been attended with the cruelties of the Inquisition, and when we got Church and State divorced in this country, we accomplished for our people that highest possible quality of liberty to be found in our organic institutions, and I am for preserving it. I am opposed to the union of Church and State.” “What are you going to do with that large body of Christians who, by reason, first of your law, and second, of their own conscientious convictions, will be obliged in Chicago to keep two days in the week, one on account of their own conviction, and one on account of your statutory enactment? You do them a wrong.”—Congressional Record of July 13, 14. Senators Vest of Missouri, and Daniels of Virginia, ably supported Mr. Morgan. Senator Sherman is also understood as opposed to any legislation committing the government to religious legislation. The people of this country are not aware of the fact that Congress at one stroke may undo the work of an age, and the act when done, at first may have such a harmless look that but few will detect the danger lurking in it. In spite of the efforts of these clear-minded champions of the principles of religious liberty and of the Constitution, the World’s Fair appropriation bill has passed the Senate with this Sunday-closing incubus tacked to it. It must now go before the House of Representatives. We cannot tell what that body will do; but there is no doubt that the same churchly influence will be brought to bear upon the House that has been so effectual in the Senate. If it passes the House, the President’s signature, or his failure to sign it for ten days, will make the appropriation and all its conditions valid. Even then the commissioners may refuse the money upon such conditions . The commissioners feel that there is far more hypocrisy than morality in the course the Senate has taken. Senators spend Sundays as they please. If they go to church in the morning, they go to ride in the afternoon. They drink wine and champagne in the Senate bar-room week days, and out of their own bottles Sundays. They give their consent to many irregular proceedings to drain the public treasury, and fill their own pockets; then with a sudden and violent wrench of virtue and morality, they undermine the principles of the Constitution, and declare that the visitor at the World’s Fair must spend Sunday in his heated and perhaps overcrowded apartments, the street, saloon, or go to church, if he can get in, to hear the Rev. Dr. Bogus preach on the duty of the Christian church to the State. Of course if he goes to church, he should be sure to take his pocket-book along, so as to be able to contribute liberally to the cause which has deprived him of his rightful privilege of spending Sunday in Jackson Park. If this spirit thus manifested is not the spirit of pharisaism rebuked by Christ, we do not know what it is. They bind grievous burdens and lay them on men’s shoulders, but they themselves will not touch them with one of their fingers. We wish to emphasize the fact that the danger that this country will become irreligious is not one half so great as the danger is that it will become a religious despotism; for history repeats itself, and religious despotism has been the order of history for more than a thousand years, and the steps which this country is now taking in her legislative halls show an astonishing likeness to the initial steps which in the fourth century brought about that deplorable union of the Church and the State, against which the fathers of the American Republic so successfully combated. Shall we remain true to the principles which Washington, Jefferson, and Madison established and sustained, or shall we permit the American Republic, with so noble a birth, such a generous endowment of resources, such an exalted place in history, and such an open door for all that constitutes national progress, to be diverted from those God-given principles of religious liberty which have been the secret of her success, at the imperious demands of a clergy who would substitute compulsion for conversion?—M. E. K., in Battle Creek Moon.