A FALSE CHARGE

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 14, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 24.

Read the full edition

A FALSE CHARGE.

THE Christian Herald of May 12, 1892, publishes the following paragraph, which virtually endeavors to make a Scripture doctrine bear the responsibility of a tremendous error:—
“The Watchman points the intimate connection between the prevalence of crime and the rejection of the more solemn views of the future life. It thinks the lessening of the sense of the sacredness of life to be a natural outcome of low views of future retribution, and the absence of the sense of responsibility to a divine judgment. This is worth thinking about. If so, it furnishes a strong presumptive argument against any views of future retribution which tend to confirm the soul in indifference to the issues of the future life. Does not the doctrine of annihilation or extinction produce just this effect?”
That which is more responsible than anything else for skepticism, and consequently for a loose state of morality among the people, is the view of future retribution taught by popular theology, from which sound reason and the better feelings of every man’s heart revolt with abhorrence. A view which men cannot believe will not influence them. And discarding the view of eternal conscious misery for the sins of a brief life here, and not knowing the better teachings of the Scriptures on this point, they turn against the Bible, throw off restraint, and consequently give free rein to the leadings of the carnal mind. “Does not the doctrine of annihilation,” says the Herald, “produce just this result?” Well, does it? If it does, facts can be produced to show it. But where are the facts? Does the Scripture doctrine of the utter loss of life because of sin, lead men to sin? Let the criminals be brought forward, if such can be found, who will claim, either directly or by implication, that they are led into, or encouraged in, their evil course by the doctrine of the second death, as set forth in the Scriptures. Until this can be done, let such insinuations as are contained in the foregoing paragraph never be found upon the lips of candid men. The facts will be found just the opposite. Multitudes have been rescued by the Bible view from the infidelity into which the teachings of popular theology had thrown them.