AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 37., September 13, 1892

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

236.—ALL THINGS COMMON. ACTS 2:44.

Did the primitive church at Jerusalem establish a community of goods (Acts 2:44, 45; 4:32-35), or does it mean when it says that they sold their possessions and had all things common, that they simply created a poor fund for the needy? J. C. S.

Answer.—It does not appear from the record that they established, in the strict sense of the word, a community of goods, that is, to the degree of putting all their possessions into a common fund, and all drawing their entire living from the same. But under the exigencies of the case, it was necessary that something be done immediately for those who were, or who would be, brought into destitute circumstances by their acceptance of the gospel; for the hatred of Jews against believers would lead them to treat them with great opposition, excluding them from their society, and embarrassing them in every way possible in their temporal matters. Besides, those who were called to devote their whole time to the promulgation of the truth of the gospel would need immediate provision for their support. Hence those who possessed property sold it and made provision for those in need.

With the meaning of the expression “all things common” the Jews were doubtless familiar; for it is said that in every great festival in Jerusalem none who came in were required to hire houses, but these were furnished gratis, so also were such utensils as they might have occasion to use. In other words, everything of this kind was held to be for their common use. But in the case of the disciples, money was needed besides, and was raised in the way stated.

There was nothing compulsory about the matter, as we learn from the case of Ananias and Sapphira. They were not obliged to sell their possession in the first place, and after it was sold, they could have done with the proceeds whatever they pleased. But when they pretended to devote it all to the cause, while keeping back a part of it for their own selfish use, thus seeking to get credit for more than they did, they fell into condemnation.

The arrangement brought to view in the text did not continue long, as is evident from the fact that the apostle afterward gave directions about taking up collections for the poor saints at Jerusalem.p. 585

But if there had been strictly a community of goods, this distinction of rich and poor would not have existed, as one would have been possessed of just as much as another. And besides, none were allowed to help themselves indiscriminately to whatever they liked, but regularly-constituted authorities distributed it to each one as circumstances might require. This seems to have been done, first, by the apostles; afterward, by seven men chosen for that purpose. Acts 6:1-4.

237.—LEST THEY SHOULD SEE. MARK 4:11, 12.

Please explain Mark 4:11, 12. The language of the text would seem to imply that the Saviour spoke in parables so that the people could not understand him, because he feared they would be converted and forgiven, and so be saved. Yet I cannot believe that this is the meaning; for the Scriptures teach that God is not willing that any should perish, but that all should be saved. W. D. P.

Ans.—The Saviour does not propose to instruct or redeem us without our co-operation. So, in teaching the people, he adopted that method which would lead them to show how much interest they had in the matter. He spoke in parables which it would require some thought and study on their part to understand, but such that the lesson could be easily perceived by any one who had the least desire to be spiritually enlightened. But they chose rather to remain in a gross and sensual condition, and to have darkness rather than light. And Christ said that he that doeth evil will not come to the light “lest his deeds should be reproved.” Matthew’s record of this parable is more full. Matt. 13:13-15: “Therefore speak I to them in parables: because they seeing see not; and hearing they hear not, neither do they understand. And in them is fulfilled the prophecy of Esaias, which saith, By hearing ye shall hear, and shall not understand; and seeing ye shall see, and shall not perceive: for this people’s heart is waxed gross, and their ears are dull of hearing, and their eyes they have closed; lest at any time they should see with their eyes, and hear with their ears, and should understand with their heart, and should be converted, and I should heal them.” This places the responsibility with themselves, where it belongs. “Their eyes they have closed,” etc.

238.—RESURRECTION OF THE WICKED.

It is claimed by some, from such texts as Ps. 49:19, Isa. 26:14, Prov. 21:16, and Jer. 51:57, that the wicked dead will never have a resurrection. What is the meaning of these passages? H. J. S.

Ans.—Isolated texts should never be interpreted to conflict with great principles uniformly taught in the Scriptures. The plan of salvation itself involves as a necessary condition that all men shall be released from the death they die in Adam, and the Scriptures everywhere teach that the wicked shall give an account of their deeds in the judgment. To do this, they must be raised to life. To rightly interpret a writer’s language, we must take into account the subject he has in mind. Frequently the sacred writers refer only to the future eternal life of the righteous, and when, in such a connection, they say that the wicked shall not see life, they have reference to that kind of life only. But this does not contradict the fact that sinners will be raised to give account of their deeds, and perish in the second death. In this way we may understand such passages as John 3:36; Ps. 49:19. Isaiah in the passage cited seems to refer to the false gods of the heathen; Prov. 21:16 to a spiritual condition in this life, like Eph. 2:1, and Jer. 51:57 is simply contrasting the long sleep of death with the temporary slumber of drunkenness. See the subject of the resurrection of the unjust fully discussed in the pamphlet on that subject published at this Office.

239.—PERFECTED FOREVER. HEB. 10:14.

Will you please explain Heb. 10:14-17? Who are the sanctified? How were they made perfect? And what sins and iniquities are to be remembered no more? J. R. B.

Ans.—The offering referred to, is the offering of Christ upon the cross. In that there was provision for the forgiveness of sin and for crowning with eternal heavenly perfection all those who will give themselves to the service of God, and accept these offers of his grace. The word “sanctified” here means those who will, and do, separate themselves and consecrate themselves to the service of God. The sins and iniquities are the sins of those who will avail themselves of the provisions and privileges of the new covenant. And remission means the final putting away and blotting out of the sins of the people of God. And when that is done, his people will be forever perfected in the kingdom of God, and there will then be no more offerings for sin.

240.—GOG AND MAGOG. EZEKIEL 38.

Please give a brief explanation of Ezekiel, chapters 38 and 39, especially 39:8-16. F. P.

Ans.—Many things have been offered by the Lord to the children of men in different ages of the world, on certain conditions to be fulfilled on their part. But men not complying with the conditions, the promises were never fulfilled. The prophecy of the 38th and 39th chapters of Ezekiel, seems to be one of this nature. It was a conditional prophecy, but the conditions never having been complied with, it was never fulfilled. Under different conditions, the real design of the prophecy, that is, the end had in view, will be accomplished at the end of the thousand years, where Gog and Magog again appear, as brought to view in Rev. 20:8.