THE INCOME TAX

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 15, 1895

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 72, No. 3.

Read the full edition

THE INCOME TAX.

Now that the income tax which Congress has seen fit to impose upon every one whose income is above a certain sum per annum is about to be enforced, and the blanks which are to be filled out by those who will come within the provisions of the law are now being distributed to the inspectors of the internal revenue, it may be well to take note of the matter so as to be able to understand it. The immediate cause of this law was the necessity of raising a revenue for the support of the government. The hard times and high tariffs caused a falling off in the amount of goods bought in other countries. This decreased the amount of duties received by the government, so that now the government is in precisely the same condition in which men often find themselves,—its expenditures exceed its receipts, and it is steadily going into debt; for issuing bonds is but another name for hiring money.
Since duties on imports, or indirect taxation, failed to furnish enough money for the expenses of the government, Congress has resorted to direct taxation in the form of an income tax.
This tax is levied only upon those whose net income is $4000 or more annually. Upon those whose income reaches this figure, a tax of two per cent is levied. It will be seen that this does not touch poor people at all, whereas duties on imports tax the consumer no matter what his financial condition may be. This may please the poor, but what good reason is there why every citizen, no matter what his financial condition may be, should not, according to his means, bear his share in the financial support of the government.
Many feel in this way, and from the very fact that the law does not affect all equally, they declare that it is unjust; and one, John G. Moore, a New York City broker, proposes to test the constitutionality of the income tax law before the courts of the country. To this end he has presented a petition before the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, asking for an injunction to restrain the commissioner of internal revenue from collecting the income tax. In the petition the following reasons are urged against the law: In taxing corporations, and then again taxing incomes of members or shareholders of these corporations, there is actually a double tax on the same incomes. Another objection is that the majority of citizens are entirely exempt from paying any income tax. Again, aliens residing in this country are made to pay the tax when their income is derived from another country.
It is said that Senator Edmonds, who is regarded as one of the best constitutional lawyers in this country, drew up the petition, and that he will act as senior counsel for Mr. Moore. Others, particularly great corporate bodies, propose to fight the law, but the probability is that the law will stand, and the income tax will be collected, until other means of revenue shall justify Congress in removing the income tax law from among the laws of the country. M. E. K.