SENTIMENTAL EVIDENCE

4%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Mountain View, California · Jul 25, 1906

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 29.

Read the full edition

SENTIMENTAL EVIDENCE.

Commenting on the response to the call for relief of sufferers by the earthquake, the Commoner says:
Confronted by such generosity as this the pessimist must stand silent, and he who constantly insists that the world is growing worse is answered by a million generous acts. Our common humanity is more than a sentiment—it is a fact.
We would not detract one scintilla from the credit due to those who nobly and bravely helped in the great emergency. But to give a universal credit to the world, or even to the United States, for innate generosity because of what a comparatively few have done in this case, is “sentiment” pure and simple. Perhaps not one in a hundred even in California so much as raised a finger in the way of genuine help. If the circumstance of the earthquake and the fire are to be taken as in any way adducing evidence that the world is not growing worse, what meant the necessity for the great aggregation of federal and state troops, and municipal and volunteer police, to keep the poor sufferers from being robbed and murdered? Why was it necessary for those who had food and other necessaries for sale to be officially enjoined, and otherwise compelled, not to charge exorbitant prices? It was evident that extortion would have been the order of the day, on the part of merchants and house owners, and those who had their services for hire, but for the appeals and orders of influential men. Armed protection and enforced generosity are not necessary under any conditions when men are growing better, especially when the calls of hunger and nakedness and exposure are filling the air.
What about the great lack of generosity, the absolute oppression of the poor, the general inclination to take advantage wherever opportunity opened, of which dire complaint has long been made from pulpit, press, and rostrum? And certain political journals have been the loudest in the pessimistic cry, if it is to be called by that name. So far as the money response is concerned, the bulk of it has come from sources that have been most bitterly denounced. Surely the generosity that has to be stimulated by disaster, that is not moved until a general sentiment is forced by the disrupted elements, is not the kind to boast of as evidence that the world is better at heart.
A generosity that would equalize the condition of mortals in the matter of earth’s common resources, and labor to that end from voluntary impulse in ordinary times, in ordinary business and social life, would better prove that the world is growing better. The spirit that feeds the poor and clothes the naked and ministers to the afflicted, and deals honestly and liberally at all times with all classes, is the true test of generosity. A general spirit of this character would better prove a generally enhanced moral condition.
Such evidences as are being presented to show that the world is growing better are not at all complimentary. They rather indicate that men’s consciences must be frightened and their nerves racked by some over-awing phenomena of nature in order to call out any sentiment of sympathy and generosity at all. They emphasize, rather than rebut, the sure testimony of Scripture, that “in the last days perilous times shall come. For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good, traitors, heady, high-minded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God, having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof.”
Such is God’s prophetic picture of the general conditions of our time, and we know that it is a true one, however much men may try to cover it. It does not say that there is no generosity in the world at all, or that all men are hardened against real sympathy for the suffering and the needy. But it does say and mean just what it says, and it is due to the world that it be kept before the people. Be not deceived; the whole world, or even the whole nation, will not be accredited with generosity because a few thousand of them are moved to help the sufferers in a great disaster. Do not forget that where dollars are going to San Francisco for charity, thousands are going for profit. Do not forget that men of business are far more concerned as to what they can make out of the situation—even to profit by the disaster—than they are to assist somebody that is in need.
Let us give due credit to every one who so much as expressed a word of sympathy for the unfortunate, but let us not carry it to the extreme of covering from the world God’s faithful testimony as to its true condition. There can be no worse robbery of the poor than this.

“SABBATH DESECRATION.”

[From the Indianapolis Star.]
I was much interested in the article entitled, “Baptist Ministers on Sabbath Desecration,” which appeared in the Star recently.
The committee appointed to draft resolutions touching this question, after expressing its disapproval of the recent violation of Sunday laws, also expresses a lack of confidence in the promises or sincerity of the city authorities. Then the report says:
“We are compelled to entertain the belief that the only reasonable plan for us to pursue, is to appeal to the consciences of Christian people. . . . It is scarcely possible to obtain moral reform . . . by confiding in the official or personal integrity of unreliable and immoral people.”
It seems strange that every Christian minister should not have understood and recognized this everlasting Gospel principle, and the truthfulness of the above statement, and that moral reforms are not brought about through immoral persons; and all Christian ministers ought to have understood without waiting for immoral people to teach them,
or, in the words of the committee, “are compelled to believe that the only reasonable plan is to appeal to the conscience.” This is God’s plan. This is the Gospel. But alas! many teachers of the Word have forsaken the Gospel way and are appealing to civil rulers to enforce moral duty instead of appealing to the consciences of men.
Where do we hear of Christ or the apostles or prophets appealing to the civil power to enforce Sabbath observance, or any other religious duty? The Gospel was the mighty power and cleaver used by them to gain moral reforms. Paul said, “I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ, for it is the power of God unto salvation,” and knowing the terror of the Lord, he said he persuaded men; he appealed to conscience.
What a different method was used by God’s servants as recorded in His Word, to that adopted by would-be present-day reformers. We read, “For I was ashamed to require of the king a band of soldiers and horsemen to help us against the enemy in the way; because we had spoken unto the king, saying, The band of our God is upon all them for good that seek Him; but His power and His wrath is against all them that forsake Him. So we fasted and besought our God for this; and He was entreated of us.” Ezra 8:22, 23.
If there was more praying and fasting, and more seeking of God for the power of the Gospel, and an entire separation of religion and the civil power, methinks there would be a reform affected that would not simply terrorize people for fear of the penalties of civil law, but their consciences would be reached, and their fear would be of displeasing God.
Why should we expect civil rulers to attempt moral reform, when the civil law was not instituted to rule in moral matters? Ours is a civil government to rule in civil matters and deal with crime. God’s government is a moral government that deals with morals and punishes for sin. The state does not punish a man for sin, but for crime; and when Christians try to compel civil rulers, to enforce morality, or incorporate Christian laws, institutions,
or usages into the civil law, they are going outside of the limit of civil power; and this is why it is so hard to enforce the law. The state must adopt the Inquisition if it enters into the realm of the enforcement of religious institutions.
I heartily agree with the closing words of the Baptist committee’s report: “We believe this deplorable Sabbath desecration will never be restrained until Christian people themselves shall exemplify its meaning and condemn its perversion. To them God entrusts its preservation, and not its mayors, councils, or police.” REV. W. J. STONE.
3735 North Capitol Avenue.
Gobbi Building, Healdsburg. This is a typical scene which might be met in every town where the earthquake did any considerable damage, the front wall fallen away, leaving open bedrooms which appear like little doll houses seen on exhibition.
Gobbi Building, Healdsburg. This is a typical scene which might be met in every town where the earthquake did any considerable damage, the front wall fallen away, leaving open bedrooms which appear like little doll houses seen on exhibition.