SUNDAY AND THANKSGIVING DAY

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 13, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 49.

Read the full edition

SUNDAY AND THANKSGIVING DAY.

The Christian Statesman declares that the presidential proclamation of Thanksgiving is a “national recognition, not an enforcement of our national religion.”
If any one should give President Harrison’s last Thanksgiving proclamation a careful reading, with the hope of learning what our national religion is, he would not be any wiser after reading than he was before; for there is nothing in it that Christians, Jews, Mohammedans, or any one who believes in a supreme being could not indorse. Even the conventional phrase, “In the year of our Lord,” as expressed by the letters “A. D.,” is conspicuous by its absence.
Again the Statesman says, “Thanksgiving illustrates the exact position of National Reformers as to the relation our Christian government sustains to the religious aspects of the Sabbath.”
If the above statement be true, and we willingly concede that the observance of Thanksgiving day and the observance of Sunday both alike rest upon nothing better than human authority, and as the Statesman says, they “illustrate the exact position . . . as to the relation our Christian government sustains to the religious aspects of the Sabbath,” then it follows that if the State has power to prohibit common labor on Sunday, making such labor a crime and a misdemeanor, it has also the power to prohibit the same upon Thanksgiving day, and prescribe penalties to be inflicted upon those who disobey! We have no doubt that if our legislators should have the temerity to attempt to compel abstinence from labor on Thanksgiving day, the whole mass of the American people would at once cry out that their civil rights were being ruthlessly invaded; yet this is what they are now doing under the Sunday laws, and the Statesman declares that in their relations to our Christian government Sunday and the national Thanksgiving day occupy the same position! And if this is the case, either cessation from common labor on Thanksgiving should be enforced, or the enforcing of Sunday rest should not be attempted, since, according to the Statesman, they both occupy the same “exact position.”
Really, they do not in law occupy the same position. Thanksgiving day is now set apart by the President and the governors of the different States, as a day of public worship, as far as their authority goes, as truly as Sunday is set apart by the laws of the States for the same purpose; but as neither President nor governor represent the legislative branch of the government, they can affix no penalty to a violation of their command or recommendation, and therefore it is a recommendation without authority. If the advocates of Sunday sacredness would come down to this position, and content themselves with recommending that people should keep Sunday, the day would lose its savage character, as a day associated with fines and penalties, and become as harmless as Thanksgiving day.
Thanksgiving, as it is now observed, has in it but little of the religious element. With the most of people, the “turkey” receives much more attention than the public religious services that may be held that day. But if the position of the Statesman is correct, that our government sustains the same relation to Sunday that it does to Thanksgiving day, and believing as it also does that cessation from labor on Sunday should be enforced by law, the Statesman, to be consistent with itself, must demand that whoever does common work on Thanksgiving day should be arrested and fined. The theory of the Statesman appears to be that men may be made holy by enforced idleness on Sunday, and be made thankful by not being allowed to work on Thanksgiving day; to all of which we beg leave to dissent. M. E. K.