SOLUTION OF THE SUNDAY AND SABBATH QUESTION

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Michigan · Aug 21, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 34.

Read the full edition

SOLUTION OF THE SUNDAY AND SABBATH QUESTION.

BY ELD. J. O. MATTESON.
We present herewith some extracts from a treatise of Bishop A. Grimelund, of Norway, called “Søndagens Historie” (the History of Sunday), and from “Konkordiebogen” (confession of faith by the Lutheran Church). These are both of high authority, and since their truthfulness on the point here presented cannot be doubted, these extracts will be a welcome help to earnest souls who desire and need light on this question.
The Bishop says, in the book mentioned, pages 3 and 4:—
The name Sunday is not found in the Old Testament, neither has the day been placed in any prominent position under the name “the first day of the week.” Nor has the Sunday been appointed as a rest-day by any law until A. D. 321. Its ancient name before Christ, was the day of the sun; yet this name has no connection with the creation of the sun, which took place on the fourth day in the history of creation. In the history of creation, Sunday is placed on the same level as the other days of the week, under the name “the first day.” That this is the same day of the week which in the New Testament is called “the first day of the week,” is seen from the fact that the week of seven days, recognized among Jews and Christians, has been obtained from the history of creation, and received as a division of time ordained by God.
Sunday began the week at the dawn of creation, but the record does not give it any preference before the rest of the days. Nor has Sunday, or “the first day of the week,” been distinguished in the law of Moses or the Jewish festivals. Our Sunday meets us from the beginning unnoticed, quietly and silently. It is somewhat different with the last day of the week, the seventh day. Of this it is said, with evident emphasis (Gen. 2:2, 3): “And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all the work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.”
In these words the Bishop has presented two great truths very clearly: 1. That Sunday, or the first day of the week, has not obtained “any prominent position” in the Bible, but is placed “on the same level with the other days of the week;” and that Sunday has not been “appointed as a rest-day by any law, until A. D. 321;” 2. That the seventh day is the rest-day of God, blessed and sanctified by the great Creator at creation, before the fall.
Concerning the object of the Sabbath, the Bishop says:—
The rest of God had, so to speak, overshadowed the seventh day; and when the Israelites kept that day according to the commandment of God, it was a sign unto them that the Lord was with them, and would make them partakers of his rest. The Sabbath should be a rest-day for the tired body, but it should also be a sign of covenant with God, and the rest of the soul in God. With this double object, the seventh day could not but be a day of rejoicing to the people of Israel, and it is also thus presented in the Holy Scriptures. Num. 10:10; Neh. 8:10, 11.—Søndagens Historie, p. 7.
Thus our Lord Jesus Christ found the Sabbath, when he came and dwelt among his people. He did not come to destroy the law with its commandments, but to fulfill it. Matt. 5:17. . . . The law of the Sabbath was also holy unto him, and he kept both sides of the commandment, both the negative, concerning rest from outward work, and the positive, concerning meeting in “holy convocation” on the seventh day. He never went outside the limits of his own country, but wherever he came on the Sabbath day, he visited the synagogues of the land where the Jews assembled. It is said significantly of him, that he went into the synagogues on the Sabbath, according “as his custom was” (Luke 4:16), and the reading of the Old Testament, which they used, gave him, as a rabbi, an opportunity to connect his gospel with the reading, as an exposition. Mark 1:21, 22; Luke 4:21, 23, 44.—Id. pp. 8, 9.
The first Christians were of Jewish origin, and the first church in Jerusalem was a Jewish Christian church. It followed, as might be expected, the law and Sabbath custom of the Jews. It had of course no express commandment from the Lord to do anything else.—Id. p. 13.
So far, the Bishop follows the history of the Sabbath. It is indeed a pleasure to see how the Sabbath is acknowledged to be a work of God, and to have originated from the word of God, even by those who are not its friends. Jesus kept it, and the first Christians kept it.
This is more than any one can say concerning the Sunday. And it is certainly reasonable to believe that the Spirit of God guided the Christians who were under the personal supervision of the apostles, rather than that church which mingled Christianity with heathenism, and at last became a fallen, persecuting church, wading through rivers of blood. That this church had more light concerning the Sabbath and Sunday than the church which Christ himself, and the apostles, instructed, is certainly a great mistake.
That there is found no commandment in the word of God concerning the change of the Sabbath, the Bishop acknowledges in the following words:—
Yes, all this may be well enough. The resurrection day of our Lord is indeed a commemorative day, which never can be forgotten and passed by in his church. But from this, one might say, It does not follow that we should give up and forsake the Sabbath ordained by God himself, and in creation plainly foreshadowed, or move it unto any other day of the week, although that day is such a commemorative day. To do this, we need just as express a commandment of God by which the former ordinance is abolished; but where do we find such a commandment? It is true that such a commandment is not found.—Id. p. 18.
The Bishop tries indeed, further on in his book, to defend Sunday as an honorable day of commemoration and day of assembling for the church; but this he consequently does according to his own liking, and the ordinances of men, without any foundation in the word of God. The commandment of God is lacking; neither has he found any example from Christ, the apostles, or the first Christians. How it was possible for the Sunday, without all this, to be honored so highly, the Bishop shows very clearly in his book:—
The Sunday obtained of course a somewhat changed position through the edict of the Emperor Constantine, given on March 7, 321, when it was appointed to be a holiday for the whole Christian State. Although the Emperor in this does not expressly have reference to the Christian church, yet this commandment did not only introduce general worship on Sunday, but it also ordained as a civil law, that the day should be a general rest-day. In this edict, which originated before the Emperor had publicly professed Christianity, the day is called the day of the sun (dies solis). This may no doubt be traced to the inclination of the Emperor to unite the worship of the sun with some form of Christianity.—Id. p. 31.
(Concluded next week.)